A Real Pain · 2024
A Real Pain: a small, sharp road trip through grief, guilt and family history
A Real Pain review: Jesse Eisenberg's heritage-tour comedy is brief and bittersweet, carried by a restless Kieran Culkin performance that lingers long after.
Good
Editorial score out of 10
A Real Pain is a modest film in scale and running time, and its modesty is part of its intelligence. Jesse Eisenberg's second feature as director follows two cousins on a heritage tour of Poland and uses that journey to ask awkward questions about inherited trauma, performative grief and what it means to feel pain when your own life is comparatively comfortable. It is funny in a prickly, conversational way and sad in a way that sneaks up rather than announcing itself.
- 7.9
- Editorial score
- #90
- Of 112 movies reviewed
- 2024
- Released
- 90 minutes
- Runtime
Its great asset is Kieran Culkin, whose Benji is the kind of person who lights up a room and then burns it down. The film is at its best whenever it simply lets him loose.
Will Sharpe gives James a gentle, slightly over-rehearsed sincerity that Benji punctures in one of the film's sharpest exchanges.
The journey
The structure is straightforward. David and Benji meet at the airport, join a small group led by James, an earnest British guide played by Will Sharpe, and move through Warsaw, a Lublin cemetery and a visit to the Majdanek concentration camp before heading off on their own to find their grandmother's old house. Eisenberg never turns the tour into a checklist of solemn stops; the travel logistics, hotel rooms and train carriages are as important as the monuments.
One of the film's most provocative threads is Benji's objection to travelling first class through a country where their ancestors were packed into freight cars. It is both a sincere moral point and a way of making everyone around him uncomfortable, and the script keeps that ambiguity alive.

Culkin and Eisenberg
Culkin's performance, which earned wide acclaim and an Academy Award, is a portrait of charisma as a symptom. Benji is magnetic with strangers, blunt with his cousin and unable to sit with his own sadness for long. Culkin makes the quick flips from mischief to fury to tenderness feel entirely natural.
Eisenberg plays David as an anxious, buttoned-up counterweight, and his quiet envy of Benji's ease is well observed. The trouble is that the script gives Benji all the fireworks, so David can seem more like a reaction than a fully realised character. A late dinner scene, in which David finally articulates what his cousin means to him, helps redress the balance.
The group
The supporting ensemble is small but carefully chosen. Jennifer Grey is warm and funny as a recently divorced traveller, and Kurt Egyiawan is quietly moving as a Rwandan genocide survivor who converted to Judaism. Will Sharpe gives James a gentle, slightly over-rehearsed sincerity that Benji punctures in one of the film's sharpest exchanges. These characters widen the film's conversation about who gets to own grief.
Style and sound
Visually, the film is clean and unshowy, relying on natural light and real Polish locations. Its most striking choice is the soundtrack, almost entirely Chopin piano pieces. The music suits the Polish setting and the melancholy mood, but used so continuously it risks flattening the rhythm of scenes, and a sharper sense of silence at key moments might have landed harder. The camp sequence is handled with welcome restraint, without score, and it is all the more powerful for that.
What works
- Kieran Culkin makes Benji charming, exhausting and heartbreaking at once
- Balances humour and historical grief without cheapening either
- A lean 90 minutes with no wasted scenes
- The tour group gives the cousins a funny, humane chorus
What doesn’t
- Eisenberg's David is written more thinly than his cousin
- The Chopin-heavy soundtrack sometimes feels like wallpaper
- Its low-key ending may feel slight to some viewers
Head to head
- Craft
- 7.58.1
- Story
- 7.88.0
- Direction
- 7.68.6
- Performances
- 8.99.2
Anora edges it by 0.5. See them side by side
The verdict
A Real Pain does not reach for grand statements, and some will find its ending too understated. But within its brief running time it manages a delicate balancing act between comedy and grief, anchored by one of the most vivid supporting turns of its year. Its broad critical warmth feels earned. The thinner writing for David and a slightly monotonous musical palette keep it just below excellent, at a solid 7.9.





