Alien: Romulus · 2024
Alien: Romulus is a slick, scary return to basics that leans too hard on nostalgia
Alien: Romulus review: Fede Álvarez delivers tactile terror and a standout David Jonsson turn, but constant franchise callbacks dull this Alien revival's bite.
Good
Editorial score out of 10
After two Ridley Scott prequels that divided audiences with their mythology, Alien: Romulus goes back to the stripped-down template: a small group, a dark ship and something hunting them. Fede Álvarez, who showed his command of tight, nasty suspense in Don't Breathe, delivers a franchise entry that is often genuinely frightening and handsomely made. It was generally received as the strongest Alien film in some years.
- 7.1
- Editorial score
- #109
- Of 112 movies reviewed
- 2024
- Released
- 8.4
- Best at: Craft
The problem is that it cannot stop reminding you of better films. For every fresh idea, there is a line, image or musical cue lifted from earlier entries, and the cumulative effect turns a lean horror film into something closer to a greatest-hits compilation.
The station is claustrophobic and eerily beautiful, and a sequence built around a swarm of facehuggers drawn to body heat is inventively staged.
Setup and characters
The opening on Jackson's Star colony is one of the film's strongest stretches. A place without sunlight, where workers' contracts are extended at the company's whim, gives Rain a clear and sympathetic motive to escape. Cailee Spaeny plays her with a steady, understated determination, and the colony's grim bureaucracy is a nice echo of the franchise's long-running distrust of corporations.
The film's heart, though, is Andy, an older-model synthetic reprogrammed to protect Rain. David Jonsson gives him a stammering, sweet vulnerability early on and then something colder when circumstances change his priorities. It is the most interesting character work in the film. The rest of the young crew are more functional: a hot-headed leader, his pregnant sister, a pilot, a cousin. They exist mainly to make the wrong decisions at the right moments.

Horror and set pieces
When Álvarez focuses on pure suspense, Romulus works very well. The station is claustrophobic and eerily beautiful, and a sequence built around a swarm of facehuggers drawn to body heat is inventively staged. A later scene built around weightlessness and acidic blood is the kind of clever, rule-based action that the series has not delivered in a long time.
The creature effects combine animatronics and puppetry with digital work, and the tactile approach pays off: the monsters feel present in the room. Benjamin Wallfisch's score nods to Jerry Goldsmith without simply copying him, and the sound design is excellent.
The nostalgia problem
The film's biggest weakness is its reliance on familiarity. It borrows famous lines verbatim, restages memorable moments and brings back a face from the original through digital recreation, a choice that attracted considerable criticism for its uncanny appearance. These nods may delight longtime fans, but they undermine the tension, because they invite the audience to recognise references instead of fearing for characters.
The final act also escalates in a way that some found boldly grotesque and others found overwrought. It is certainly memorable, but it tips the tone away from the tight, grounded horror of the first two thirds.
Look and feel
The production design is a real pleasure. Chunky analogue monitors, cassette-era computers and industrial interiors link Romulus convincingly to the 1979 aesthetic. Galo Olivares' cinematography uses darkness and harsh emergency lighting well, and the film's modest scale suits it.
What works
- Practical creature work and sets give the horror real physical weight
- David Jonsson is excellent as the vulnerable synthetic Andy
- Several tense, inventive set pieces, notably a zero-gravity sequence
- Retro-futurist production design matches the 1979 original
What doesn’t
- Constant callbacks and repeated lines feel like franchise box-ticking
- Most of the young crew are indistinct and barely developed
- A digital recreation of a familiar face is distracting
Head to head
- Craft
- 8.48.6
- Story
- 6.27.6
- Direction
- 7.68.7
- Performances
- 7.48.3
Furiosa: A Mad Max Saga edges it by 1.0. See them side by side
The verdict
Alien: Romulus is a capable, frequently scary genre film with superb practical craft and one excellent performance. It also plays it too safe, mistaking reference for reverence and populating its story with characters who rarely rise above archetypes. Fans will find much to enjoy, which is why it scores a respectable 7.1, but it lands well short of the originals it so openly admires.





