Among Us · 2018
Among Us: a brilliant social deduction idea that lives or dies on the company you keep
Among Us review: Innersloth's lying-and-accusing party game is a sharp social deduction design, though thin mechanics and public lobbies limit it.
Good
Editorial score out of 10
Among Us is proof that a design does not need depth of mechanics to generate depth of play. Its tasks are trivial, its visuals are cheerfully basic and its menus are functional at best, yet a round among friends can produce more drama, laughter and outright betrayal than games with many times the budget.
- 7.4
- Editorial score
- #113
- Of 116 games reviewed
- 2018
- Released
- 7.8
- Best at: Gameplay
That strength is also its ceiling. The game provides the stage but very little of the performance, and when the people around the table are not up for the theatre, there is not much left underneath.
The best moments come from confident lies, desperate defences and the occasional innocent player ejected through sheer bad luck.
How it plays
A round begins with crewmates fanning out across a map such as The Skeld or Polus to complete tasks: swiping a card, emptying rubbish, rerouting power. Impostors mimic this behaviour while waiting for a moment alone with a victim, using vents to move unseen and sabotage to split the group. Turning off the lights or triggering a reactor meltdown forces crewmates to react, and chaos is where impostors thrive.
The core pleasure arrives at meetings. Players share alibis, accuse one another and vote, often on flimsy evidence. The best moments come from confident lies, desperate defences and the occasional innocent player ejected through sheer bad luck. Later updates introduced optional roles, such as crew members with extra tools and impostors with disguise abilities, which help seasoned groups keep the deduction fresh.

Structure and story
There is no story to speak of, and none is needed. The setting is a light science-fiction backdrop of spaceships, research stations and airships, populated by bean-shaped astronauts in customisable hats. What narrative exists is emergent: the tale of who saw whom near electrical and why they claimed to be somewhere else.
This is worth being clear about for anyone expecting a campaign or single-player mode. Among Us is a multiplayer game first and last.
Presentation
The art style is simple and readable, with bright colours that make each player identifiable at a glance. That clarity is functional rather than beautiful, and the sound design is sparse. Menus and lobby tools improved over time, and the addition of maps like The Fungle gave the game a little more visual personality, but it has never been a showpiece.
On the other hand, the low demands mean it runs almost anywhere, which played a large part in its enormous popularity when it was rediscovered by streamers and players well after its original release.
Who it is for
Among Us is best for established friend groups who will jump into a voice call and commit to the roleplay. Families and younger players will also find it approachable. Solo players relying on public matchmaking are likely to have a far patchier time, since quick chat and text alone struggle to carry the discussion, and lobbies can be derailed by people leaving early or ignoring the rules.
What works
- A simple ruleset that produces endless arguments and memorable bluffs
- Very low barrier to entry for players of any age or skill
- Cross-platform play makes getting a group together easy
- Later roles and maps add welcome variety to the formula
What doesn’t
- Tasks are shallow minigames that exist mainly as cover for lying
- Public lobbies suffer from leavers, cheats and silent voters
- Almost entirely dependent on voice chat outside the game
Head to head
- Story
- 4.05.8
- Gameplay
- 7.89.0
- Longevity
- 7.29.0
- Presentation
- 6.68.0
Deep Rock Galactic edges it by 1.2. See them side by side
The verdict
As a social deduction design, Among Us is sharp, accessible and hugely influential, and its best rounds are genuinely unforgettable. Its thin moment-to-moment play, lack of solo value and reliance on external voice chat keep it firmly in good-but-limited territory. With the right group it can feel like an eight; with strangers, considerably less.




