Animal Crossing: New Horizons · 2020
Animal Crossing: New Horizons turns island chores into something close to therapy
Animal Crossing: New Horizons review: Nintendo's island life sim adds crafting and terraforming to a gentle routine, but friction and repetition remain.
Excellent
Editorial score out of 10
Animal Crossing: New Horizons arrived at a moment when a great many people needed a calm, gentle place to spend a little time each day, and it met that need with remarkable grace. Beyond its timing, it is the most flexible and creatively open entry in Nintendo's long-running series, even if it keeps some of the series' more stubborn habits.
- 8.4
- Editorial score
- #87
- Of 116 games reviewed
- 2020
- Released
- 8.9
- Best at: Presentation
Its central appeal is ownership. The island starts as a scrappy campsite and, over weeks and months of short sessions, becomes something that feels entirely personal. Few games are as good at making small daily progress feel meaningful.
Its aquarium, insect exhibits and art wing are beautifully designed spaces that turn collecting into something close to sightseeing.
How it plays
Days revolve around a gentle loop: shake trees, dig up fossils, catch whatever is in season, sell the haul and put the proceeds towards home loans or projects. New Horizons adds a crafting system built around DIY recipes, letting players make tools, furniture and decorations from wood, stone and more unusual materials. Nook Miles, a secondary currency earned for everyday activities, provide a steady stream of small goals.
The major addition is terraforming, unlocked after the early game. Being able to raise cliffs, dig rivers and lay paths transforms the island into a canvas, and the ability to place furniture outdoors encourages elaborate gardens, markets and themed areas.
The friction is familiar. Crafting is done one item at a time with repeated animations, tools wear out and break, and early progress is deliberately gated by real-world days. Some players find the slow drip charming; others find it patronising.

Island life and characters
There is no plot in the traditional sense, only a sequence of milestones: welcoming new residents, upgrading the resident services building, persuading K.K. Slider to perform. The animal villagers remain the heart of the experience, each with a personality type and catchphrase, though their dialogue cycles through lines more quickly than long-time fans would like.
Blathers' museum is a highlight. Its aquarium, insect exhibits and art wing are beautifully designed spaces that turn collecting into something close to sightseeing.
Presentation
This is one of the best-looking games on Switch. Textures are soft and tactile, water and weather shift convincingly, and seasonal changes such as cherry blossom and snowfall are handled with real care. The hourly soundtrack, a series tradition, adapts to time of day and remains quietly delightful.
Multiplayer is more awkward. Only one island exists per console, the first player to set up holds many of the key decisions, and visiting friends online involves lengthy airport sequences.
Who it is for
New Horizons suits anyone who enjoys routine, collecting and decorating, and it is especially well suited to short daily play. Families can share it, if not always evenly. Players who want clear objectives, challenge or a steady pace of new content should know that it is designed around patience rather than momentum, and its free updates concluded in 2021 alongside the paid Happy Home Paradise expansion.
What works
- Terraforming and outdoor decoration give real creative ownership
- The real-time calendar makes daily visits feel rewarding
- A warm, gorgeously detailed island that changes with the seasons
- Expanded museum is a genuinely lovely space to wander
What doesn’t
- Crafting multiple items and breakable tools add needless friction
- Only one island per console, with a clear first-player bias
- Villager conversations repeat quickly and lack earlier personality
Head to head
- Story
- 5.64.5
- Gameplay
- 8.39.7
- Longevity
- 8.89.8
- Presentation
- 8.97.6
Factorio edges it by 0.8. See them side by side
The verdict
New Horizons is the richest Animal Crossing yet, and its creative tools elevate the series' soothing formula. Clumsy crafting, gated early days and a restrictive approach to shared play stop it short of greatness, but for the many who settle into its rhythms it remains an unusually comforting companion.



