Animal Well · 2024
Animal Well is a pocket-sized metroidvania with secrets buried several floors deep
Animal Well review: Billy Basso's eerie, combat-free metroidvania hides layer upon layer of puzzles, though its most obscure secrets test patience.
Excellent
Editorial score out of 10
Animal Well feels less like a game than a locked box someone has handed over without instructions. It is small in footprint yet extraordinarily dense, and the more it is prodded, the more it gives back. That sense of discovery, of noticing something odd in a corner and realising it means something, is the whole point.
- 8.7
- Editorial score
- #67
- Of 116 games reviewed
- 2024
- Released
- 9.1
- Best at: Presentation
Its generosity comes with a caveat. Animal Well does not hold hands, and at its outer edges it stops being a game played alone and becomes a puzzle for a community. How appealing that sounds will determine how much it clicks.
The map must be found and marked by hand, and it is easy to lose the thread of which door or ledge has been left behind.
How it plays
The creature controlled by the player is fragile and cannot fight. Instead, exploration is driven by a set of items that seem modest at first: a bubble wand, a frisbee, a yo-yo, a slinky and more. Each opens routes in obvious ways, and then in less obvious ones, as it becomes clear that the tools interact with switches, animals and physics in ways the game never spells out.
This is metroidvania design stripped to its logic. There are no upgrades to health or damage, only a growing vocabulary of verbs. Puzzle rooms are compact and cleverly layered, often combining platforming precision with a moment of lateral insight. Several chase sequences involving large animals are tense precisely because running and thinking are the only options.
Frustration arrives when that vocabulary runs dry. The map must be found and marked by hand, and it is easy to lose the thread of which door or ledge has been left behind.

World and mystery
There is no dialogue and almost no explicit narrative. The well is a strange, melancholy ecosystem of ghostly cats, seahorses, chameleons and giant birds, with statues and murals hinting at something older. Meaning is implied rather than told, which suits the atmosphere.
The structure is best described in layers. Reaching the main ending is a satisfying adventure in itself. Collecting eggs uncovers further paths. Beyond that sits a stratum of secrets so obscure that they were designed with collective effort in mind, and players who enjoy piecing together clues on forums will find that deeply appealing. Solo players may see them as walls.
Presentation
Basso built his own engine, and it shows in the details. The pixel art is simple in shape but rich in effect: shimmering water, dynamic lighting from candles and fireflies, drifting smoke and subtle reflections. The palette leans dark, with bursts of colour that guide the eye.
Audio is equally considered. Ambient hums, dripping water and sudden animal cries create unease with very little music, and the quiet makes every unexpected sound count.
Who it is for
This is ideal for fans of cryptic exploration games and anyone who keeps a notebook beside the screen. It is relatively short if played for its main route alone, but the long tail of secrets offers far more for those willing to dig. Players who prefer clear objectives, combat or a firm sense of progression may bounce off its reticence.
What works
- Every tool has surprising uses that reveal themselves gradually
- Striking pixel art with lighting and particle effects that feel alive
- Genuinely unnerving animal encounters without any combat
- Secrets that reward notebook-keeping and lateral thinking
What doesn’t
- The deepest puzzles lean on outside collaboration to crack
- Backtracking can drag when the next step is unclear
- Sparse direction will frustrate players who like a clear goal
Head to head
- Story
- 6.88.9
- Gameplay
- 8.99.4
- Longevity
- 8.99.2
- Presentation
- 9.19.2
Blue Prince edges it by 0.5. See them side by side
The verdict
Animal Well is a remarkable piece of craft, all the more so for being largely the work of one developer. Its ingenious tool design, eerie atmosphere and seemingly bottomless secrets earn a high score, while its occasional opacity and reliance on community detective work keep it just shy of the very best in its genre.




