Barbie · 2023
Barbie: a candy-coloured comedy that is sharper, and preachier, than expected
Barbie review: Greta Gerwig's dazzling doll comedy has a pitch-perfect Margot Robbie and scene-stealing Ryan Gosling, even if its messages are spelled out loud.
Good
Editorial score out of 10
Barbie had every reason to be a glossy toy advertisement. Instead, Greta Gerwig turned a Mattel property into a self-aware comedy about identity, gender and the contradictions of a doll that has been praised and criticised for decades. It became a cultural phenomenon and the biggest box-office hit of 2023, and it is easy to see why: it is funny, visually spectacular and knowingly playful about its own commercial origins.
- 7.7
- Editorial score
- #99
- Of 112 movies reviewed
- 2023
- Released
- 9.0
- Best at: Craft
It is also, at times, frustratingly on the nose. For every sly observation there is a scene that states its message outright, and the brilliance of its first half is not quite sustained to the end.
The climax, involving a battle for control of Barbieland, piles on plot mechanics and loses some of the earlier lightness.
Barbieland
The film's opening stretch is wonderful. After a cheeky parody of 2001: A Space Odyssey, we arrive in Barbieland, where the Barbies are doctors, presidents and Nobel laureates, while the Kens stand around on the beach waiting to be noticed. Sarah Greenwood's production design recreates the dreamhouses and plastic streets as physical sets, with painted skies and no walls, and the effect is gorgeously tactile. Barbie floats down from her roof to her car because that is how a child would move her.
Margot Robbie is perfectly cast. She plays the idealised surface convincingly, but her gradual confusion, from flat feet to a sudden awareness of mortality, is played with a sincerity that grounds the silliness.

Ken
Ryan Gosling's Ken nearly runs away with the film. His hunger for Barbie's attention and later discovery of patriarchy, horses and the Mojo Dojo Casa House produce some of the funniest moments of the year. Gosling commits completely, and his big musical number, a power ballad about the agony of being just Ken, is a highlight that blends parody with real showmanship. Simu Liu, as a rival Ken, and Michael Cera, as the lonely Allan, add further comic texture.
The real world
Once the story moves to Los Angeles, the film becomes more uneven. The Mattel boardroom scenes, led by Will Ferrell's cartoonish chief executive, are broad and toothless, and the mother-daughter storyline with America Ferrera's Gloria and her daughter Sasha feels underwritten. Ferrera delivers a much-discussed monologue about the impossible expectations placed on women, which many viewers found rousing and others found too direct for a film otherwise so witty.
The climax, involving a battle for control of Barbieland, piles on plot mechanics and loses some of the earlier lightness. The film recovers its footing in a quiet, moving late scene featuring Rhea Perlman as Barbie creator Ruth Handler.
Craft and style
Beyond the sets, Jacqueline Durran's costumes are witty and exact, and Rodrigo Prieto's cinematography gives Barbieland a bright, stage-like glow. The soundtrack, with contributions from Dua Lipa, Nicki Minaj and others, is well integrated, and Billie Eilish's reflective ballad gives the film an unexpected emotional pause.
What works
- Barbieland's handmade, life-size production design is a joy
- Ryan Gosling's Ken is a brilliantly committed comic creation
- Margot Robbie balances plastic perfection with real vulnerability
- Packed with smart visual gags and genuinely funny musical moments
What doesn’t
- Its themes are often explained in speeches rather than dramatised
- The real-world Mattel scenes are broad and weaker than Barbieland
- The third act loses comic momentum as the plot tangles
Head to head
- Craft
- 9.08.6
- Story
- 7.08.5
- Direction
- 8.29.0
- Performances
- 8.59.3
Everything Everywhere All at Once edges it by 1.0. See them side by side
The verdict
Barbie is an inventive, funny and gorgeously designed blockbuster that pushes its source much further than most studio films would dare. Its best material, especially in Barbieland and with Gosling's Ken, is terrific. But its tendency to lecture and a slack final act prevent it from being as sharp as Gerwig's finest work, which is why it scores a 7.7.





