Skip to content
Album reviewEssential

Buena Vista Social Club · 1997

Buena Vista Social Club: a cancelled session that became Cuba's most famous record

Buena Vista Social Club review. The 1997 album recorded in Havana with Compay Segundo, Ibrahim Ferrer and Rubén González, and why it still sounds unhurried.

Voxizer EditorialSection editor Pablo Huguet9 min read

Essential

Editorial score out of 10

Buena Vista Social Club exists because two musicians from Mali could not get visas. In March 1996 World Circuit's Nick Gold had arranged for them to record in Havana with Cuban players, and Ry Cooder had flown in for it. When the African half of the session failed to arrive, the studio was booked and the Cubans were already there, so the plan changed: make a record of the songs these musicians had grown up playing, with the people who had played them first. The result is a quiet, almost conversational album that went on to sell more than any record of its kind and to make stars of musicians in their late sixties, seventies and eighties.

9.2
Editorial score
#15
Of 44 albums reviewed
1997
Released
14
Tracks

It still works because nobody on it is performing a rediscovery. Compay Segundo, Ibrahim Ferrer, Rubén González, Eliades Ochoa and Omara Portuondo are simply playing, mostly live, in an old RCA studio whose wooden walls you can almost hear. The record has a reputation as a time capsule. Listened to now, it sounds more like a working band on a good week.

How it came about

The musical director was Juan de Marcos González, who had been planning to record Cuba's golden-era repertoire with its surviving players for years and was assembling the Afro-Cuban All Stars at the same time. Many of the same musicians recorded A toda Cuba le gusta for that project in the same sessions, and a solo album by Rubén González came out of them too. De Marcos González, Gold and Cooder went looking for singers and players who had fallen out of view: Ferrer had all but stopped singing, González was long past his years as a bandleader's pianist, and Segundo, in his late eighties, had been playing the same songs for most of the century.

Cooder produced, and his approach was to set up microphones and get out of the way. Arrangements were worked out on the floor according to the feel of each song, and most of what you hear was recorded in one or two takes. Communication went through an interpreter, and by most accounts the music did the rest. The project took its name from a danzón that González started playing one afternoon before a session, a tune that had been the signature of a members' club in Havana's Buena Vista district in the 1940s.

  1. 1996

    March: the Havana sessions at EGREM, planned as a Malian-Cuban collaboration

  2. 1997

    June: World Circuit releases the album; Nonesuch follows in the US in September

  3. 1998

    A Grammy, and the short run of concerts in Amsterdam and at Carnegie Hall

  4. 1999

    Wim Wenders' documentary takes the musicians to a far wider audience

  5. 2008

    The Carnegie Hall concert finally appears as a live album

  6. 2022

    Selected for the US National Recording Registry

Buena Vista Social Club
Buena Vista Social ClubWorld Circuit, original 1997 CD booklet (inner spread), via Cover Art Archive

The songs

The opener, Chan Chan, is the most recent composition on the record and the one everybody knows: Compay Segundo's four-chord son, sung by Eliades Ochoa with Segundo on the second voice his stage name refers to. Its words sketch a small rural scene, a couple walking towards a village and a job of work along the way, and the tune circles patiently enough that it feels much older than its 1980s origins. It became the group's calling card for good reason.

Two tracks later, El cuarto de Tula shows the other side of the band. Sergio González Siaba's son about a room on fire opens up into a long descarga, with Ochoa, Ferrer and Manuel "Puntillita" Licea trading improvised lines, Barbarito Torres tearing through a laúd solo, and a thirteen-year-old on timbales. Candela, Faustino Oramas's son full of double meanings, gives Ferrer room to play the rogue. These are the tracks for anyone who thinks the album is only for late evenings.

The boleros are the heart of it. Dos gardenias, Isolina Carrillo's song from the 1940s, was chosen after Cooder heard Ferrer and González working through it before a session, and Ferrer sings it with the restraint of someone who no longer needs to prove anything. Omara Portuondo's Veinte años, the only lead vocal by a woman on the record, was cut in a single take on her way out of the building. Compay Segundo overdubbed both voices on ¿Y tú qué has hecho? and then played a tres duet with Cooder's guitar.

Where to start
TrackWhy
Chan ChanThe signature: four chords, two voices, endlessly patient
Dos gardeniasIbrahim Ferrer's bolero, the album's emotional centre
El cuarto de TulaSeven minutes of descarga with a laúd solo at the peak
Buena Vista Social ClubRubén González alone with an old danzón, and the source of the name
Veinte añosOmara Portuondo in one take
Watch
Buena Vista Social Club — trailer

Rubén González and the danzones

If the album has a secret weapon, it is the piano. Rubén González had played with Arsenio Rodríguez in the 1940s, and here, past his mid-seventies, he plays like a man let back into a room he had been locked out of. Pueblo Nuevo and the title track are both danzones by Israel "Cachao" López, first recorded by Arcaño y sus Maravillas, and González treats them as places to wander. His runs are light, rhythmic and slightly sly, and the band, led by Orlando "Cachaito" López on bass, keeps the floor steady under him.

These two tracks are what set the record apart from a straightforward revival. A danzón is formal, a dance with sections, and González loosens it without ever losing the step. On this evidence, the album's dedication of so much space to one pianist was the right call.

A record that sounds less like a revival than a band that never stopped.

Gallery · 3 imagesBuena Vista Social Club, "El Cuarto de Tula" official video (EGREM session footage), via YouTube · Buena Vista Social Club, "Chan Chan" official video, via World Circuit Records on YouTube

Production and performance

The studio is part of the sound. EGREM's main room, built for RCA before the revolution, had changed little since the 1950s, and Cooder's recording keeps its air and its wood. Voices sit close but not on top of the microphone, the bass is round rather than punchy, and the percussion, maracas, bongos and Joachim Cooder's udu and dumbek, ticks along at the edge of the stereo picture. Nothing is compressed for radio. It is an album that rewards a decent pair of speakers and forgives a cheap one.

The weak point is the producer's own playing. Cooder's guitar is tasteful through most of the record, and on El carretero he adds mbira and a floor slide to the guajira that work well enough. But his electric and acoustic slide on Candela and Amor de loca juventud sits on top of the band rather than inside it, and anyone who loves the Cuban originals tends to notice. It is a small fault, and the price of having the person who made the session possible also play on it.

How it sounds

Intimacy
9/10
Small groups in a wooden room, most tracks live
Energy
6/10
Two long descargas; elsewhere it rarely raises its voice
Variety
8/10
Son, bolero, danzón, guajira and a criolla
Accessibility
9/10
No Spanish needed to follow the feeling

Sequencing and legacy

The running order front-loads its strengths: Chan Chan, De camino a la vereda, El cuarto de Tula and Pueblo Nuevo make one of the strongest opening runs of any record from the decade. The middle stretch, a sequence of three-minute boleros sung in turn by Segundo and Ferrer, is lovely track by track but loses shape on a straight listen. The album recovers with the title track near the end, and closes quietly with Sindo Garay's La bayamesa, an old patriotic criolla rather than the anthem of the same name.

The album's success reshaped the careers of everyone on it and, for a time, the world-music market as a whole. It also left a framing that does not quite hold up: that Cuban music had stood still since the 1950s and was waiting to be found. It had not. Son had fed salsa, timba was at its height in mid-1990s Havana, and several of these players had worked steadily for decades. The record is a document of one strand of a living tradition, not a rescue. For a newer conversation between Caribbean tradition and pop, Debí Tirar Más Fotos is a useful companion; our review of it makes the comparison from the other end.

Head to head

Cohesion
8.99.3
Production
9.49.3
Performance
9.69.0
Songwriting
9.09.2

Dead level: both score 9.2.See them side by side

The nostalgia that clings to this record is part of its appeal and part of its trap. Like Wong Kar-wai's In the Mood for Love, it can be enjoyed as a mood, but it repays attention to the craft that produces the mood.

For you if

  • Anyone who has heard Chan Chan in a café and wanted to know what the rest sounds like
  • Listeners who like acoustic music played live, with the room left in
  • Fans of bolero singers, piano soloists and small-band arrangements

Not for you if

  • Anyone after the dance-floor punch of salsa or timba
  • Listeners who want lyrics they can follow without any Spanish
  • Anyone who finds slide guitar out of place in Cuban music

Newcomers should start with the original album before the live record or the many spin-offs; the solo albums by Ferrer and González that followed are the natural next step.

What works

  • Takes recorded live in one room, so you hear the band listening to itself
  • Ibrahim Ferrer's Dos gardenias, a bolero sung with no wasted breath
  • Rubén González's piano turns two old danzones into the album's high points
  • Fourteen tracks that range from country guajira to Havana dance music

What doesn’t

  • Ry Cooder's slide guitar sits awkwardly in a few tracks that did not need it
  • The middle run of short boleros blurs together on a straight listen
  • Its framing as a rediscovery flattens the history of Cuban music since the 1950s
EssentialHow we score

The verdict

Buena Vista Social Club earns its place through performances rather than legend. Ferrer's boleros, González's danzones and Segundo's steadiness are the reasons to return, and the decision to record the band live in an old room is what keeps them sounding present nearly three decades on. The score stops short of the top tier because the record is uneven in its middle, because its producer's guitar occasionally intrudes, and because the story told around it has always been bigger than the album itself. Strip that story away and what is left is still a superb record by musicians at ease with one another and with their material, and that is the version most worth hearing.

Quick answers

Is Buena Vista Social Club worth listening to?

Voxizer scores Buena Vista Social Club (1997) 9.2 out of 10 — essential. Buena Vista Social Club earns its place through performances rather than legend. Ferrer's boleros, González's danzones and Segundo's steadiness are the reasons to return, and the decision to record the band live in an old room is what keeps them sounding present nearly three decades on.

Who will enjoy Buena Vista Social Club?

Anyone who has heard Chan Chan in a café and wanted to know what the rest sounds like. Listeners who like acoustic music played live, with the room left in. Fans of bolero singers, piano soloists and small-band arrangements.

Who should skip Buena Vista Social Club?

Anyone after the dance-floor punch of salsa or timba. Listeners who want lyrics they can follow without any Spanish. Anyone who finds slide guitar out of place in Cuban music.

What is Buena Vista Social Club like, in short?

A record made by accident, from a session planned for something else, in six days. Fourteen standards and near-standards of son, bolero and danzón, sung by the people who knew them best. The sound of the room does as much work as any arrangement; most takes are live. Rubén González and Ibrahim Ferrer are the revelations, Compay Segundo the anchor.

What readers say

Written by Voxizer members and checked by our moderators before they appear.

Written reviews

–

No written reviews yet

Write a review
9–10
0
7–8.5
0
5–6.5
0
3–4.5
0
0–2.5
0

Nobody has reviewed Buena Vista Social Club yet. Be the first.

All reviews →

Verified sources

Published by the Voxizer editorial team — David Abellán, Ignacio Pineda, Pablo Huguet. Section editor for albums: Pablo Huguet.

Revision history

  1. Published

Scores are revised when the facts behind them change, and the change is recorded here. How we score.