Skip to content
Album reviewExcellent

Chromakopia · 2024

Chromakopia: the messiest Tyler record, and the one with the most at stake

Chromakopia review. Tyler, the Creator's eighth album trades the neatness of his last two for something louder, looser and far more confessional.

Voxizer EditorialSection editor Pablo Huguet9 min read

Excellent

Editorial score out of 10

Two albums ago, Tyler, the Creator proved he could hold one mood for forty minutes without blinking. Chromakopia spends fifty-two minutes taking that skill apart on purpose, and the wreckage is the most revealing thing he has put his name to.

8.7
Editorial score
#27
Of 44 albums reviewed
2024
Released
14
Tracks

It arrived on a Monday morning in October 2024, which is not how the industry releases major records, and the album behaves the way that decision did: against the grain, at odd angles, louder than anyone had reason to expect. Fourteen tracks, every one written and produced by Tyler himself, are bound together by his mother's voice rather than by any musical logic. Bonita Smith opens the record telling her son never to dim his light, and keeps coming back between songs with advice, warnings and memory. She is the reason a record this scattered holds at all.

Where it sits

Every Tyler album since Flower Boy has come with a costume and a name to go with it. Igor was a blond wig, a pastel suit and one break-up told start to finish. Call Me If You Get Lost was a passport, a Gangsta Grillz frame and DJ Drama bellowing over the intros. Chromakopia hands him a green army jacket, a painted mask and a marching band, and then spends the whole record pulling that mask off and putting it back on.

The persona is the thinnest he has used, and that turns out to be the design. Where the previous two albums invented a character to hide the author behind, this one keeps admitting there is nobody under the costume but a man in his thirties working out what his mother was trying to tell him. The green is the only thing that stays consistent. Everything else — the voices, the tempos, the sense of who is speaking — moves.

  1. 2015

    Cherry Bomb buries the songs under distortion and splits the audience in half

  2. 2017

    Flower Boy turns the writing inward and the palette warm

  3. 2019

    Igor commits to one character, one synthesiser and one break-up

  4. 2021

    Call Me If You Get Lost borrows the Gangsta Grillz mixtape frame, DJ Drama and all

  5. 2024

    Chromakopia drops the frame, keeps the costume and gives the narration to Bonita Smith

That run matters because it explains what is missing here. The three albums before this one were sequenced like short films. Chromakopia is sequenced like a shoebox of tapes, and the argument about whether that is a flaw or the method runs through everything below.

Chromakopia
ChromakopiaTyler, the Creator / Columbia Records, from the official "Noid" video

The songs

St. Chroma opens on a whisper and a marching cadence, with Daniel Caesar arriving over the top of a rhythm that sounds like boots on tarmac, and it is the clearest statement of intent on the record. Rah Tah Tah follows with pure swagger and almost no subtext, a two-and-a-half-minute reminder that Tyler can still rap harder than most people who do nothing else. Noid, the lead single, loops a piece of Ngozi Family's Zamrock guitar from 1977 under a song about parasocial dread, and the join between those two things is the best production trick on the album.

Then the mood turns without warning. Hey Jane stages a conversation about an unplanned pregnancy from both sides, spoken plainly enough that the beat almost gets out of the way. Judge Judy tells a story about a woman from the past and withholds its ending until the last thirty seconds. Take Your Mask Off is the thesis stated outright, four verses aimed at four kinds of pretence, one of them his own. Tomorrow is a quiet panic about friends with children and houses. And Like Him, with Lola Young singing the hook, is the one that will still be played in ten years: a son asking his mother about a father he has never met, over a beat that barely moves.

A record that keeps interrupting its own party to take a phone call from home.

Between those, the album parks two of the loudest things Tyler has made. Sticky is a horn-driven posse cut with GloRilla, Sexyy Red and Lil Wayne, built on a James Brown sample and a drumline, and it is enormous. Balloon, with Doechii, is ninety seconds of Miami bass energy dropped into the back half like a firework through a letterbox. Whether that placement reads as brave or careless depends entirely on the listener.

Where to start
TrackWhy
St. ChromaThe mission statement: whisper, marching band, and a Daniel Caesar hook that arrives like a sunrise
NoidZamrock guitar and celebrity paranoia; the single that sounds like nothing else on radio
StickyHorns, drumline and three guests who all show up hungry; the room-filler
Take Your Mask OffThe album's argument, delivered without a costume to hide behind
Like HimThe emotional centre, and the reason the record earns its length

The fourteen tracks average under four minutes and several stop short of three, which keeps the pace up but leaves some ideas half-built. The closer in particular arrives before the record has finished answering the questions it raised.

Watch
Chromakopia — trailer

Production

Tyler produced all of it, and the arrangements are the strongest argument for his standing as a producer rather than a rapper who makes his own beats. The palette is wide: choral stacks, clipped funk guitar, detuned synthesiser pads, live horns, drum programming that leans deliberately dry. Individual songs change shape two or three times, usually at the two-minute mark, and usually without warning.

That restlessness is the album's signature and its main risk. On Noid and Sticky, the turns land like punchlines. On a couple of the mid-album tracks, they read as an unwillingness to let a good idea finish. The mixing is precise enough that none of it ever turns to mush, which is not something that could be said of Cherry Bomb, and the low end has real weight on a decent system without being tuned for a car park.

Gallery · 3 imagesTyler, the Creator / Columbia Records, from the official "Sticky" video · Tyler, the Creator / Columbia Records, from the official "Darling, I" video · Tyler, the Creator / Columbia Records, from the official "Thought I Was Dead" video

Performance

As a rapper, Tyler is sharper here than he has been since Flower Boy. The bragging on Rah Tah Tah is delivered with a bounce he has not used in years, and the confessional writing on Take Your Mask Off and Tomorrow is unusually direct for a writer who has built a career on misdirection. His singing, which used to be a texture, now carries whole hooks.

The guests are less even. Doechii and Lola Young earn their features outright, each doing something the song could not do without them. GloRilla and Sexyy Red both land. Others pass through in well under a minute and leave the impression of a favour returned rather than a part written for them. Bonita Smith, who is not a musician at all, gives the most memorable performance on the record.

How it measures up

Energy
8/10
Two genuine bangers, and a middle section that sits down
Intimacy
8.5/10
The confessional writing is closer than anything since Flower Boy
Density
9/10
Arrangements change shape two or three times per song
Accessibility
7/10
Rewards a full sitting; hostile to shuffle
Running time
53/62
Minutes, against the sprawl of a modern rap album

Sequencing and cohesion

Here is the one real complaint. Igor was an argument for sequencing as composition: twelve tracks that could not be reordered without breaking. Chromakopia puts a Miami bass party record between its two most vulnerable songs and dares the listener to call it a mistake. Sometimes the whiplash works, because that is what a mind under pressure actually sounds like. Sometimes it is just whiplash.

The counterweight is Bonita Smith. Her passages arrive exactly where the record threatens to fly apart, and they reframe the song that follows almost every time. Take them out and this is a strong, disorganised collection of songs. Leave them in and it becomes a portrait of a man being talked to by the person who knew him first. We think that is enough to carry it, but it is a closer call than the score suggests.

Head to head

Cohesion
7.88.8
Production
9.29.1
Performance
8.98.0
Songwriting
8.88.3

Chromakopia edges it by 0.4. See them side by side

Anyone coming to Tyler for the first time will find Igor the easier door: shorter, tidier, built on one idea carried the whole way. Chromakopia asks more and gives back more, and it is best heard second.

For you if

  • Anyone who has followed Tyler since Flower Boy and wants to hear him stop performing
  • Listeners who play albums end to end and enjoy a record that argues with itself
  • Anyone who values production that refuses to repeat a bar

Not for you if

  • Listeners who need a consistent mood from first track to last
  • Anyone who came for the party records and would rather skip the phone calls
  • Shuffle listeners; half of this falls apart out of order

For readers who want the full context around the release, the album's own site still carries the artwork, the tracklist and the trucking-company conceit that trailed it across America in the autumn of 2024.

What works

  • Bonita Smith's spoken passages give fourteen scattered tracks one spine
  • Tyler produced every track himself, and no arrangement sits still for long
  • Sticky and Rah Tah Tah are built for a room rather than a pair of headphones
  • Like Him lands the album's hardest turn without ever raising its voice

What doesn’t

  • The sequencing lurches between party records and confessions
  • The paranoia theme gets restated more often than it gets developed
  • Several guest spots pass in under a minute and leave little trace
ExcellentHow we score

The verdict

Chromakopia is the sound of an artist with total control of his tools choosing not to use it. The production is the richest of his career, the writing is the most exposed, and the record is held together by a voice that belongs to somebody who never asked to be on it. What keeps the score below the top tier is the sequencing: the turns between the party and the confession are abrupt often enough to break a first listen, and a couple of songs stop before their ideas do. That looseness is also why it lands harder than the albums either side of it. Tidier records will age more comfortably. Few will feel this close to someone thinking aloud.

Quick answers

Is Chromakopia worth listening to?

Voxizer scores Chromakopia (2024) 8.7 out of 10 — excellent. Chromakopia is the sound of an artist with total control of his tools choosing not to use it. The production is the richest of his career, the writing is the most exposed, and the record is held together by a voice that belongs to somebody who never asked to be on it.

Who will enjoy Chromakopia?

Anyone who has followed Tyler since Flower Boy and wants to hear him stop performing. Listeners who play albums end to end and enjoy a record that argues with itself. Anyone who values production that refuses to repeat a bar.

Who should skip Chromakopia?

Listeners who need a consistent mood from first track to last. Anyone who came for the party records and would rather skip the phone calls. Shuffle listeners; half of this falls apart out of order.

What is Chromakopia like, in short?

Tyler's eighth album: fourteen tracks, written and produced by him, out on a Monday in October 2024. Bonita Smith's spoken passages hold the thing together where the sequencing will not. Sticky, Rah Tah Tah and Noid supply the noise; Take Your Mask Off and Like Him supply the weight. Less tidy than Igor or Call Me If You Get Lost, and more honest than either.

What readers say

Written by Voxizer members and checked by our moderators before they appear.

Written reviews

–

No written reviews yet

Write a review
9–10
0
7–8.5
0
5–6.5
0
3–4.5
0
0–2.5
0

Nobody has reviewed Chromakopia yet. Be the first.

All reviews →

Verified sources

Published by the Voxizer editorial team — David Abellán, Ignacio Pineda, Pablo Huguet. Section editor for albums: Pablo Huguet.

Revision history

  1. Published

Scores are revised when the facts behind them change, and the change is recorded here. How we score.