Skip to content
Movie reviewExcellent

Conclave · 2024

Conclave: a papal election thriller that plays power politics like chess

Conclave review: Edward Berger's gripping Vatican thriller is elegant, tense and grounded by Ralph Fiennes, though its final revelation will divide viewers.

Voxizer EditorialSection editor David Abellán3 min read

Excellent

Editorial score out of 10

Conclave takes one of the world's most secretive rituals and treats it as a political thriller, complete with scandals, leaked documents and shifting alliances. Edward Berger, who directed the acclaimed All Quiet on the Western Front, brings elegance and control to the material, while Robert Harris's plotting provides an efficient engine of suspense. It is sophisticated popular entertainment of a kind that mainstream cinema rarely offers, and its screenplay won the Academy Award for adaptation.

8.2
Editorial score
#75
Of 112 movies reviewed
2024
Released
8.9
Best at: Performances

It is also, at heart, a well-made potboiler. The film enjoys its twists, and its final one has proved sharply divisive.

A shot of white umbrellas crossing a courtyard became one of the film's signature images.

The election

After the Pope's sudden death, Lawrence, the dean of the College of Cardinals, finds himself managing the election while privately struggling with his own faith. The main contenders represent broad factions: Stanley Tucci's liberal Bellini, John Lithgow's ambitious Tremblay, Lucian Msamati's socially conservative Adeyemi and Sergio Castellitto's hardline traditionalist Tedesco. A late arrival, a Mexican cardinal serving in Kabul named Benítez, adds an unexpected factor.

The structure is strong. Each round of voting shifts the balance, and each revelation removes or elevates a candidate. The film makes the procedural details, from the burning of ballots to the sealing of rooms, compelling in their own right. Its weakness is that the cardinals can resemble positions in a debate more than rounded people.

Conclave
ConclaveFocus Features

Fiennes and company

Ralph Fiennes is superb as Lawrence. He conveys a man of integrity who wants no part of power, but who is increasingly forced to act politically to protect the Church. His doubt, fatigue and flashes of anger are finely calibrated, and the film rests comfortably on his performance.

Tucci and Lithgow are both excellent, the former conveying wounded idealism and the latter slippery ambition. Isabella Rossellini, as Sister Agnes, who oversees the nuns serving the cardinals, has relatively little screen time but delivers one of the film's most satisfying moments, a reminder of the women who keep the institution running while being excluded from its power.

Watch
Conclave — trailer

Visual and musical style

The Sistine Chapel was recreated for the production, and Suzie Davies' design, together with Stéphane Fontaine's cinematography, gives the film an austere grandeur. Compositions frequently emphasise symmetry and ritual, with cardinals in red forming striking patterns against marble and stone. A shot of white umbrellas crossing a courtyard became one of the film's signature images.

Volker Bertelmann's score, driven by stabbing strings, is effective at building suspense but occasionally insists too heavily on drama in scenes that would be more powerful with restraint.

Gallery · 3 imagesFocus Features

The ending

Without spoiling it, the final revelation turns the film's themes of institutional change and certainty in an unexpected direction. For some viewers it is a bold and fitting culmination; for others it feels like a narrative sleight of hand designed to provoke, arriving too late to be explored. Either way, it shifts the film from a thriller about politics into something more pointed about the Church's future.

What works

  • Ralph Fiennes brings anguished intelligence to a quietly heroic role
  • Turns ballots and whispered corridor chats into genuine suspense
  • Striking production design recreates the Sistine Chapel in detail
  • Isabella Rossellini makes a small role unforgettable

What doesn’t

  • The final twist feels more provocative than fully earned
  • Rival cardinals lean towards neat ideological types
  • Volker Bertelmann's strident score can oversell the tension

Head to head

Craft
8.89.5
Story
7.89.6
Direction
8.49.7
Performances
8.99.3

Parasite edges it by 1.2. See them side by side

ExcellentHow we score

The verdict

Conclave is intelligent, gripping and handsomely produced, with a first-rate central performance and an ensemble clearly relishing its intrigue. Its characters are sometimes more schematic than complex and its ending is a gamble that does not land for everyone. As an unusually literate thriller, it earns an 8.2.

Quick answers

Is Conclave worth watching?

Voxizer scores Conclave (2024) 8.2 out of 10 — excellent. Conclave is intelligent, gripping and handsomely produced, with a first-rate central performance and an ensemble clearly relishing its intrigue. Its characters are sometimes more schematic than complex and its ending is a gamble that does not land for everyone.

What readers say

Written by Voxizer members and checked by our moderators before they appear.

Written reviews

–

No written reviews yet

Write a review
9–10
0
7–8.5
0
5–6.5
0
3–4.5
0
0–2.5
0

Nobody has reviewed Conclave yet. Be the first.

All reviews →

Verified sources

Published by the Voxizer editorial team — David Abellán, Ignacio Pineda, Pablo Huguet. Section editor for movies: David Abellán.

Revision history

  1. Published

Scores are revised when the facts behind them change, and the change is recorded here. How we score.