Skip to content
Album reviewExcellent

Cowboy Carter · 2024

Cowboy Carter: Beyoncé's sprawling, brilliant argument about who owns country

Cowboy Carter sees Beyoncé take on country, folk and Americana across 27 tracks, an ambitious and often thrilling album that is weighed down by its length.

Voxizer EditorialSection editor Pablo Huguet3 min read

Excellent

Editorial score out of 10

Beyoncé's move into country was never going to be a simple change of costume. Cowboy Carter is framed as a reclamation: an argument that the genre's roots run through Black musicians who were written out of its commercial story, and that an artist from Houston has as much claim to it as anyone. The album makes that argument with enormous confidence and, at its best, with real beauty.

8.0
Editorial score
#40
Of 44 albums reviewed
2024
Released
27
Tracks

It is also exhausting in a way her tightest records are not. The ideas and performances are frequently thrilling, but a leaner edit could have made it a masterpiece rather than an excellent, overstuffed statement.

Texas Hold 'Em is the obvious crowd-pleaser, a banjo-driven line-dance invitation that crossed over to a country audience in a way few expected.

The songs

The opening Ameriican Requiem sets the tone, part hymn and part manifesto, with stacked harmonies addressing the question of who gets to be called country. Blackbiird, a cover of the Beatles song sung with four young Black country artists, turns a civil-rights-era composition into a gentle passing of the baton. 16 Carriages is one of the finest songs Beyoncé has recorded, a weary, gospel-tinged account of working since childhood.

Texas Hold 'Em is the obvious crowd-pleaser, a banjo-driven line-dance invitation that crossed over to a country audience in a way few expected. The reworked Jolene flips Dolly Parton's plea into a warning, and Daughter moves from murder ballad into a startling operatic passage.

Cowboy Carter
Cowboy CarterBeyoncé

Performance and production

Vocally, this is a showcase. Beyoncé shifts between clipped, twangy phrasing, soaring gospel, a hushed folk register and full-throated rock, often inside a single song. The production, overseen with a large team of collaborators, avoids lazy imitation of Nashville radio. Instead it layers acoustic guitars, pedal steel and handclaps with the low end and vocal stacking of contemporary R&B, so that the album sounds like its own hybrid rather than a pastiche.

Guest appearances are mixed. The spoken interludes from Linda Martell, one of the first Black women to find success in commercial country, and Willie Nelson as a genial radio host carry real historical weight. Duets with Miley Cyrus and Post Malone are pleasant but less revealing.

The length problem

This is where the album stumbles. After a remarkably strong first half, the running order grows restless: there are interludes, a flamenco sketch, a Nancy Sinatra and Beach Boys collage in Ya Ya, and late tracks such as Riiverdance and Tyrant that lean back towards club music. Individually many are enjoyable, but together they blur the concept and test patience. The radio-station framing explains the variety without fully justifying it.

Who it is for

Cowboy Carter is best approached as a double album to be heard in sittings. Listeners who come for the country songs will find the richest material early on; those who follow Beyoncé's larger project of reclaiming Black musical history will find the whole sprawl rewarding.

What works

  • Beyoncé's vocal range and control are at their most versatile here
  • Linda Martell and Willie Nelson cameos frame a sharp point about history
  • Texas Hold 'Em and 16 Carriages are superb, very different entry points
  • Clever reinterpretations of Jolene and Blackbiird add new perspectives

What doesn’t

  • At around 78 minutes, the running order sags badly in its second half
  • Radio-show interludes and genre detours dilute the country concept
  • Some guest duets feel more like marquee pairings than real conversations

Head to head

Cohesion
7.18.4
Production
8.69.0
Performance
9.09.1
Songwriting
8.29.3

Blonde edges it by 0.9. See them side by side

ExcellentHow we score

The verdict

At its best, Cowboy Carter is as ambitious and beautifully sung as anything in Beyoncé's catalogue, and its central argument about the history of American music is made with intelligence and conviction. The 8.0 reflects excellent songwriting and outstanding performance held back by an album that is at least a third longer than it needs to be. It was deservedly celebrated and widely debated, and both responses make sense.

Quick answers

Is Cowboy Carter worth listening to?

Voxizer scores Cowboy Carter (2024) 8.0 out of 10 — excellent. At its best, Cowboy Carter is as ambitious and beautifully sung as anything in Beyoncé's catalogue, and its central argument about the history of American music is made with intelligence and conviction. The 8.

What readers say

Written by Voxizer members and checked by our moderators before they appear.

Written reviews

–

No written reviews yet

Write a review
9–10
0
7–8.5
0
5–6.5
0
3–4.5
0
0–2.5
0

Nobody has reviewed Cowboy Carter yet. Be the first.

All reviews →

Verified sources

Published by the Voxizer editorial team — David Abellán, Ignacio Pineda, Pablo Huguet. Section editor for albums: Pablo Huguet.

Revision history

  1. text revised
  2. Published

Scores are revised when the facts behind them change, and the change is recorded here. How we score.