Dune · 2021
Dune: a monumental, immersive opening chapter that stops just as it takes off
Dune review: Denis Villeneuve's 2021 adaptation is a huge feat of scale, sound and design, though it covers only half the story and stays emotionally cool.
Excellent
Editorial score out of 10
For decades, Frank Herbert's Dune was considered close to unfilmable. David Lynch's 1984 adaptation became a notorious, if cultishly admired, misfire, and a planned Alejandro Jodorowsky version never came to pass. Denis Villeneuve's approach was to split the story in two and to treat it with complete seriousness, and the result is a film of overwhelming scale and precision that set a new standard for big-screen science fiction.
- 8.5
- Editorial score
- #61
- Of 112 movies reviewed
- 2021
- Released
- 9.6
- Best at: Craft
It also has the frustrations of a first half. It is all setup and escalation, ending at a point where most films would be reaching their midpoint.
On a large screen with a powerful sound system, the effect is overwhelming in the best sense.
Houses and politics
The story's political web, involving the Emperor, the rival houses Atreides and Harkonnen, the Bene Gesserit sisterhood and the native Fremen of Arrakis, is dense, but Villeneuve and his co-writers Jon Spaihts and Eric Roth manage it with admirable clarity. Scenes are built around key relationships rather than exposition dumps, so audiences unfamiliar with the novel can follow the essentials.
The first hour moves deliberately, introducing Caladan's rainy seas, the Atreides household and the test Paul undergoes with the Reverend Mother. Once the family arrives on Arrakis, tension grows steadily towards a spectacular betrayal and a flight into the desert.

Cast
Timothée Chalamet makes a convincing Paul, a slight, watchful young man burdened by visions and expectation. Rebecca Ferguson is outstanding as Lady Jessica, torn between her role as mother and her training as a Bene Gesserit, and she provides the film's emotional heat. Oscar Isaac brings noble warmth to Duke Leto, Jason Momoa is a lively Duncan Idaho, and Stellan Skarsgård's Baron Harkonnen is a floating, grotesque menace.
Zendaya's Chani, heavily featured in marketing, appears largely in dreamlike visions and a short final stretch. Javier Bardem and Sharon Duncan-Brewster make strong impressions in limited screen time.
Scale and sound
Dune's visual and sonic design is its triumph. Greig Fraser's cinematography captures brutalist architecture, dusty ochre landscapes and ornithopters that move like dragonflies. The sandworms are presented with a sense of godlike size, and Patrice Vermette's production design gives each culture a distinct, monolithic identity. The film won numerous Academy Awards in technical categories, including cinematography, score and sound.
Hans Zimmer's score uses throat singing, bagpipes, percussion and wailing vocals to create something ancient and alien. On a large screen with a powerful sound system, the effect is overwhelming in the best sense.
Distance and incompleteness
The film's seriousness is also a limitation. Humour is scarce and characters speak in grave, measured tones, which can make the drama feel cool rather than involving. The decision to end at a transitional moment is faithful to the plan of a two-part story, but viewing it on its own leaves a sense of anticipation rather than completion.
What works
- Colossal sense of scale in its ships, sandworms and landscapes
- Hans Zimmer's score and the sound design are thunderously immersive
- Rebecca Ferguson's Lady Jessica is the film's emotional core
- Clear, confident handling of a notoriously dense source novel
What doesn’t
- Ends abruptly, feeling like the first half of a single film
- Its sombre, stately tone can feel emotionally remote
- Zendaya's Chani appears mostly in visions and brief scenes
Head to head
- Craft
- 9.69.7
- Story
- 7.68.5
- Direction
- 9.09.3
- Performances
- 8.38.8
Dune: Part Two edges it by 0.4. See them side by side
The verdict
Dune is a technically dazzling achievement and a remarkably coherent adaptation of difficult material, with excellent performances and some of the most spectacular imagery in modern blockbusters. Its emotional reserve and incomplete narrative mean it plays best as the opening movement of a larger work. On its own terms, it earns an 8.5.





