Elden Ring · 2022
Elden Ring pours FromSoftware's precision into a world of boundless discovery
Elden Ring review: FromSoftware's open-world epic, with a mythos by George R.R. Martin, pairs peerless exploration with brutal bosses and a few rough edges.
Masterpiece
Editorial score out of 10
Elden Ring is FromSoftware's most ambitious game and the one that brought its style of design to the widest audience. It takes the demanding combat, cryptic storytelling and intricate level design of the Souls games and places them in a vast open world, where the freedom to wander off and find something else becomes an answer to nearly every challenge.
- 9.6
- Editorial score
- #2
- Of 116 games reviewed
- 2022
- Released
- 9.8
- Best at: Longevity
The result is one of the defining games of its era. It has flaws, particularly in its late game, but its sense of wonder and discovery is extraordinary.
The sense of scale, from the Erdtree towering over the landscape to hidden underground worlds, is breathtaking.
How it plays
Combat builds on the Souls formula with welcome additions. Jumping allows new attacks, stealth lets players pick off enemies, and Spirit Ashes summon allies to help in battle. Ashes of War let players customise weapon skills, and a wide range of builds, from sorcerers to heavily armoured warriors, are viable.
Torrent, a spectral horse, transforms exploration and allows fights on horseback. The world is dense with caves, catacombs, ruins and enemies, and nearly every direction offers something new. Crucially, if a boss is too difficult, players can go elsewhere, grow stronger and return later.
Legacy dungeons, large handcrafted castles and cities, provide the game's most intricate level design. They are among the best spaces FromSoftware has built, combining interconnected paths and memorable bosses.
The weaknesses become more obvious over time. Smaller dungeons reuse layouts and bosses, and late-game encounters can feature aggressive, long combos that feel less readable than earlier fights.

World and story
The Lands Between is a haunting, beautiful place, with golden trees, ruined castles and eerie landscapes. Its history, shaped by George R.R. Martin's mythos and Miyazaki's storytelling, is conveyed through item descriptions, conversations and environments.
The main story is enigmatic but compelling, focusing on demigods, broken orders and ancient conflicts. Side characters have intriguing questlines, but these are often obscure and can be missed without guides.
Shadow of the Erdtree, released in 2024, adds a vast new area with some of the most challenging and memorable content in the game, and stands as one of the best expansions of recent years, even if its difficulty proved divisive.
Presentation
Art direction is magnificent, with vast vistas, colossal architecture and imaginative creature design. The sense of scale, from the Erdtree towering over the landscape to hidden underground worlds, is breathtaking. The orchestral score lends drama to boss battles.
Technically, performance at launch was inconsistent, particularly on PC, where stuttering was a widely reported issue. Later updates improved matters, but the game is not a technical showcase.
Who it is for
This is essential for fans of action RPGs and open worlds, and it is the most accessible FromSoftware game for newcomers thanks to its flexibility. It is still challenging, however, and players who dislike difficulty or cryptic storytelling may find it daunting. The size of the world demands a significant commitment.
What works
- An open world packed with genuine discoveries rather than checklists
- Torrent, stealth and spirit summons give players real freedom in combat
- Legacy dungeons like Stormveil Castle are among the studio's finest
- Shadow of the Erdtree is an expansion of rare scale and quality
What doesn’t
- Reused bosses and repetitive catacombs thin out the late game
- Late-game difficulty spikes feel less fair than earlier challenges
- Obscure questlines are easily missed without outside help
Head to head
- Story
- 9.09.0
- Gameplay
- 9.68.0
- Longevity
- 9.88.2
- Presentation
- 9.49.0
Elden Ring edges it by 1.5. See them side by side
The verdict
Elden Ring earns a landmark score for combining FromSoftware's precision with a truly open world full of discovery, and for doing so at a scale few thought possible. Repetitive late-game content and some difficulty spikes are small blemishes on a game that won Game of the Year at The Game Awards and deserves its place among the best ever made.





