folklore · 2020
folklore: Taylor Swift steps out of the spotlight and finds a storyteller's voice
folklore is Taylor Swift's hushed, story-driven lockdown album with Aaron Dessner, a graceful reinvention whose quiet palette occasionally blurs together.
Excellent
Editorial score out of 10
For most of her career, Taylor Swift's songs were read as diary entries, decoded line by line for clues about her life. folklore is the album where she deliberately changed the game. Recorded in isolation during 2020 and released with almost no warning, it is a collection of short stories, with narrators who are not always Swift and settings that range from a Rhode Island mansion to a teenage summer romance.
- 8.5
- Editorial score
- #31
- Of 44 albums reviewed
- 2020
- Released
- 16
- Tracks
The shift in sound is just as pronounced. Pop hooks give way to piano figures and gentle strings, and the result is her most critically admired record, and the one that persuaded many sceptics to take her writing seriously.
folklore is the obvious recommendation for listeners who have never been drawn to Swift's pop albums but enjoy singer-songwriter or indie folk records.
The writing
The lyrics are the reason to listen. the last great american dynasty tells the story of Rebekah Harkness, a socialite who once lived in a house Swift later bought, and then quietly writes Swift herself into the final verse. my tears ricochet imagines a funeral from the point of view of a ghost watching an old adversary. mirrorball is a lovely, self-aware portrait of an entertainer who will do anything to be liked.
The standout conceit is the teenage love triangle told across cardigan, august and betty, three songs that each narrate the same story from a different perspective. It is a novelist's trick, and Swift pulls it off with detail that makes the characters feel lived-in.

The sound
Aaron Dessner's production brings the soft-focus textures of his work with The National: repeating piano motifs, brushed drums, drones and swelling strings. Jack Antonoff contributes a handful of songs, including the understated mirrorball. exile, sung with Justin Vernon of Bon Iver, is the most dramatic moment, his deep, dark opening verse answered by Swift before the two voices collide.
The limits of the approach show over the full running time. The palette rarely changes, and songs such as peace, epiphany and hoax, all fine on their own, lose some impact by sitting together in the album's slower second half.
Performance
Swift sings with more restraint here than on any earlier record, favouring a close, conversational delivery that suits the storytelling. It is not a showy vocal album, but the phrasing is careful, and the understatement makes the more emotional peaks land.
Who it is for
folklore is the obvious recommendation for listeners who have never been drawn to Swift's pop albums but enjoy singer-songwriter or indie folk records. Long-time fans will find her writing at its most ambitious. It is best heard as a whole, in a quiet room, rather than skipped through for singles.
What works
- Swift's most literary writing, full of character and precise detail
- The cardigan, august and betty trio tells one story from three angles
- Aaron Dessner's piano-and-strings settings are subtle and warm
- exile with Bon Iver is a gripping, genuinely dramatic duet
What doesn’t
- The muted, mid-tempo palette makes the back half run together
- At over an hour, a few songs could have been cut without loss
- Some of the production feels tasteful to the point of timidity
Head to head
- Cohesion
- 8.48.6
- Production
- 8.39.0
- Performance
- 8.58.7
- Songwriting
- 9.08.5
folklore edges it by 0.1. See them side by side
The verdict
folklore earns an 8.5: an excellent album with some of the finest songwriting of Swift's career and a creative partnership that opened a new chapter for her. It won the Grammy for Album of the Year, and its reputation among critics has endured. Its uniform mood and generous length hold it back from true greatness, but as a reinvention made under strange circumstances, it remains remarkably assured.




