Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood · 2009
Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood is the rare epic that gets almost everything right
Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood review: Bones' faithful adaptation of Hiromu Arakawa's manga is a superbly plotted fantasy epic about sacrifice and hubris.
Masterpiece
Editorial score out of 10
Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood has spent years near the top of fan rankings, and it is easy to see why. It is a sweeping fantasy adventure with a clear moral core, a complex political conspiracy, memorable villains and an ending that pulls its many threads together with remarkable confidence. Few long-form stories, animated or otherwise, are this well structured.
- 9.5
- Editorial score
- #3
- Of 93 anime reviewed
- 2009
- Released
- 64
- Episodes
Its accessibility is part of the achievement. It can be enjoyed simply as an exciting adventure, yet it also deals seriously with genocide, military complicity and the cost of trying to cheat loss, without ever becoming preachy.
Both the Japanese cast and the English dub are highly regarded, a rarity that has helped the show reach a wide audience.
Story
Brotherhood exists because the earlier 2003 adaptation ran ahead of Arakawa's manga and invented its own storyline. This version follows the source to its conclusion, and the difference is striking. What begins as a quest for the Philosopher's Stone expands into a conspiracy reaching the highest levels of the nation, involving the mysterious homunculi and a long-planned scheme hidden within Amestris's history.
The plotting is exceptional. Details introduced early resurface much later with new meaning, and multiple storylines, from military intrigue to a neighbouring country's royal succession, converge naturally. The main weakness is at the start: the opening episodes rush through events that viewers of the 2003 series already knew, which can make some early emotional beats feel compressed for newcomers. The climax, though thrilling, is also very long.

Characters
Edward and Alphonse make a compelling pair: Ed is brash, stubborn and quick-witted, and Al is gentle and thoughtful despite his imposing armour. Their bond is the story's anchor. Around them is one of anime's finest ensembles: Roy Mustang, the ambitious Flame Alchemist with his own reasons for seeking power; Winry, the brothers' mechanic and friend; Scar, a vengeful survivor of a state-sanctioned massacre; and homunculi, each named for a sin and given distinct personality. Even minor figures often receive arcs that pay off, and the series treats its antagonists with notable nuance.
Animation and sound
Bones delivers consistently strong animation across a long run. Alchemy is visualised with crackling transmutation circles and inventive transformations of the environment, and major fights are fluid and well choreographed. Character designs are clean and expressive, suited to both comedy and tragedy. The frequent comic interludes, with characters shrinking into cartoonish forms, are true to the manga but can feel jarring at dramatic moments.
Akira Senju's score is grand and stirring, with choral pieces that underline the story's epic scope. The series cycled through several opening themes by well-known Japanese artists, including YUI's popular first opening. Both the Japanese cast and the English dub are highly regarded, a rarity that has helped the show reach a wide audience.
Who it is for
Practically anyone who enjoys fantasy, adventure or character-driven drama should watch it. It is an excellent introduction to anime and a satisfying experience for veterans. Its darker content, including war atrocities and body horror, makes it better suited to teenagers and adults. The earlier 2003 series is worth seeing separately as a different interpretation.
What works
- Tightly plotted from start to finish, with nearly every thread paying off
- A huge cast in which heroes, villains and side characters all get real arcs
- Handles war crimes, grief and moral responsibility with serious weight
- Balances humour, horror and action without losing its tonal footing
What doesn’t
- Early episodes race through material the 2003 series had already adapted
- Comic chibi gags sometimes undercut tense or tragic scenes
- The extended final battle stretches over several episodes
Head to head
- Sound
- 9.19.7
- Story
- 9.69.5
- Animation
- 9.09.8
- Characters
- 9.59.4
Princess Mononoke edges it by 0.1. See them side by side
The verdict
Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood is a landmark of television anime: brilliantly plotted, richly populated and emotionally resonant from start to finish. Its rushed early episodes and occasionally jarring humour are minor blemishes on a story that delivers on almost every promise. Its enduring acclaim is thoroughly deserved, and a 9.5 marks it as one of the medium's all-time great achievements.





