Her · 2013
Her: Spike Jonze's tender, prescient love story between a man and his software
Her review: Spike Jonze's near-future romance is gentle, witty and melancholy, led by Joaquin Phoenix and Scarlett Johansson's remarkable voice performance.
Excellent
Editorial score out of 10
Her could easily have been a satire or a cautionary tale about technology. Spike Jonze instead made something gentler and more unusual: a sincere love story that uses its speculative premise to explore loneliness, intimacy and the ways people grow apart. It won the Academy Award for Best Original Screenplay and has become increasingly relevant as conversational software has become part of everyday life.
- 8.7
- Editorial score
- #47
- Of 112 movies reviewed
- 2013
- Released
- 9.1
- Best at: Performances
It is also a film of great visual and emotional delicacy, anchored by two remarkable performances, one of which is heard but never seen.
Both are rather underused, and a fuller exploration of Theodore's human relationships might have strengthened the contrast.
Theodore and Samantha
Theodore works at a company that produces handwritten-style letters for clients who want to express love or gratitude, a detail that neatly establishes his gift for emotional articulation and his difficulty applying it to his own life. He is separated from his childhood sweetheart Catherine and has retreated into video games and solitude.
The arrival of Samantha, a curious, witty and quickly evolving operating system, changes that. Their relationship develops through conversations, shared observations and a growing sense of discovery, and Jonze treats it without condescension. The film acknowledges that others find it strange, but it is more interested in what the relationship gives Theodore, and in Samantha's own evolving sense of self.

The performances
Joaquin Phoenix gives one of his most tender performances, with a high-waisted wardrobe, a moustache and a soft, hesitant manner. He is funny in his awkwardness and deeply sympathetic in his yearning, and he spends much of the film acting opposite an earpiece.
Scarlett Johansson's voice performance is extraordinary. Without any physical presence, she creates a character who is playful, curious, sensual and eventually overwhelming in her capacity to grow. Johansson replaced another actor's recorded performance during post-production, and it is hard now to imagine the film without her.
Amy Adams is lovely as Theodore's friend Amy, a documentary maker going through her own relationship difficulties, and Rooney Mara brings sharpness to flashbacks of Catherine. Both are rather underused, and a fuller exploration of Theodore's human relationships might have strengthened the contrast.
A soft future
K.K. Barrett's production design imagines a near future without chrome or dystopian gloom. Los Angeles, partly created using location footage from Shanghai, is dense, clean and warm, filled with high-rise apartments, subway trains and crowds absorbed in their devices. Clothes are retro and colourful, and technology is discreet, often reduced to a small earpiece and a pocket device.
Hoyte van Hoytema's cinematography is bathed in reds, oranges and pinks, and the score by Arcade Fire and Owen Pallett is gentle and melancholy. Karen O's The Moon Song, performed by Samantha and Theodore, is a small, perfect moment.
Pacing
The film's middle section, after the relationship becomes established, loses some momentum and can feel repetitive. The story's later developments, which explore the fundamental differences between Theodore and Samantha, restore the tension and lead to a quietly moving conclusion.
What works
- Scarlett Johansson creates a vivid character through voice alone
- Joaquin Phoenix is vulnerable, funny and deeply sympathetic
- Its soft, pastel near-future is subtle and convincingly designed
- Treats a strange premise with warmth rather than mockery
What doesn’t
- The middle stretch loses momentum as the relationship settles
- Amy Adams and Rooney Mara are underused in key roles
Head to head
- Craft
- 8.99.0
- Story
- 8.69.5
- Direction
- 8.89.1
- Performances
- 9.19.2
Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind edges it by 0.5. See them side by side
The verdict
Her is a thoughtful, beautifully made and emotionally honest film that has only become more resonant with time. Its pacing sags in the middle and some supporting characters are underexplored, but the central performances and the delicacy of Jonze's vision are exceptional. It earns an 8.7.





