Skip to content
Album reviewEssential

Homogenic · 1997

Homogenic: strings and static in one landscape, and Björk's most complete record

Homogenic review. Björk's 1997 third album marries Icelandic strings to rough electronic beats, and remains the clearest statement of what she does.

Voxizer EditorialSection editor Pablo Huguet8 min read

Essential

Editorial score out of 10

Homogenic is the album where Björk stopped trying things on and decided what she was. Her first two solo records were cheerful raids on whatever sounded new in London in the early 1990s: house, big band, trip hop, a show tune. This one picks two ingredients, strings and programmed beats, and refuses to add a third. The result is the most coherent record she has made and, nearly three decades later, the one that still sounds least like anybody else.

9.4
Editorial score
#11
Of 44 albums reviewed
1997
Released
10
Tracks

It is also a harder listen than its reputation suggests. The beats are rough and sometimes punishing, the melodies are long and unhurried, and there is very little here built to be hummed on the bus. Homogenic asks for attention and pays it back generously, which is a different bargain from the one Debut and Post offered.

Context

By 1996 Björk was one of the most visible musicians in Britain, and the visibility had turned dangerous. A stalker posted an acid bomb to her London home, the police intercepted it, and the press attention that followed made the house unworkable as a studio. Early sessions there with the engineer Markus Dravs had already produced 5 Years, one of the first songs written for the album. The rest of the record moved to El Cortijo, a studio near Málaga offered by her tour drummer Trevor Morais, where she worked with a smaller, chosen group of collaborators.

The most important of them was Mark Bell, one half of the Sheffield techno duo LFO, whom she would later cite as a major influence on her music; Homogenic was the first of their many records together. Nellee Hooper, who had co-produced Debut and Post, was not part of this one. Guy Sigsworth, Howie B and Dravs fill out the credits, but the sound of the record is the sound of Björk and Bell together.

  1. 1993

    Debut, produced with Nellee Hooper, is released by One Little Indian

  2. 1995

    Post follows, a wider and more playful collection of styles

  3. 1996

    A stalker's attack drives recording out of her London home

  4. 1997

    Homogenic is completed in Spain and released in September

  5. 1998

    Wins her a Brit Award for International Female Solo Artist

The concept was stated plainly at the time: Iceland, a place where the landscape is volcanic and the population is among the most wired in Europe. The strings were meant to stand for the old country, the beats for the new one and for the ground itself. That is a neat idea on paper. What makes the record work is that it never feels like an idea on paper.

Homogenic
HomogenicFrame from the official Bachelorette video, directed by Michel Gondry; via björk on YouTube

The songs

The record opens with Hunter, a martial snare figure under a slow, coiled melody and a string part that seems to circle its prey. It is a statement of intent rather than a welcome, and it tells a listener everything about the next forty minutes: patient, rhythmic, cold on the surface and very warm underneath.

Jóga comes next and remains the heart of the album. The strings, played by the Icelandic String Octet, carry a melody of enormous breadth, and underneath them Bell's beats crack and rumble like shifting rock. The lyric, written with the poet Sjón and addressed to a close friend, is about emotional states as terrain, and the production makes that literal. Bachelorette, also written with Sjón, is grander still: a dramatic, almost operatic string arrangement in which a woman tells her own story as it is being written, with a melodrama the record otherwise keeps in check.

Where to start
TrackWhy
JógaThe album's whole idea in five minutes: strings above, tectonic beats below
BacheloretteThe most cinematic arrangement she has recorded, and a superb vocal
All Is Full of LoveThe gentlest track, with harp and strings over a soft pulse
HunterThe opener, and the clearest sense of the record's discipline
5 YearsFor anyone who wants to hear how hard the beats can push

The middle of the record is where it asks most of the listener. All Neon Like is long, glittering and slow to resolve. 5 Years is a bitter address to a lover who cannot cope with being loved, set against beats that clatter and distort. Immature and Unravel are smaller, more private songs; Unravel in particular, built with Sigsworth around a sustained organ and a hushed vocal, is lovely but easy to pass over between bigger moments. Alarm Call lightens the mood with a bouncing, almost hip-hop rhythm and an optimism the album has earned by then.

Pluto is the outlier, a blast of distorted techno and screamed vocals that some listeners will find thrilling and others will skip on every play. It is placed well, a release of pressure before the calmer final stretch, but it is also the moment the record's discipline comes closest to testing its audience's patience.

Watch
Homogenic — trailer

Production

Bell's contribution is the reason Homogenic does not sound like a dated late-1990s electronica record. His beats are not built for dancing. They have mass and grain, they crackle and break up, and they sit in the mix like something physical rather than a loop running under a song. Against them the strings are recorded close and warm, and Eumir Deodato's orchestration gives the larger arrangements a sweep that recalls film scores without ever turning into one.

Two ingredients, held in tension for forty-three minutes: strings for the old country, beats for the ground beneath it.

The small touches are chosen as carefully as the big ones. Accordion and glass harmonica appear in places, but sparingly; the record's restraint is the point. Where Post threw a new instrument at each song, Homogenic takes a narrow set of colours and finds out how far they go. The answer is a long way.

Gallery · 3 imagesFrame from the official Hunter video, directed by Paul White; via björk on YouTube · Frame from the official Bachelorette video, directed by Michel Gondry; via björk on YouTube · Frame from the official Alarm Call video, directed by Alexander McQueen; via björk on YouTube

Performance

Björk's voice is the third element, and it has rarely been used with more control. She moves from a near-spoken murmur to full-throated cries within a phrase, sometimes in a style that echoes the declamatory singing of Icelandic male choirs. On Jóga and Bachelorette the vocal rides above the strings with a power that would be overwhelming if the melodies were less shapely. On Unravel and All Is Full of Love she pulls back almost to nothing, and the songs are better for it.

There is also more anger here than on the earlier records, especially in 5 Years and Pluto, and the voice is pushed into rough, unlovely registers to carry it. Not everyone will want to hear that. It is, however, what makes the gentler songs land, because the record has shown it is not simply pretty.

How it feels

Energy
6/10
Bursts of force between long, slow builds
Intimacy
8/10
Personal lyrics, close-miked strings and voice
Density
7/10
Few elements, but each one carries weight
Accessibility
5/10
Jóga and Bachelorette welcome you; Pluto does not

Cohesion and legacy

The working title was Homogeneous, and it was a manifesto: Björk wanted an album with "only one flavour", and she got one. That narrowness is its great strength. Every track is recognisably part of the same world, and the sequencing moves from tension to release with real care. It is also the reason some listeners prefer Post, which is messier, funnier and more various.

Homogenic was nominated for a Grammy for Best Alternative Music Performance and lost to Radiohead's OK Computer, released the same year, which is the comparison worth drawing. Both are records about the uneasy meeting of technology and feeling. Radiohead's is anxious and urban; Björk's is elemental and, in the end, hopeful. Three years later Radiohead's Kid A turned towards electronics too, by a very different route.

Head to head

Cohesion
9.59.6
Production
9.69.5
Performance
9.49.4
Songwriting
9.39.6

OK Computer edges it by 0.1. See them side by side

The record's videos, by Michel Gondry, Paul White, Alexander McQueen and Chris Cunningham, extended its world into images that are as well remembered as the songs, and the album set the template for much of what she made next. Vespertine and everything after it start from the idea, proven here, that strings and electronics can be one instrument.

For you if

  • Listeners who want an album with a single, consistent world to live inside
  • Anyone who knows Jóga or All Is Full of Love and wants the record around them
  • Fans of electronic music who like their beats with grit and weight

Not for you if

  • Anyone looking for the bright, eclectic pop of Debut and Post
  • Listeners with no patience for abrasive tracks such as Pluto
  • Those who want a record to work in the background rather than demand attention

The album is best heard in order and in one sitting, as its sequencing intends; the official site gathers the videos and the rest of the catalogue.

What works

  • One deliberately narrow palette of strings and beats, held across all ten tracks
  • Jóga and Bachelorette are among the strongest singles of her career
  • Mark Bell's beats sound like rock and weather rather than club furniture
  • The voice ranges from a near-whisper to a scream without losing the melody

What doesn’t

  • Pluto and 5 Years are abrasive enough to stop casual listeners cold
  • The narrow palette means less variety than the playful Post offered
  • Immature and Unravel are slight beside the singles around them
EssentialHow we score

The verdict

Homogenic is the record on which Björk's ambitions and her means finally matched. The decision to work with only strings and beats could have produced a stiff exercise; instead it yields an album in which every element earns its place and the emotional range runs from fury to tenderness without leaving the same landscape. A couple of slighter songs and a few deliberately abrasive moments keep it just short of the very top tier, and listeners who loved the variety of Post may find it severe. For everyone else it is the essential Björk album, and one of the defining records of the late 1990s.

Quick answers

Is Homogenic worth listening to?

Voxizer scores Homogenic (1997) 9.4 out of 10 — essential. Homogenic is the record on which Björk's ambitions and her means finally matched. The decision to work with only strings and beats could have produced a stiff exercise; instead it yields an album in which every element earns its place and the emotional range runs from fury to tenderness without leaving the same landscape.

Who will enjoy Homogenic?

Listeners who want an album with a single, consistent world to live inside. Anyone who knows Jóga or All Is Full of Love and wants the record around them. Fans of electronic music who like their beats with grit and weight.

Who should skip Homogenic?

Anyone looking for the bright, eclectic pop of Debut and Post. Listeners with no patience for abrasive tracks such as Pluto. Those who want a record to work in the background rather than demand attention.

What is Homogenic like, in short?

Two ingredients, strings and beats, held in balance across ten tracks without a detour. Jóga and Bachelorette are the entry points, and still the best things she has released as singles. Mark Bell's programming gives the electronics a physical, geological weight. A few tracks are abrasive by design; this is not the easy Björk record.

What readers say

Written by Voxizer members and checked by our moderators before they appear.

Written reviews

–

No written reviews yet

Write a review
9–10
0
7–8.5
0
5–6.5
0
3–4.5
0
0–2.5
0

Nobody has reviewed Homogenic yet. Be the first.

All reviews →

Verified sources

Published by the Voxizer editorial team — David Abellán, Ignacio Pineda, Pablo Huguet. Section editor for albums: Pablo Huguet.

Revision history

  1. Published

Scores are revised when the facts behind them change, and the change is recorded here. How we score.