Skip to content
Hardware reviewEssential#5 in hardware

IBM Model M · 1985

IBM Model M: the keyboard that set the layout, and still sets the standard for feel

IBM Model M review. The 1985 buckling-spring keyboard fixed the PC layout and is still made today; loud, heavy and limited, but very hard to wear out.

Voxizer EditorialSection editor Pablo Huguet9 min read

Essential

Editorial score out of 10

Forty years after it first shipped, the IBM Model M is still the keyboard others are measured against. It fixed where the arrow keys, the function row and the numeric keypad sit on a PC keyboard, it made a loud mechanical click into a mark of quality, and the design is still being manufactured, on IBM's own tooling, in Kentucky. Very few products from 1985 can be bought new. This is one of them.

9.0
Editorial score
#5
Of 33 hardware reviewed
1985
Released
9.6
Best at: Design

That longevity is the case for the Model M, and also the caveat. It types beautifully, it is built like office furniture and it will probably outlive the next three computers on your desk. It is also heavy, noisy and plain by the standards of anything sold today, and its electronics were designed for a world without gaming, macros or USB. Whether that adds up to a classic or a curio depends on what you ask a keyboard to do.

What it is

The Model M is less a single keyboard than a family, built in dozens of variants by IBM from 1985, by Lexmark after IBM spun off its printer and keyboard business in 1991, and by Unicomp since 1996. What unites them is the switch and, in most cases, the layout. The best known is part number 1391401, the 101-key board sold with IBM's PS/2 computers from 1987, and it is the one most people mean when they say "Model M".

It was not the first keyboard to carry IBM's buckling spring. The Model F, which shipped with the original IBM PC, used springs over a capacitive circuit board and is, by most accounts, the more refined mechanism. The Model M kept the spring and put it over a cheaper plastic membrane, which let IBM build it in much greater numbers. By a widely cited estimate, more than ten million were shipped during the IBM and Lexmark years.

  1. 1983

    Principal design work on the Model M begins at IBM

  2. 1985

    The first Model M is announced with the IBM 3161 terminal

  3. 1986

    The Enhanced Keyboard ships with IBM's PC AT and PC XT

  4. 1987

    Part number 1391401 becomes standard with the PS/2 line

  5. 1991

    Lexmark takes over IBM's keyboard manufacturing

  6. 1996

    Unicomp acquires the designs and tooling in Lexington, Kentucky

The layout matters as much as the switch. IBM borrowed the inverted-T arrangement of cursor keys from the keyboard of DEC's VT220 terminal, moved the function keys into a row across the top and gave the numeric keypad its own block. Earlier PC keyboards had put the function keys in a column on the left and doubled the keypad as cursor control. After the Model M, that arrangement disappeared, and the one on your desk today, unless it is a compact or split board, is a descendant.

IBM Model M
IBM Model MBorgHunter, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

How it types

Under every key is a coiled spring standing on a membrane, held in a barrel. Press the key and the spring bows sideways until, at a fixed point, it buckles: it snaps over, a small hammer at its base strikes the membrane, and the keystroke registers at the same moment the finger feels the break. The click is the spring hitting the barrel wall. IBM has written that the patent for the switch describes this as audible feedback for the operator, which is to say the noise was designed in rather than tolerated.

What that produces, as widely described by typists and keyboard enthusiasts, is an unusually unambiguous key. There is no question of whether a press has registered, and because the actuation point and the tactile point coincide, there is little reason to drive the key into the bottom of its travel. Many people who type for a living find that this lets them type with a lighter, more even touch over long sessions. Others find the force on the heavy side.

How it measures up

Typing feedback
9.5/10
The break, the click and the actuation arrive together
Noise
9/10
Higher is louder; colleagues will notice
Build and durability
9.5/10
Steel plate, thick case, decades of evidence
Gaming suitability
4/10
Limited rollover and no modern extras
Desk footprint
8/10
Full size and heavy; it stays where it is put

The trade-off is sound. A Model M is loud in a way that modern "clicky" switches only approach, and its click is lower and more resonant than theirs, partly because the whole steel-and-plastic frame carries it. In a home study that is part of the appeal. In an open-plan office, or under a microphone, it is an imposition on everyone else.

Watch
IBM Model M — trailer

Design and build

The Model M was designed for offices that expected equipment to last a decade, and it shows. A curved steel plate sits behind the key assembly, the case is thick plastic, and the full-size board weighs between two and two and a half kilos depending on its generation. Early boards came with a detachable coiled cable using IBM's own connector at the keyboard end, so a damaged lead could be swapped; from about 1994, to save money, a fixed flat cable replaced it.

The keycaps are removable, and on earlier boards they come in two pieces, a printed cap over a separate stem, which makes cleaning simple and relabelling possible. Legends on many IBM boards are dye-sublimated into PBT plastic and do not wear away with use. Later models moved to one-piece caps and printed legends, a small loss that collectors notice.

The noise was the point, not a by-product.

Age brings one recurring fault. The steel plate is held to the key assembly by melted plastic rivets, and on some old boards those rivets have become brittle and broken, which lets keys go soft or stop registering. It is a known repair, usually done by replacing the rivets with small bolts, but it is the first thing to ask about when buying one second-hand.

Gallery · 3 imagesDaniel Beardsmore, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons · Jacek Rużyczka, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Features, then and now

By modern standards the feature list is short, and it was never meant to be long. There is no backlight, no media control, no software and no macro layer, and the board has limited key rollover, so some combinations of three or more simultaneous keys may not all register. For typing, that is rarely noticeable. For games that ask for several held keys at once, it can be.

Unicomp's current range answers some of this. Its boards use the same buckling-spring mechanism on the original designs, with USB connections and layouts that add Windows keys, and in 2020 the company introduced a New Model M on fresh tooling, since joined by a smaller tenkeyless board. They do not turn the design into a gaming keyboard, and they are not meant to.

The Model M against a modern flagship
AspectIBM Model M (1391401)Corsair K100 RGB
SwitchBuckling spring over membraneCherry MX Speed or Corsair OPX
FeelTactile and clickyLinear
ConnectionPS/2 (adapter for USB)USB
ExtrasNonePer-key RGB, macro keys, control wheel
Best atLong typing sessionsGames and media control

The comparison with a modern flagship such as the Corsair K100 RGB is less a contest than a choice of purpose. One is built around a single excellent keystroke; the other around everything a keyboard can be made to do in addition to typing.

Head to head

Value
8.66.4
Design
9.67.9
Features
7.49.0
Performance
9.08.1

IBM Model M edges it by 1.3. See them side by side

Value and alternatives

The Model M's value has an odd shape. Because so many were made, and because they rarely die, original IBM boards remain easy to find second-hand, though common part numbers in good condition now command collector prices and rarer variants considerably more. A new Unicomp board costs roughly what a mid-range mechanical keyboard does and comes with a warranty, which a forty-year-old IBM does not.

The alternative within the family is the Model F, which many enthusiasts consider the better keyboard and which has also been reissued in small runs. Outside it, modern clicky switches offer a lighter version of the same idea in a quieter, smaller and more feature-rich package. None of them reproduces the buckling-spring keystroke exactly, and that, more than nostalgia, is why the Model M is still being bought.

For you if

  • Writers, programmers and anyone who types for hours and wants each keystroke confirmed
  • People who want a keyboard that will outlast several computers
  • Collectors of computing history who also want to use what they collect

Not for you if

  • Anyone sharing a room, an office or a microphone with other people
  • Players who need full rollover, macros and lighting
  • Those who want a compact, portable or wireless board

The simplest route to buckling springs today runs through Unicomp, which builds them on the design IBM handed on. IBM itself has written about the keyboard's sound and its continued production.

What works

  • Buckling springs give a crisp, consistent actuation point you can feel and hear
  • The Enhanced layout it introduced is the one most keyboards still copy
  • A steel backplate and a two-kilo frame make it stay put and outlast its computer
  • Still in production at Unicomp, so a new buckling-spring board is a choice, not a hunt

What doesn’t

  • Loud enough to be a problem in a shared office or on a voice call
  • Limited key rollover and no backlight, media keys or modern extras
  • Ageing plastic rivets that hold the backplate can fail and need a repair
EssentialHow we score

The verdict

The Model M earns its score on two counts that few products can claim together: it shaped the way nearly every later keyboard is laid out, and it remains, four decades on, one of the most satisfying keyboards to type on. Its switch makes every press unambiguous, its build makes it close to permanent, and its continued production means the experience is not confined to collectors. The marks it loses are for what it never tried to be. It is loud, heavy and spare, its rollover is limited, and an original needs an adapter and occasionally a repair to work with a modern computer. For typing, those are footnotes. For gaming or a shared office, they are reasons to look elsewhere.

Quick answers

Is IBM Model M worth buying?

Voxizer scores IBM Model M (1985) 9.0 out of 10 — essential. The Model M earns its score on two counts that few products can claim together: it shaped the way nearly every later keyboard is laid out, and it remains, four decades on, one of the most satisfying keyboards to type on. Its switch makes every press unambiguous, its build makes it close to permanent, and its continued production means the experience is not confined to collectors.

Who will enjoy IBM Model M?

Writers, programmers and anyone who types for hours and wants each keystroke confirmed. People who want a keyboard that will outlast several computers. Collectors of computing history who also want to use what they collect.

Who should skip IBM Model M?

Anyone sharing a room, an office or a microphone with other people. Players who need full rollover, macros and lighting. Those who want a compact, portable or wireless board.

What is IBM Model M like, in short?

The keyboard that established the 101-key PC layout almost every board since has followed. Buckling springs give a sharp, tactile, audible keystroke that few modern switches imitate closely. Built to last decades, with a steel plate inside and a frame that weighs over two kilos. Loud, limited in rollover and short on features; a writer's tool more than a gamer's.

What readers say

Written by Voxizer members and checked by our moderators before they appear.

Written reviews

–

No written reviews yet

Write a review
9–10
0
7–8.5
0
5–6.5
0
3–4.5
0
0–2.5
0

Nobody has reviewed IBM Model M yet. Be the first.

All reviews →

Verified sources

Published by the Voxizer editorial team — David Abellán, Ignacio Pineda, Pablo Huguet. Section editor for hardware: Pablo Huguet.

Revision history

  1. Published

Scores are revised when the facts behind them change, and the change is recorded here. How we score.