Ice Cream Man · 2018
Ice Cream Man serves suburban horror in wildly inventive, uneven single scoops
Ice Cream Man, W. Maxwell Prince and Martin Morazzo's horror anthology, is formally daring and deeply unsettling, though its quality varies issue to issue.
Good
Editorial score out of 10
Ice Cream Man has a pitch that sounds like a gag: a horror anthology hosted by a smiling ice cream van driver. In practice, it is one of the stranger and more ambitious horror comics of recent years, closer in spirit to The Twilight Zone or Black Mirror than to a slasher, and far more interested in despair than in jump scares.
- 7.4
- Editorial score
- #50
- Of 53 comics reviewed
- 2018
- Released
- 36
- Issues
As with most anthologies, the quality varies. When W. Maxwell Prince and Martin Morazzo hit, they produce single issues that linger for days. When they miss, the book can feel like an exercise in misery.
Most issues follow a new set of characters in a new situation, and the horror often emerges from very human places.
Scoops of despair
Most issues follow a new set of characters in a new situation, and the horror often emerges from very human places. The very first story, involving a young boy and his pet spider, establishes the series' template: intimate stakes, a sense of creeping wrongness and Rick the ice cream man wandering through with a knowing smile. Later stories tackle addiction, loneliness, parental failure, obsession and ageing, with supernatural elements that range from subtle to wildly surreal.
Prince also enjoys formal experimentation. Individual issues play with unusual narrative structures, experimental page layouts and genre pastiche, turning the anthology format into a playground. These are frequently the best instalments, precisely because they refuse to repeat a formula.
Morazzo and O'Halloran
Martin Morazzo's art is clean, detailed and almost clinical, with a fine line that makes suburban homes, shopping centres and hospital rooms look ordinary until something goes badly wrong. That precision gives the grotesque moments, and there are many, a genuinely queasy impact. Chris O'Halloran's colours lean on bright, candy-coated pastels that ironically echo the ice cream theme, so even the most horrifying scenes arrive wrapped in cheerful tones.
Together they excel at page layout, particularly in the experimental issues where the visual structure carries as much meaning as the script.
The trouble with the mythology
The weakest element is the overarching storyline. Rick has an ongoing conflict with forces opposed to him and a larger cosmic backstory, but these threads are presented in fragments and abstractions that rarely match the emotional punch of the standalone tales. Readers hoping for a satisfying explanation of what he is may find the answers deliberately elusive.
The tone can also wear thin in large doses. Prince's worldview is bleak, and some issues seem designed mainly to punish their characters, leaving little room for the moments of grace that make the best stories hit harder. Read in bulk, the relentless unhappiness can flatten the impact of individual tragedies.
Who it is for
Ice Cream Man suits readers who enjoy literary, psychological horror and are drawn to anthology television, as well as anyone curious about comics that experiment with form. It is best read an issue or a collection at a time rather than binged. Readers sensitive to themes of self-harm, drug use or harm to children should approach with caution, as the book does not hold back.
What works
- Formally adventurous issues play with structure, layout and genre
- Martin Morazzo's clean, precise line makes the grotesque doubly shocking
- Mostly standalone stories make it easy to dip in at almost any point
- Takes everyday sadness, from addiction to loneliness, seriously
What doesn’t
- Quality swings sharply between inspired issues and slighter ones
- Bleakness sometimes feels cruel for its own sake
- The overarching mythology is vague and less compelling than the one-offs
Head to head
- Art
- 8.28.9
- Story
- 7.38.8
- Pacing
- 7.57.6
- Characters
- 7.08.7
Immortal Hulk edges it by 1.2. See them side by side
The verdict
Ice Cream Man is a daring and genuinely unnerving series, with sharp art and some unforgettable single issues that stretch what a horror comic can do. Its unevenness, occasional gratuitous bleakness and thin connecting mythology keep it from greatness. A 7.4 reflects a good, distinctive anthology whose highs are well worth the lows.




