It Was Just an Accident · 2025
It Was Just an Accident: a revenge thriller that keeps refusing to become one
It Was Just an Accident review. Jafar Panahi's Palme d'Or winner turns a kidnapping into a tense, darkly funny argument about guilt, memory and what justice is for.
Essential
Editorial score out of 10
A man drives home at night with his wife and young daughter, hits a dog, and needs his car looked at. That is the whole of the inciting incident in Jafar Panahi's It Was Just an Accident, and the title is the first of its jokes. Nothing that follows is accidental, and almost nothing is simple. The mechanic who hears the customer's prosthetic leg squeak across the workshop floor has heard that sound before, in a prison corridor, while blindfolded.
- 9.1
- Editorial score
- #24
- Of 112 movies reviewed
- 2025
- Released
- 9.4
- Best at: Direction
Panahi made the film in secret, without the permit the Islamic Republic requires, after his own detention in Tehran's Evin prison in 2022 and 2023. That history could easily have produced a film of pure accusation. Instead it has produced a tense, frequently funny moral thriller whose real subject is uncertainty: what a person owes the truth when the only evidence is a sound, a smell and the memory of pain. It is the best thing he has made since Taxi, and the most accessible.
The premise
Vahid, played by Vahid Mobasseri, works in a garage on the edge of Tehran. He spent time in detention, like many of the people he will soon meet, and was interrogated by a man the prisoners called Eghbal, or "peg leg", for the artificial limb that announced him. When the stranger with a squeaking leg leaves the garage, Vahid follows. The next day he takes him, drives him into the desert and starts to dig.
Then he stops. The man insists he is not Eghbal, that his leg was lost recently, that he has a family waiting. Vahid has never seen his interrogator's face. He knows the voice, perhaps, and the gait. That is not nothing, but it is not certainty either, and the film's engine is his decision to go and find someone who might be surer. He loads the man into his van and drives back into the city.
What follows over the first act is a gathering. Vahid seeks out Shiva, a wedding photographer played by Mariam Afshari, who was held in the same place. She is working, which is how a bride and groom in full wedding clothes end up in the back of a van in the desert with a hooded man in a box. Others join, each with their own memories of Eghbal and their own idea of what he deserves. None of them can quite agree on whether this is him.

Direction
Panahi's films since his 2010 ban have been made in constrained spaces: his flat in This Is Not a Film, a car in Taxi, a border village in No Bears. It Was Just an Accident is the first in years to move this freely, across the city and out into the desert, yet the van remains its centre of gravity. Much of the drama happens in that cramped interior, with the camera fixed on faces arguing about what to do, and the effect is close to theatre without ever feeling staged.
The long takes are the point. Panahi lets scenes run until an argument exhausts itself and something else surfaces: a joke, a confession, a practical problem that cannot wait. Tension rarely comes from what the characters do. It comes from how long they are allowed to talk before someone has to act, and from the knowledge that the man in the box can hear every word.
The question is never only whether this is the man. It is what it would mean if he were.
That restraint extends to the politics. There are no speeches about the regime, and the state appears mostly as a pressure the characters carry around with them: the officials who have to be paid off, the neighbours who might be watching, the hijabs that several of the women do not wear. The film makes its case through behaviour, which is more persuasive than any declaration would be.
Performances
The cast is made up largely of performers with little or no screen reputation outside Iran, and the unvarnished delivery gives the testimony scenes a weight that polish would have worn away. Mobasseri plays Vahid as a man whose certainty keeps cracking under the strain of having to be certain; he is sympathetic, stubborn and at times frightening, and the film never lets the audience settle on one of those.
Afshari is the standout. Shiva is practical, sardonic and furious in roughly equal parts, and she holds the group together with the patience of someone who has had to organise her own survival before. Mohamad Ali Elyasmehr, as Hamid, is the group's most volatile member, and the film uses him to voice the case for revenge with real force rather than as a straw man. Ebrahim Azizi has the hardest job of all, playing a man who is often trapped, hooded or out of frame, and who must stay ambiguous for a long time.
The comedy depends on these performances. Panahi has always had a dry sense of humour, but here it borders on farce: a bride and groom stranded in the desert in their wedding clothes, a group of traumatised people bickering over petty logistics while a possible torturer waits in the back. The laughs never undercut the seriousness. They make it bearable, and then they make it worse.
Craft
The film was shot quickly and clandestinely by the cinematographer Amin Jafari, and the image is plain: natural light, practical locations, a camera that sits still and watches. It is honest work, and occasionally striking, especially in the wide desert compositions where a lone tree and a parked van carry a whole scene. For long stretches, though, the visual style is simply functional, which is the one area where the conditions of production show.
Amir Etminan's editing is more distinctive. Scenes are allowed to breathe and then cut off abruptly, which keeps the audience slightly off balance. Sound matters more than image here, since the central question turns on what Vahid heard. The squeak of the leg is used sparingly and to great effect, and the film's quietest passages are among its most tense. No composer is credited, and music is used so sparingly that the viewer is left alone with the arguments.
Where it sits
The Palme d'Or made Panahi one of very few directors to have won the top prize at Cannes, Venice and Berlin. It was also the first Palme for an Iranian film since Abbas Kiarostami's Taste of Cherry in 1997, and Kiarostami, who wrote Panahi's debut, is a visible influence on the long car conversations here.
1995
The White Balloon, written by Abbas Kiarostami, wins the Caméra d'Or at Cannes
2000
The Circle wins the Golden Lion at Venice
2010
Panahi is sentenced to six years in prison and banned from making films for twenty
2015
Taxi, shot from inside a car, wins the Golden Bear at Berlin
2022
Panahi is detained in Evin prison; he is released in February 2023
2025
It Was Just an Accident premieres at Cannes on 20 May and wins the Palme d'Or
Among recent Palme winners, the obvious comparison is Anatomy of a Fall: another film about the impossibility of knowing for certain what someone did, built from long scenes of people arguing over evidence. Justine Triet's film uses a courtroom; Panahi uses a van and a shovel. Both trust the audience to live with doubt, and both are better for it.
Head to head
- Craft
- 8.58.4
- Story
- 9.19.0
- Direction
- 9.48.8
- Performances
- 9.09.5
It Was Just an Accident edges it by 0.2. See them side by side
For anyone coming to Panahi for the first time, this is the natural place to begin. It is more conventionally gripping than his earlier work, and it contains, in compressed form, almost everything his career has been about: the cost of speaking, the comedy of bureaucracy and the stubbornness of people who refuse to be silenced.
For you if
- Viewers who want a thriller built on dialogue and moral doubt rather than action
- Anyone interested in Iranian cinema or in films made under political pressure
- Admirers of Anatomy of a Fall or the car-bound films of Abbas Kiarostami
Not for you if
- Anyone looking for a conventional revenge film with a clear catharsis
- Viewers who find long, static conversation scenes hard going
- Anyone not ready for frank testimony about torture, even when it is told rather than shown
The film is streaming on MUBI in the UK, where it was released in cinemas in December 2025.
What works
- A premise built on doubt, so every scene re-opens the question of who is in the van
- Long, patient takes that let arguments run until they turn into something else
- Humour that arrives in the worst possible places and makes the fear sharper
- A non-professional cast whose own histories give the dialogue unusual weight
What doesn’t
- The middle stretch circles the same dilemma one or two times too often
- Some supporting characters exist mainly to voice a position in the debate
- The plain, clandestine image is honest but rarely more than functional
The verdict
It Was Just an Accident takes a premise that could have been a straightforward revenge thriller and turns it into something stranger and more searching: a film about how people who were harmed in the dark decide what justice looks like in daylight. Panahi's direction is controlled without being cold, his cast give the material a weight that feels earned, and the humour sharpens the horror instead of relieving it. The middle section loops once or twice too often, and the image is more practical than memorable, which keeps it just short of the very top tier. But it is a gripping, humane and quietly furious piece of filmmaking, made at real personal risk, and it deserves the prize it won.





