Joker · 2019
Joker: Joaquin Phoenix's towering performance in a film that borrows too much
Joker review: Todd Phillips' dark origin story is anchored by a mesmerising Joaquin Phoenix, but its muddled politics and Scorsese borrowings limit its impact.
Good
Editorial score out of 10
Joker is a comic-book film that aspires to be something else entirely: a gritty, character-driven drama in the style of 1970s and early 1980s American cinema. Todd Phillips strips away superhero spectacle to focus on a lonely, mentally ill man pushed to breaking point. It was a colossal commercial success, won the Golden Lion at the Venice Film Festival and earned Joaquin Phoenix the Academy Award for Best Actor, while Hildur Guðnadóttir won for her score.
- 7.2
- Editorial score
- #107
- Of 112 movies reviewed
- 2019
- Released
- 9.4
- Best at: Performances
It also sparked fierce debate. Some saw it as a powerful portrait of alienation; others felt it was derivative, shallow in its politics and uncomfortably sympathetic towards violent resentment.
He idolises Murray Franklin, a talk show host played by Robert De Niro, and dreams of performing on his show.
Arthur's world
The film's Gotham is a city of garbage strikes, rats and social cuts, a clear evocation of New York in the era of Martin Scorsese's Taxi Driver. Arthur lives with his mother Penny in a shabby apartment and endures humiliations at every turn: beaten by teenagers, mocked by colleagues, dismissed by social services. He idolises Murray Franklin, a talk show host played by Robert De Niro, and dreams of performing on his show.
This setup is effective in building sympathy and dread. The trouble is that it closely follows the template of The King of Comedy, in which De Niro himself played an obsessive would-be comedian, and Taxi Driver, to the extent that it can feel more like homage than original work.
Phoenix
Joaquin Phoenix's performance is the reason to see Joker. He lost significant weight for the role, and his gaunt, contorted body becomes a key part of the character. His uncontrollable, painful laughter is disturbing, his moments of dancing alone are strangely graceful, and his gradual transformation into a confident, performative figure is chilling. It is a bold, fearless performance that dominates every scene.
The supporting cast has less to work with. Zazie Beetz's neighbour Sophie is underwritten, and De Niro's talk show host is more a device than a character, although his final scenes with Phoenix are tense.
Politics and provocation
Joker gestures towards themes of inequality, mental health care and media cruelty, and depicts a city on the brink of unrest against the wealthy, represented by Thomas Wayne. Yet these ideas are delivered bluntly, and the film's point of view on Arthur's violence is unclear. It can be read as critique or as validation, and its reliance on shock makes it difficult to find nuance. Much of the pre-release debate concerned whether it might inspire real-world anger, which says something about how ambiguous its framing is.
Craft
Lawrence Sher's cinematography bathes Gotham in sickly greens and yellows, and the production design convincingly recreates a grimy, pre-gentrification city. Guðnadóttir's score, built around a mournful cello, gives Arthur's descent a tragic, operatic weight. The sequence in which Arthur dances down a long outdoor staircase has become an instantly recognisable image, even if its music choice attracted controversy.
What works
- Joaquin Phoenix's physical, unnerving performance is extraordinary
- Hildur Guðnadóttir's mournful cello score is haunting
- Grimy, 1970s-style Gotham is vividly realised
- The stairway dance sequence is a striking, iconic image
What doesn’t
- Borrows heavily from Taxi Driver and The King of Comedy
- Its social commentary is muddled and heavy-handed
- Unrelenting misery leaves little room for nuance
Head to head
- Craft
- 8.49.5
- Story
- 6.49.6
- Direction
- 7.49.7
- Performances
- 9.49.3
Parasite edges it by 2.2. See them side by side
The verdict
Joker is a well-crafted, uncomfortable film carried by one of the most intense performances of its decade. Its heavy borrowing from Scorsese, blunt social commentary and relentless misery limit its depth, and it never quite earns the seriousness it claims. It earns a 7.2, largely on the strength of Phoenix's extraordinary work.




