Knives Out · 2019
Knives Out: Rian Johnson's gleeful whodunnit with a sharp modern edge
Knives Out review: Rian Johnson's star-studded murder mystery is witty and cleverly plotted, with Daniel Craig and Ana de Armas leading a gleeful ensemble.
Excellent
Editorial score out of 10
Knives Out is a loving update of the classic country-house murder mystery, made with the playfulness and structural ingenuity that Rian Johnson brings to genre filmmaking. It has an eccentric detective, a sprawling mansion, a will, a family of suspects and a series of twists, but it also uses the genre's conventions to satirise class, privilege and anxieties about immigration in contemporary America. It was a critical and commercial hit and spawned a series of sequels.
- 8.3
- Editorial score
- #71
- Of 112 movies reviewed
- 2019
- Released
- 8.8
- Best at: Story
It is, above all, great fun: a crowd-pleaser that respects its audience's intelligence.
The Thrombey mansion is a triumph of production design, cluttered with antiques, games and a spectacular circular display of knives.
The mystery
The story begins with the discovery of Harlan's body and a series of police interviews with the family, told through flashbacks that reveal each member's lies and grievances. Johnson then makes a bold structural decision: relatively early, the film appears to reveal a crucial piece of information, shifting the story from a whodunnit to a suspense thriller.
This choice, which should not be spoiled further, creates tension in a different register, as the audience watches a character try to avoid detection. It also sets up further surprises, and Johnson's plotting ensures that almost every seemingly minor detail matters. The final revelations are satisfying and fair.

Marta and Blanc
Ana de Armas is the film's secret weapon. Marta, the daughter of immigrants, is kind, honest to a fault and unable to lie without vomiting, a comic device that becomes a crucial plot element. De Armas makes her warm and sympathetic, and the film's moral core rests on her.
Daniel Craig, as Benoit Blanc, is a delight. With a drawling Southern accent, he plays the detective as a self-assured, occasionally absurd figure whose deductions are sharper than his manner suggests. The accent can feel like a caricature at times, but Craig's comic commitment is infectious.
The Thrombeys
The family is a gallery of entitled characters. Jamie Lee Curtis's self-made daughter Linda, Don Johnson's philandering husband Richard, Michael Shannon's resentful son Walt, Toni Collette's lifestyle influencer Joni and Chris Evans's spoilt, sweater-wearing grandson Ransom all get memorable moments. Evans, in particular, is gleeful in a role that plays against his heroic image. Christopher Plummer is warm and mischievous as Harlan.
With so many talented actors, some inevitably have little to do, and several characters remain sketches. The satire of their politics, including an argument at the birthday party about immigration, is funny but occasionally obvious.
Style
The Thrombey mansion is a triumph of production design, cluttered with antiques, games and a spectacular circular display of knives. Steve Yedlin's cinematography is warm and autumnal, and Nathan Johnson's lively string score adds a classic feel. The film's visual storytelling includes plenty of hidden clues for those paying attention.
What works
- An intricately designed plot that plays fair with its clues
- Ana de Armas gives the mystery a warm, sympathetic centre
- Daniel Craig clearly relishes Benoit Blanc's eccentricities
- Witty social satire of wealth and entitlement
What doesn’t
- Some of the starry ensemble get only a handful of scenes
- Political jokes are occasionally too on the nose
- Blanc's broad Southern accent can tip into caricature
Head to head
- Craft
- 8.08.4
- Story
- 8.89.0
- Direction
- 8.48.8
- Performances
- 8.59.5
Anatomy of a Fall edges it by 0.6. See them side by side
The verdict
Knives Out is a witty, entertaining and cleverly constructed mystery that revitalised the whodunnit for modern audiences. Some thinly drawn characters and on-the-nose satire are small blemishes on a sharp and satisfying film. It earns an 8.3.





