Lady Bird · 2017
Lady Bird: Greta Gerwig's funny, piercing portrait of a mother and daughter
Lady Bird review: Greta Gerwig's coming-of-age comedy is warm, specific and deeply felt, led by Saoirse Ronan and Laurie Metcalf at their very best.
Excellent
Editorial score out of 10
Lady Bird is a coming-of-age film that feels intensely personal without ever becoming indulgent. Greta Gerwig's solo directorial debut draws on her own Sacramento upbringing, though it is not autobiography, and turns a familiar story of a teenager desperate to leave home into a sharp, funny and deeply moving study of a mother-daughter relationship. It was widely acclaimed and earned Oscar nominations for Best Picture, Best Director, Ronan and Metcalf.
- 8.7
- Editorial score
- #47
- Of 112 movies reviewed
- 2017
- Released
- 94 minutes
- Runtime
Its power lies in its specificity. The film knows these people, this city and this moment in time, and it refuses to caricature any of them.
Saoirse Ronan is superb as Lady Bird, capturing her self-dramatising confidence, cruelty, humour and vulnerability.
A year in Sacramento
The film unfolds as a series of short, sharply observed episodes across Christine's final year of high school. She auditions for the school musical, falls for a sweet drama student, then for a pretentious musician, drifts away from her best friend Julie to court a popular girl, and secretly applies to East Coast colleges her family cannot afford.
The structure is brisk and occasionally slight, with many scenes lasting only a minute or two. Some of the story's beats, including first sex, a school dance and teenage rebellion, are familiar. But Gerwig's writing gives each moment an unexpected twist, a precise line of dialogue or a telling detail that makes it feel fresh.

Mother and daughter
The heart of the film is Christine's relationship with Marion. The opening scene, in which a tender shared moment in the car turns into an argument that ends with Christine throwing herself from the moving vehicle, captures their dynamic perfectly: love and exasperation, pride and wounded feelings, all colliding at once.
Saoirse Ronan is superb as Lady Bird, capturing her self-dramatising confidence, cruelty, humour and vulnerability. Laurie Metcalf matches her as Marion, a woman exhausted by work and money worries, whose criticism of her daughter comes from fear and love. Their scenes together are among the most truthful depictions of a parent and teenager in modern cinema, and the film pointedly refuses to take sides.
The supporting cast
Tracy Letts is wonderful as Larry, Christine's gentle father, who is quietly battling depression and unemployment. Lucas Hedges gives Danny, the first boyfriend, a hidden sadness, and Timothée Chalamet is very funny as Kyle, a self-absorbed musician who reads Howard Zinn and refuses to use mobile phones. Beanie Feldstein is lovely as Julie, and Lois Smith brings wisdom and wit to Sister Sarah Joan, a nun who is kinder to Christine than she expects.
Some of these characters appear only briefly, and a longer film might have developed them more. But the economy of Gerwig's writing is also part of its charm.
Place and period
Sacramento, which Christine considers the dullest place imaginable, becomes a character in its own right. Gerwig and cinematographer Sam Levy photograph the city with warmth, and the film's ending is a moving tribute to the importance of home. The early-2000s period details, including songs and a background of news about the Iraq War, are subtle and well chosen. Jon Brion's score is gentle and understated.
What works
- Saoirse Ronan and Laurie Metcalf are extraordinary together
- Sharply specific about class, money and hometown embarrassment
- Funny, tender scenes that never tip into sentimentality
- Tracy Letts gives a quietly devastating turn as the father
What doesn’t
- Its episodic structure can feel slight at times
- Many coming-of-age beats are familiar from other films
- Some supporting friends and boyfriends are sketched briefly
Head to head
- Craft
- 8.19.0
- Story
- 8.37.6
- Direction
- 8.68.7
- Performances
- 9.39.1
Lady Bird edges it by 0.5. See them side by side
The verdict
Lady Bird is a funny, perceptive and emotionally rich film, anchored by two superb performances. Its slight, episodic structure and familiar beats are small limitations against the precision and warmth of Gerwig's writing and direction. It earns an 8.7 as one of the finest coming-of-age films of its decade.





