Licorice Pizza · 2021
Licorice Pizza: a loose, sun-dappled 1970s romance that charms and frustrates
Licorice Pizza review: Paul Thomas Anderson's shaggy 1973 valley romance boasts two luminous debuts in Alana Haim and Cooper Hoffman, but its age gap unsettles.
Good
Editorial score out of 10
Licorice Pizza is Paul Thomas Anderson in a relaxed, nostalgic mood, a hangout film about the San Fernando Valley where he grew up. After the intense, meticulous dramas There Will Be Blood and Phantom Thread, it is looser and more whimsical, drifting through a series of episodes loosely inspired by real people and events. Many critics adored its sunny, shaggy charm, while others found it aimless and its central relationship troubling.
- 7.8
- Editorial score
- #95
- Of 112 movies reviewed
- 2021
- Released
- 8.4
- Best at: Craft
It is often delightful, and its lead performances are genuine discoveries. It is also difficult to overlook what the film asks audiences to find romantic.
A truck coasting backwards down a hill with no fuel is a brilliant, suspenseful set piece.
Gary and Alana
The film opens with Gary meeting Alana on school picture day and immediately asking her to dinner. She laughs him off, but agrees to accompany him to New York as a chaperone when he appears on a television variety show. Gary's precocious hustle, including a waterbed business and later a pinball arcade, becomes the engine for their adventures, while Alana tries to find her own direction, flirting with acting and local politics.
Alana Haim, of the band Haim, is a revelation. Alana is frustrated, funny, insecure and quick-tempered, a woman whose life has stalled and who is embarrassed to find herself hanging around with teenagers. Haim's real family plays her family, adding to the film's warm, lived-in feel. Cooper Hoffman, son of Philip Seymour Hoffman, is equally natural as Gary, with a charming blend of swagger and boyishness.

The age question
Gary is fifteen and Alana is twenty-five, and the film presents their bond as a meandering romance. Anderson frames it as a platonic friendship laced with longing, and there is nothing explicit between them. Yet the film's romantic framing of the relationship, with little interrogation of the imbalance, left many viewers uncomfortable. The film appears aware of the awkwardness, but it does not do enough with that awareness.
A separate subplot involving a restaurant owner who speaks to his Japanese wives in a mock accent was also criticised, and it feels like an unnecessary misstep.
Episodes and cameos
The film's episodic structure yields some wonderful sequences. Bradley Cooper's cameo as the volatile film producer Jon Peters is a comic tour de force, culminating in a hair-raising drive when a waterbed delivery goes wrong during the 1973 oil crisis. A truck coasting backwards down a hill with no fuel is a brilliant, suspenseful set piece. Sean Penn plays an ageing movie star modelled on William Holden, and Benny Safdie is quietly moving as a closeted local politician.
The second half, however, becomes meandering, and the loose narrative sometimes feels as if it could continue indefinitely without reaching a destination.
Style
Shot on 35mm film by Anderson and Michael Bauman, Licorice Pizza has a warm, grainy texture that perfectly evokes the 1970s. The soundtrack, featuring songs from the period and a score by Jonny Greenwood, adds to the nostalgic atmosphere, and the recreation of the Valley's shops, restaurants and suburbs is superb.
What works
- Alana Haim gives a funny, prickly and magnetic debut performance
- Bradley Cooper's unhinged cameo is a comic highlight
- Warm, grainy evocation of the 1970s Valley feels lived-in
- The truck sequence during the fuel crisis is a brilliant set piece
What doesn’t
- The age gap between the leads is uncomfortable and unexamined
- A restaurant owner's mock-Japanese accent gag has aged badly
- Shaggy, episodic structure meanders in the second half
Head to head
- Craft
- 8.48.1
- Story
- 7.08.0
- Direction
- 8.48.6
- Performances
- 8.39.2
Anora edges it by 0.6. See them side by side
The verdict
Licorice Pizza is a charming, beautifully shot and often very funny film, carried by two outstanding debut performances. Its uncomfortable central relationship, a misjudged running gag and meandering structure hold it back from Anderson's best work. It earns a 7.8.





