Mayhem · 2025
Mayhem: Lady Gaga's noisiest pop record, and her most controlled
Mayhem review. Lady Gaga's 2025 album pairs big pop hooks with industrial edges and a rock-band rawness. Here is who it suits, and where it sags.
Excellent
Editorial score out of 10
Mayhem is the best Lady Gaga album in more than a decade for anyone who wants her loud, theatrical and tuneful at once, and it is a strong place to start if you have only known the hit singles. It is fourteen songs of dance-floor pop with industrial edges, played with more live-band weight than she has used on a pop record before. The weak spot is the second half, where the ideas thin out.
- 8.4
- Editorial score
- #32
- Of 44 albums reviewed
- 2025
- Released
- 14
- Tracks
Gaga has said she wrote and recorded far more songs than the fourteen she kept, and the selection shows. The best of them are crowded with hooks, switch genre mid-chorus and still stay on the beat. The record is not tidy, but it is controlled, and that is the quality that separates it from a simple return to form. It sounds like an artist deciding exactly how much chaos to allow.
Context
Gaga arrived at this record from two very different directions. Chromatica (2020) was a clean, club-facing album that many fans felt kept her at arm's length, and the years since were spent on film work, jazz standards with Tony Bennett and the A Star Is Born soundtrack. By 2024 she had said publicly that she wanted to return to the pop music her earliest fans loved, and that her fiancé Michael Polansky had encouraged her to lean into the joy of it. The result is a pop album made by someone who has nothing left to prove.
It was made at Shangri-La in Malibu, the studio where she also recorded Joanne and the A Star Is Born songs, and that history is audible. Where Chromatica was built on a laptop, Mayhem has the sound of a room: drums that move air, bass that has fingers behind it, guitars used as texture rather than decoration. Cirkut and Andrew Watt, two producers better known for radio-ready pop, bring the polish, and the album holds the line between the two worlds.
2008
The Fame introduces a dance-pop star with art-school instincts
2011
Born This Way goes for stadium-sized anthems and religious imagery
2016
Joanne strips back to guitars and a country-rock palette
2020
Chromatica returns to the dance floor in a tighter, cleaner form
2025
Mayhem combines the club and the band on one record

The songs
"Disease" opens the album with a chant that is half taunt and half confession, over a thick, grinding synth line that sounds closer to industrial dance than to radio pop. It is a bold first move, and it works because the chorus is simple enough to shout. "Abracadabra" follows and is the album's clearest single: a spell-casting hook, a bassline that keeps nudging forwards and a vocal that sounds delighted to be there. Both were released before the album, and both set the terms for what comes next.
The middle of the record is where the genre-hopping lives. "Garden of Eden" is the funk-leaning one, with a loose, sly vocal. "Perfect Celebrity" turns guitars loud and aims its lyrics at the machinery of fame. "Vanish Into You" is the synth-driven slow burner that Gaga has said was the first song she wrote for the album, and it carries the weight of that. "Killah" borrows from Prince-style funk without turning into a pastiche. In every case the song has a clear chorus; the experiments sit around it rather than replacing it.
| Track | Why |
|---|---|
| Disease | The industrial hook that sets the tone |
| Abracadabra | The cleanest pop hit on the record |
| Vanish Into You | The slow-burn highlight, and the first song written |
| Killah | The funk-rock sideswipe that proves the range |
| Blade of Grass | The piano ballad that gives the second half its heart |
Production
The production is the strongest argument for the album. Gaga co-produced alongside Cirkut and Andrew Watt, with Gesaffelstein among the collaborators, and the sound is built in layers that reward headphones. Synthesisers are bright and abrasive; the live drums and bass are warm. The mix keeps the vocal at the front without flattening the rest. She has named 1990s alternative music, Prince and David Bowie melodies, funk bass and French electronic music as touchstones, and the record sounds like a conversation between all of them.
What sets it apart from most chart pop is restraint in the right places. Tracks drop out to a bare beat before the chorus returns, and the sparse moments make the dense ones hit harder. Several songs hold back their biggest sound for the final minute. The only real complaint is that the same palette appears in too many of the later songs, so the second half sounds more like the first than it should.
How it measures up
- Energy
- 8.5/10
- Dance-floor tempos for most of the running time
- Intimacy
- 5/10
- Mostly performance; the ballads are the exception
- Density
- 8/10
- Layered synths and live instruments, rarely thin
- Accessibility
- 9/10
- Strong hooks, and the experiments never block the tune
Performance
Gaga is a singer who can do almost anything, and this album asks for most of it. She snarls on "Disease", plays with a half-spoken drawl on the funk tracks, and sings straight to the back of the hall on the ballads. The record uses her voice as an instrument, with stacked harmonies in the choruses and a raw, close mic on the verses. There is theatre here, but it never swamps the singing.
The ballads matter more than the singles suggest. "Blade of Grass" is a piano-led ballad in which the production steps aside, and it gives the album a human centre that the louder tracks cannot supply. "Die with a Smile", her duet with Bruno Mars, was recorded at the end of the sessions and became a worldwide hit on its own, drawing on 1970s-style harmonies. It is a lovely song and a very different one from everything around it, which is the heart of the sequencing question.
The record sounds like an artist deciding exactly how much chaos to allow.
Sequencing
Mayhem is front-loaded. The first six tracks are a run of singles and near-singles, each with its own sound and its own hook. After that the album settles into mid-tempo synth-pop, with songs such as "LoveDrug", "How Bad Do U Want Me" and "Don't Call Tonight" doing solid, enjoyable work that does not stand out. "The Beast" brings a late jolt of weight, but the sense of risk that drives the first half is rarely matched again.
The close is the other issue. Ending on a duet with Bruno Mars gives the record a warm, sunlit farewell, and there is a case that it is the point: love as the answer to the noise. Heard in order, though, the shift is sharp, and some listeners will prefer to stop at "Blade of Grass". Neither complaint is fatal. Fourteen tracks is a sensible length, and the album never outstays its welcome.
Legacy
The album topped the Billboard 200, was widely praised on release, and took Best Pop Vocal Album at the 2026 Grammy Awards. Critics treated it as a return to the pop she was first known for, and it became the best-reviewed record of her career by the Metacritic aggregate. Its legacy is easier to describe than to measure: it showed that a major pop star could make an album with real texture, played by real people, and still have the hits.
Compared with other big releases of the period, it sits between two extremes. Brat (2024) was a sharp, club-led statement with a single, unmistakable identity. Lux (2025) was a work of orchestral ambition that asks the listener to follow it into stranger territory. Mayhem is more welcoming than either, and more generous with tunes.
Head to head
- Cohesion
- 7.78.9
- Production
- 8.89.6
- Performance
- 8.99.7
- Songwriting
- 8.39.1
Lux edges it by 0.9. See them side by side
The choice between the two comes down to temperament: Lux asks for patience and pays it back slowly, while Mayhem pays back at once.
For you if
- Fans of Gaga's early records who want the hooks back without the gloss
- Anyone who likes pop with a rock rhythm section and industrial synths
- Listeners who want a pop album that rewards headphones and repeat plays
Not for you if
- Anyone after the confessional minimalism of Joanne or the jazz albums
- Listeners who find fame-and-chaos lyrics tiresome
- Those who want every track to be a surprise to the very end
If one album from the pop of 2025 is going on the shelf for the decade, this is a reasonable candidate, and the way in is easy.
What works
- Hooks that land on first play, then reveal odd corners on the fifth
- Live-band weight under the synths gives the dance tracks real bite
- Gaga's voice moves from snarl to ballad without strain
- The three singles open the record with a run few pop albums match
What doesn’t
- The back half repeats its tempos and loses some of the front half's surprise
- Closing on the Bruno Mars duet sits oddly after an hour of industrial pop
- Several lyrics lean on fame and chaos imagery that wears thin
The verdict
Mayhem is worth hearing for anyone who likes big pop hooks with some grit under them, and it is the Lady Gaga record to pick if you want the theatre and the tunes in one place. It earns its score from the first six songs, a production that sounds like musicians in a room, and a vocal performance with range and conviction. It stops short of the top tier because the second half is more comfortable than adventurous, the lyrics keep returning to the same themes, and the closing duet pulls against the tone of everything before it. Those are small reservations next to the record's strengths. It is a confident, fun, well-made album, and the best Gaga has sounded in years.





