Monster · 2004
Monster: a patient, chilling thriller about the cost of saving a life
Monster review: Madhouse's 74-episode adaptation of Naoki Urasawa's manga is a slow-burning, unsettling psychological thriller of rare depth and ambition.
Essential
Editorial score out of 10
Monster is often recommended to viewers who think anime is all fights and fantasy. It is a grounded, novelistic psychological thriller set in post-reunification Europe, following a doctor on a moral quest to undo the consequences of saving a life. Over 74 episodes it builds a portrait of evil, trauma and redemption that few television thrillers in any medium have matched.
- 9.1
- Editorial score
- #10
- Of 93 anime reviewed
- 2004
- Released
- 74
- Episodes
It is also a very slow series. Its power comes from accumulation, and it rewards viewers willing to follow it through detours and quiet stretches.
The first ending theme, For the Love of Life, sung by David Sylvian, is a haunting choice that perfectly captures the series' mood.
Story
The opening episodes are superb. Tenma's decision to operate on the boy, and the professional fallout that follows, sets up a moral dilemma that echoes throughout the series. When Johan reappears as an adult, the story shifts into a cat-and-mouse thriller in which Tenma is both hunter and hunted. As he investigates, he uncovers Johan's past, a hidden orphanage programme and a web of people whose lives have been damaged by the same shadowy forces.
The plot spreads across many cities, characters and subplots. Standalone episodes follow ordinary people touched briefly by Tenma or Johan, and while some feel like detours, many are among the most affecting in the series. The narrative relies at times on coincidence, and the middle section can drag, but the story's structure, themes and payoff are exceptional.
Characters
Tenma is a principled, gentle protagonist who believes every life has equal value, and the series tests that belief relentlessly. Johan is a terrifying antagonist not because of violence, but because of his calm, persuasive ability to manipulate and destroy people's sense of self. Nina, Johan's twin sister, carries her own trauma and determination. Inspector Lunge, an obsessive detective who records everything in his mind as if it were a computer, is a brilliant, unsettling figure. Supporting characters, from former nurses to ex-soldiers and a young boy on the streets, are richly drawn.
Animation and sound
Madhouse's animation is realistic and restrained, closely following Urasawa's designs. Characters look like ordinary people, and European cities are depicted with careful detail. The downside is a visual plainness, with limited movement and muted colours that can make episodes feel static. The direction compensates with strong use of shadows, framing and silence to build tension.
Kuniaki Haishima's score is subtle and atmospheric, emphasising dread and melancholy. The first ending theme, For the Love of Life, sung by David Sylvian, is a haunting choice that perfectly captures the series' mood. Japanese voice performances are superb, particularly for Johan's soft-spoken menace and Lunge's clipped intensity.
Who it is for
Monster is ideal for viewers who enjoy psychological thrillers, crime dramas and slow-burning, character-rich storytelling. It is a strong choice for adults who do not usually watch anime. Those looking for fast pacing or action will likely find it too slow, and its themes of child abuse and violence are dark.
What works
- Johan is one of fiction's most chilling, enigmatic antagonists
- Explores the value of life, identity and evil with philosophical depth
- Standalone episodes about ordinary people form a vivid human tapestry
- A haunting ending theme, sung by David Sylvian, sets a sombre tone
What doesn’t
- Its deliberately slow pace and long running time demand patience
- Realistic but plain animation lacks visual flair
- Some coincidences and detours stretch the central investigation
Head to head
- Sound
- 8.78.6
- Story
- 9.38.4
- Animation
- 7.88.2
- Characters
- 9.48.7
Monster edges it by 0.7. See them side by side
The verdict
Monster is a masterful psychological thriller with a legendary villain, profound themes and a remarkable sense of place. Its plain animation, occasional coincidences and slow middle stretch are real flaws. It remains one of the most acclaimed anime thrillers ever made, and a 9.1 reflects an exceptional work of television storytelling.





