Oshi no Ko · 2023
Oshi no Ko: a glossy idol drama with a sharp knife hidden in its sleeve
Oshi no Ko review: Doga Kobo's adaptation mixes reincarnation, revenge and pointed showbusiness satire, though its tone and later arcs are uneven.
Excellent
Editorial score out of 10
Oshi no Ko arrived in 2023 with one of the most talked-about premieres in recent anime: a feature-length first episode that begins as a strange, slightly uncomfortable comedy and ends somewhere much darker. The rest of the series never quite matches that opening shock, but it builds something more unusual in its place, an entertainment-industry drama that uses the idol genre's bright colours to talk about its costs.
- 8.1
- Editorial score
- #60
- Of 93 anime reviewed
- 2023
- Released
- 24
- Episodes
It is an ambitious, frequently gripping show whose competing ambitions do not always sit comfortably together.
The in-universe idol songs are catchy and fit the story, and the Japanese voice cast handles the tonal shifts well.
From fan fantasy to revenge story
The set-up is audacious. A doctor devoted to an idol is reborn as her child, and the opening episode plays out Ai Hoshino's hidden life as a teenage mother and rising star. A tragedy at the end of that episode sets the story on a new course, and from there Aqua's motivations turn cold and investigative while Ruby pursues the idol dream with sincerity.
That dual structure gives the series its engine. Aqua's quest provides mystery and menace; the industry arcs let the show dig into how television, stage and idol work actually function. The trouble is that the two strands move at different speeds. Long stretches devoted to rehearsals or production politics can make the central thriller feel paused, and the reincarnation conceit occasionally produces moments that are more awkward than the show seems to realise.

A satire with teeth
Where Oshi no Ko is most convincing is in its portrait of the business. The reality dating show arc is the standout, examining how editing manufactures villains and how online pile-ons can push a young performer to breaking point. It is angry, specific and uncomfortably plausible, drawing on real concerns about harassment in Japanese reality television.
The idol group storyline explores the gap between public image and private exhaustion, and the stage-play arc turns to adaptation itself, looking at the tensions between original creators, scriptwriters and actors. That last arc has thoughtful ideas but is also the slowest material so far, with heavy dialogue and less forward drive.
The cast
Aqua is a compelling, guarded lead whose performance of emotional detachment is itself a kind of acting. Ruby is lighter, though her optimism is given real weight. The supporting cast is a highlight: Kana Arima, a former child star struggling with her fading relevance, and Akane Kurokawa, a method actress of unsettling intensity, both have arcs that sometimes outshine the leads.
Not every character is as well served, and the romantic tensions around Aqua can feel like a detour from the show's sharper concerns.
Animation and music
Doga Kobo's production is consistently polished, with bright, saturated colour, expressive faces and a strong eye for performance. Idol concerts and acting scenes are staged with care, and the direction uses the characters' star-shaped eyes as a recurring visual motif for obsession and ambition.
Music is central. YOASOBI's opening song became a major hit and captures the show's blend of pop gloss and darkness better than any summary could. The in-universe idol songs are catchy and fit the story, and the Japanese voice cast handles the tonal shifts well.
What works
- Feature-length opening episode is a gripping, genre-shifting hook
- Pointed critique of reality TV, online harassment and idol labour
- Polished, expressive Doga Kobo animation with standout performance scenes
- YOASOBI's opening theme is a perfect, much-imitated statement of intent
What doesn’t
- Revenge thriller and showbiz procedural often pull in different directions
- The reincarnation premise creates awkward moments that the show plays lightly
- The stage-play arc slows momentum with long stretches of backstage talk
Head to head
- Sound
- 8.97.9
- Story
- 7.96.3
- Animation
- 8.89.2
- Characters
- 8.37.8
Oshi no Ko edges it by 0.9. See them side by side
The verdict
Oshi no Ko is at its best as a clear-eyed critique of an industry that consumes young performers, and its opening episode and reality TV arc are among the strongest anime drama of recent years. An uneasy balance between revenge thriller and showbiz procedural, a slower stage-play arc and some awkward handling of its premise keep it in the low eights. The divisive reception of the source manga's conclusion also adds a note of caution for viewers planning to follow the story all the way.





