Pan's Labyrinth · 2006
Pan's Labyrinth: Guillermo del Toro's dark fairy tale of innocence and fascism
Pan's Labyrinth review: Guillermo del Toro weaves fairy tale and the aftermath of the Spanish Civil War into a haunting, beautifully made masterpiece.
Essential
Editorial score out of 10
El laberinto del fauno, better known in English as Pan's Labyrinth, is the film in which Guillermo del Toro's lifelong fascinations with monsters, fairy tales and the scars of history came together with extraordinary clarity. Set in the aftermath of the Spanish Civil War, it tells two parallel stories: one of a girl drawn into a subterranean fantasy world, the other of a sadistic officer crushing resistance in the hills. Each illuminates the other.
- 9.2
- Editorial score
- #20
- Of 112 movies reviewed
- 2006
- Released
- 9.6
- Best at: Craft
It is a fairy tale in the old European sense, beautiful and cruel, and not a children's film. Its acclaim was broad and lasting, and it won Academy Awards for cinematography, art direction and makeup.
Maribel Verdú is superb as Mercedes, Vidal's housekeeper, secretly aiding the guerrillas.
Two worlds
Ofelia arrives at the mill where Vidal has established his headquarters, clutching books of fairy tales. Her mother is weak and exhausted by a difficult pregnancy, and Vidal cares only about the son he believes she is carrying. Ofelia's retreat into the labyrinth, where the faun sets her dangerous tasks, can be read as escape or as reality; del Toro allows both possibilities to coexist.
The fantasy sequences are not an escape from brutality but a reflection of it. A giant toad draining the life from a tree, a banquet presided over by a child-eating monster and a mandrake root with the power to heal all echo the moral choices faced by the adults around her. The film's central theme, disobedience in the face of illegitimate authority, runs through both storylines.

Vidal and Mercedes
Sergi López's Captain Vidal is one of cinema's most frightening villains precisely because he is human. Obsessed with order, time and his father's legacy, he shaves meticulously, polishes his boots and commits acts of violence with chilling calm. López never plays him as a cartoon, which makes him more terrifying.
Maribel Verdú is superb as Mercedes, Vidal's housekeeper, secretly aiding the guerrillas. Her courage and quiet tenderness towards Ofelia give the film a second heroine. The guerrilla fighters themselves are sketched more thinly, and the resistance storyline can feel more functional than the fantasy.
Ivana Baquero gives Ofelia a watchful seriousness that avoids child-actor sentimentality, carrying extended sequences in which she acts opposite elaborate creature makeup.
Monsters and craft
Doug Jones plays both the Faun and the Pale Man, and both are marvels of practical effects and physical performance. The Faun is ancient, creaking and ambiguous, never quite trustworthy. The Pale Man, with eyes in the palms of its hands, appears in a sequence of nerve-shredding suspense that has become iconic.
Guillermo Navarro's cinematography contrasts the cold blues and greys of Vidal's world with the warm ambers and golds of the fantasy realm, while Javier Navarrete's score, built around a haunting wordless lullaby, provides the emotional through-line.
A note on violence
The film's violence is sudden and graphic, including a notorious early scene involving a bottle, as well as torture and gunshots at close range. It is essential to del Toro's portrait of fascist cruelty, but it may shock viewers who come expecting a fantasy adventure.
What works
- Fairy-tale and war storylines mirror each other with real power
- The Pale Man sequence is an all-time great piece of screen horror
- Sergi López makes Captain Vidal a chilling portrait of fascism
- Practical creature work and makeup remain astonishing
What doesn’t
- Graphic violence is harsh for viewers expecting a family fantasy
- Guerrilla subplot characters are less developed than Ofelia and Vidal
Head to head
- Craft
- 9.69.6
- Story
- 9.19.2
- Direction
- 9.49.7
- Performances
- 9.09.5
No Country for Old Men edges it by 0.2. See them side by side
The verdict
Pan's Labyrinth is a rare fantasy film that works equally as political allegory, war drama and fairy tale, rendered with meticulous craft and anchored by powerful performances. Its underdeveloped guerrilla subplot and harsh violence are small reservations against the scale of its achievement. It scores a 9.2 and remains del Toro's most complete work.





