Skip to content
Book reviewEssential

Piranesi · 2020

Piranesi: a whole world built out of tides, statues and one careful voice

Piranesi review. Susanna Clarke's second novel is a short, strange journal from an endless house of statues and water, and its narrator carries all of it.

Voxizer EditorialSection editor David Abellán10 min read

Essential

Editorial score out of 10

A man lives alone in a building with no outside. He calls it the House, and he has never seen anything else: halls that run further than he can walk in a day, each lined with statues, none of them repeated; clouds in the upper storeys; a sea in the basements that climbs the stairs on a schedule he has learned to predict. He keeps a journal. Susanna Clarke's second novel is that journal, and almost nothing about it should work.

9.1
Editorial score
#15
Of 61 books reviewed
2020
Released
272 pages
Pages

It works because the voice is a complete invention rather than a costume. Piranesi — the name is not his, and he knows it is not his — writes in a formal, tender, capital-lettered English that treats a dead bird and a flight of stairs with the same seriousness, because in his world they are equally worth recording. Sixteen years after Jonathan Strange & Mr Norrell, Clarke returned with a book several times shorter, and the smaller book is the more difficult trick.

She is interested in what a person is once everything that made him has been taken away, and whether what is left can still be good.

The House

The geography is the first pleasure, and it arrives without a paragraph of exposition anywhere near it. Piranesi numbers the halls, notes which vestibules flood, and records the statues as landmarks: a faun, a gorilla, a woman carrying a beehive, two children laughing. He knows the tides the way a fisherman knows them, and he has worked out enough of their arithmetic to predict when three of them will meet and fill a staircase to the ceiling. He fishes. He dries seaweed. He keeps the bones of the dead he has found, and brings them water lilies.

None of this is framed as strange, which is exactly why it lands. A lesser version of this novel would give us a narrator who wonders how he got there. Clarke's narrator does not wonder, because wondering would require a memory of somewhere else, and he has none he trusts. The reader supplies the alarm on his behalf. That division of labour — reader worried, narrator content — is the book's whole method, and it is sustained far longer than looks safe.

There is one other living man, whom Piranesi calls the Other, who appears twice a week in polished shoes, asks for help finding something called the Great and Secret Knowledge, and hands over useful objects that Piranesi accepts without ever asking where a multivitamin comes from. The comedy in those scenes is dry and entirely unforced. So is the dread underneath it.

  1. 2004

    Jonathan Strange & Mr Norrell is published, a debut many times this book's length, and goes on to win the Hugo Award for Best Novel

  2. 2006

    The Ladies of Grace Adieu collects the short stories set in the same England

  3. 2020

    Piranesi is published by Bloomsbury on 15 September, in hardback, e-book and audio on the same day

  4. 2021

    It wins the Women's Prize for Fiction and is a Hugo finalist

  5. 2024

    The Wood at Midwinter, an illustrated novella, ends the gap after it

That gap matters to how the book reads. Clarke has described the long, branching kind of novel becoming impossible for her during years of illness, and has said she came back to this one because it was the project she could hold in her head. Whatever the cause, the constraint is visible on every page, and it turns out to be a gift: a writer known for footnotes and crowds produced a book with a handful of speaking parts and no footnotes at all.

Piranesi
PiranesiBloomsbury Publishing, via Open Library

The voice

The capital letters are the tell. Piranesi writes the Beauty of the House, the Kindness of the Birds, the Drowned Halls, and dates his entries by events rather than by any calendar the reader shares. It reads at first like whimsy. It is a precise piece of characterisation, because a man with no history to refer back to has to make his own nouns, and the ones he chooses are all about care and attention.

Clarke's sentences are plain and slightly archaic, with a rhythm closer to a naturalist's field notes than to fantasy prose. There is almost no metaphor. Things are described by their measurements, their materials and their positions, which is how a scientist would do it, and Piranesi insists that he is a scientist. The effect is that when a sentence does turn emotional, it arrives with nothing in front of it to soften the landing.

The journal form also solves the problem every novel of this shape has, which is what a narrator can plausibly fail to notice. Piranesi withholds nothing. He writes down everything he has, and a second story assembles itself in the gaps between his entries: a dropped name, a phrase he uses without understanding it, an index listing something he cannot remember writing. It is closer to reading a case file than to being told a mystery.

What to expect

Pace
5/10
Deliberate for a third of its length, then it moves
Prose difficulty
3/10
Plain sentences; the capitals are the only trick
Puzzle pressure
7/10
The reader stays a step ahead of the narrator throughout
Bleakness
4/10
The situation is grim; the narrator is not
Reread value
8/10
The second pass is a different book

Those bars understate one thing: how quickly it goes. Most readers will finish this in two sittings, and the shortness is doing structural work rather than saving anyone time. A longer book would have given the House room to become ordinary, and an ordinary House would sink the whole enterprise.

What it withholds

It would be easy to oversell the puzzle. The questions raised early — who the Other is, why he needs someone else to do the walking, what became of the bones — are answered, and the answers are more conventional than the premise. Anyone arriving in the expectation that the architecture will resolve into a metaphysical system with rules will find something smaller and more human waiting instead.

That is a real limitation and it is worth stating plainly, because it is the one thing likely to disappoint. Clarke is not interested in a cosmology. She is interested in what a person is once everything that made him has been taken away, and whether what is left can still be good. The House is not a puzzle box. It is a condition.

The other thing the book withholds is cruelty. A great deal is at stake, and some of it is frightening, yet the novel never once uses its narrator's innocence against him for sport. Books built on a naive narrator usually end in humiliation, because humiliation is the easy payoff. This one declines, and the declining is the most unusual decision in it.

The practical note worth making instead is about the audio, which has a strong claim on being the best way in rather than a lesser version of the same thing.

Gallery · 3 imagesBloomsbury Publishing, via Open Library · Salamandra, via Open Library · Fazi Editore, via Open Library

Editions and the audio

Bloomsbury published Piranesi in hardback, e-book and audio on the same day in September 2020, and the audio, read by Chiwetel Ejiofor, won the Audie Award for Audiobook of the Year the following year. That is the rare case where an award says something useful about a text: a first-person journal written in a formal register is exactly the kind of writing a good reader improves, and capital letters that look mannered on the page become plain emphasis in a voice.

In print the choice is mostly cosmetic. The first Bloomsbury hardback carries a jacket of a faun on a column above a sea of scrollwork, and the paperbacks and most of the translations keep the same figure. Page counts drift between settings, which matters only if you are hunting a specific edition.

Editions at a glance
EditionYearWorth knowing
Bloomsbury hardback, UK2020The first edition, ISBN 978-1-5266-2242-6, 272 pages
Bloomsbury hardback, US2020Published the same day, same jacket and design
Bloomsbury paperback2021Carries the Women's Prize sticker and the review quotes
Audiobook2020Read by Chiwetel Ejiofor; Audie Audiobook of the Year 2021
Translations2021 onwardsSalamandra in Spanish, Fazi in Italian, Heyne in German

Which leaves the question of who the book is actually for, and that is less obvious than a shelf of prizes makes it sound.

Where it sits

Piranesi is a fantasy novel in the sense that it contains a world which cannot exist, and in no other sense. There is no magic system, no quest, no politics and no map beyond the one its narrator is drawing as he goes. Its nearest relatives are not epics but small first-person books with restricted narrators, where the pleasure is watching a mind work with insufficient data. The debt to C. S. Lewis is explicit, down to a borrowed surname and an epigraph lifted from The Magician's Nephew, and the borrowings are argued with rather than copied.

The closest thing the catalogue holds is Kazuo Ishiguro's Klara and the Sun, published six months later: another narrator describing a world she does not fully understand in a diction entirely her own, another writer trusting readers to feel the alarm the narrator cannot.

Head to head

Ideas
9.38.3
Story
8.87.1
Writing
9.58.6
Characters
8.77.9

Piranesi edges it by 1.3. See them side by side

Ishiguro's book is the sadder of the two and Clarke's the stranger, and the real difference is that Klara is kept innocent by design, while Piranesi has had his innocence inflicted on him. Anyone who finished one and wanted more of that exact feeling should go straight to the other.

For you if

  • Readers who will follow a voice anywhere and do not need a plot to start on page one
  • Anyone who loved Jonathan Strange & Mr Norrell and can accept an entirely different kind of book
  • Readers of C. S. Lewis, of Borges, of any story about someone who has been made to forget

Not for you if

  • Anyone who wants a worked-out fantasy world with rules, factions and a map at the front
  • Readers who need early momentum; the opening is description, weather and housekeeping
  • Anyone who finds an innocent narrator irritating rather than moving

For most people the decision comes down to whether the first pages hold, and the publisher's own page carries enough of the opening to settle it faster than any review can.

What works

  • A narrator whose capitalised nouns do the worldbuilding without a page of exposition
  • The journal form lets the reader assemble a second story from the gaps
  • Tides and statues make the geography something felt rather than listed
  • Short enough to finish in two sittings and different on the second pass

What doesn’t

  • The explanation underneath is more ordinary than the halls hiding it
  • Only a handful of speaking parts, and the minor ones stay sketches
  • Readers who need early momentum will find the first fifty pages static
EssentialHow we score

The verdict

Piranesi earns its reputation on craft rather than scale. A narrator this consistent is difficult to write and nearly impossible to sustain, and Clarke holds the voice for the whole book without stepping outside it once to reassure anyone. What keeps the score just below the top tier is the machinery underneath: the explanation, when it arrives, is a smaller and more ordinary thing than the halls concealing it, and the supporting characters exist largely to deliver it. That trade is worth making. Sixteen years of silence produced a short, strange, startlingly kind novel about what survives when a person has been emptied out, and there is nothing else on the shelf quite this shape.

Quick answers

Is Piranesi worth reading?

Voxizer scores Piranesi (2020) 9.1 out of 10 — essential. Piranesi earns its reputation on craft rather than scale. A narrator this consistent is difficult to write and nearly impossible to sustain, and Clarke holds the voice for the whole book without stepping outside it once to reassure anyone.

Who will enjoy Piranesi?

Readers who will follow a voice anywhere and do not need a plot to start on page one. Anyone who loved Jonathan Strange & Mr Norrell and can accept an entirely different kind of book. Readers of C. S. Lewis, of Borges, of any story about someone who has been made to forget.

Who should skip Piranesi?

Anyone who wants a worked-out fantasy world with rules, factions and a map at the front. Readers who need early momentum; the opening is description, weather and housekeeping. Anyone who finds an innocent narrator irritating rather than moving.

What is Piranesi like, in short?

A journal kept by a man who has never left the building he lives in, and does not want to. The narrator's voice carries everything: formal, exact, capitalised, entirely without irony. Clarke hands the reader answers slightly before the narrator reaches them, and that gap is the engine. The mystery underneath is slighter than the world above it; the setting outclasses the plot.

What readers say

Written by Voxizer members and checked by our moderators before they appear.

Written reviews

–

No written reviews yet

Write a review
9–10
0
7–8.5
0
5–6.5
0
3–4.5
0
0–2.5
0

Nobody has reviewed Piranesi yet. Be the first.

All reviews →

Verified sources

Published by the Voxizer editorial team — David Abellán, Ignacio Pineda, Pablo Huguet. Section editor for books: David Abellán.

Revision history

  1. Published

Scores are revised when the facts behind them change, and the change is recorded here. How we score.