Skip to content
Movie reviewExcellent

Poor Things · 2023

Poor Things: Emma Stone leads a gleefully grotesque, fearless odyssey

Poor Things review: Yorgos Lanthimos's Victorian fantasy about a revived woman discovering the world is bold, hilarious and dazzling, if repetitive.

Voxizer EditorialSection editor David Abellán3 min read

Excellent

Editorial score out of 10

Poor Things is a riotous, brazen and visually astonishing film that takes a Frankenstein-style premise and turns it into a coming-of-age comedy about a woman discovering the world with no inherited shame. Yorgos Lanthimos, working with his largest canvas yet, reunites with Emma Stone and screenwriter Tony McNamara after The Favourite, and the combination is as sharp and strange as that pairing would suggest.

8.2
Editorial score
#75
Of 112 movies reviewed
2023
Released
9.4
Best at: Craft

It is not a film for everyone, and it never tries to be. But its sheer inventiveness, and a lead performance of extraordinary range, make it one of the most distinctive studio-backed films of its year. It won the Golden Lion at Venice and brought Stone a second Academy Award for Best Actress.

Poor Things is for viewers who enjoy absurdist comedy, bold visual worlds and provocative films that invite argument.

Story

Bella Baxter begins the film as a lurching, childlike figure in a gloomy black-and-white London mansion, cared for by Godwin Baxter, the scarred scientist who created her, and observed by his earnest student Max. As her mind develops rapidly, she becomes restless, and when the dissolute lawyer Duncan Wedderburn offers to show her the world, she goes.

What follows is a picaresque journey through a fantastical Lisbon, a luxury liner and Paris, as Bella encounters pleasure, philosophy, cruelty and work. The premise lets the film observe society's rules with fresh eyes, and many of the biggest laughs come from Bella's blunt refusal to accept the manners she is expected to perform. The journey's structure is also its weakness, however: episodes blur together over a long running time, and the film's arguments about control and independence are sometimes restated rather than developed.

Poor Things
Poor ThingsSearchlight Pictures UK

Direction and craft

Lanthimos and cinematographer Robbie Ryan create a heightened world using fisheye lenses, vignettes and a shift from monochrome to saturated colour as Bella's perspective widens. The production design, full of hybrid animals, sugar-spun skylines and extravagant costumes, recalls illustrated storybooks and early fantasy cinema, and it is never less than eye-catching.

Jerskin Fendrix's score is wonderfully off-kilter, full of wheezing, bending notes that mirror Bella's unsteady first steps and later confidence. It can be abrasive at first, but it fits the film's personality perfectly.

Watch
Poor Things — trailer

Performances

Emma Stone's performance is the film's engine and its triumph. She begins with jerky, uncoordinated movement and garbled speech, and she evolves Bella with such precise physical and vocal detail that the audience can almost chart her growth scene by scene. She is fearless in the film's frank sexual material and wickedly funny in its social set pieces, including a now famous dance sequence.

Mark Ruffalo, playing against type, is a delight as Duncan, a vain seducer who cannot cope with a woman who has no interest in being possessed. Willem Dafoe, under heavy prosthetics, gives Godwin unexpected tenderness, and Ramy Youssef brings gentle sincerity to Max. Kathryn Hunter and Hanna Schygulla make vivid impressions in smaller roles.

Gallery · 3 imagesSearchlight Pictures UK · Rapid Trailer

Who it is for

Poor Things is for viewers who enjoy absurdist comedy, bold visual worlds and provocative films that invite argument. Fans of Lanthimos's earlier work will feel at home. Those uncomfortable with explicit content, or with a heroine whose sexual awakening is central to the story, should be aware that it is frank and frequent.

What works

  • Emma Stone charts Bella's growth from toddler to philosopher with total commitment
  • Mark Ruffalo is hilarious as a cad whose confidence crumbles by degrees
  • Surreal production design turns every city into a candy-coloured fever dream
  • Bold, often very funny take on autonomy, curiosity and social convention

What doesn’t

  • Episodic structure grows repetitive in the lengthy middle section
  • Frequent explicit sex scenes will alienate some viewers and divided others
  • Its satire of male control is sometimes more blunt than it needs to be

Head to head

Craft
9.49.7
Story
7.88.5
Direction
8.69.3
Performances
9.38.8

Dune: Part Two edges it by 0.7. See them side by side

ExcellentHow we score

The verdict

Poor Things is a dazzling, audacious achievement anchored by one of the best screen performances of its decade and some of the most imaginative design work in recent memory. It was widely acclaimed, though its sexual content and portrayal of liberation were debated. An overlong, repetitive middle and a tendency to state its themes too plainly keep it from the top tier, but its ambition and craft make it excellent.

Quick answers

Is Poor Things worth watching?

Voxizer scores Poor Things (2023) 8.2 out of 10 — excellent. Poor Things is a dazzling, audacious achievement anchored by one of the best screen performances of its decade and some of the most imaginative design work in recent memory. It was widely acclaimed, though its sexual content and portrayal of liberation were debated.

What readers say

Written by Voxizer members and checked by our moderators before they appear.

Written reviews

–

No written reviews yet

Write a review
9–10
0
7–8.5
0
5–6.5
0
3–4.5
0
0–2.5
0

Nobody has reviewed Poor Things yet. Be the first.

All reviews →

Verified sources

Published by the Voxizer editorial team — David Abellán, Ignacio Pineda, Pablo Huguet. Section editor for movies: David Abellán.

Revision history

  1. Published

Scores are revised when the facts behind them change, and the change is recorded here. How we score.