Roma · 2018
Roma: Alfonso Cuaron's intimate memory piece rendered on an epic canvas
Roma review: Alfonso Cuaron's black-and-white portrait of a domestic worker in 1970s Mexico City is breathtaking, tender and deliberately slow-moving.
Excellent
Editorial score out of 10
Roma is a film of enormous technical ambition devoted to a life that cinema has historically ignored. Alfonso Cuaron, returning to Mexico after major international productions, recreates the streets and household of his childhood with astonishing fidelity, but the central figure is not a stand-in for himself. It is Cleo, a live-in domestic worker, and the film asks the audience to spend two hours seeing the world through her daily routines.
- 8.7
- Editorial score
- #47
- Of 112 movies reviewed
- 2018
- Released
- 9.7
- Best at: Craft
It was a major critical success, winning the Golden Lion at Venice and Academy Awards for Cuaron's direction and cinematography, as well as for foreign language film. It also demands a particular kind of attention, and its rewards are closely tied to a viewer's willingness to give it.
Yalitza Aparicio, a trained teacher with no previous acting experience, gives a remarkable, entirely unaffected performance.
Story
The narrative is gentle and episodic for much of its length. Cleo wakes the children, cleans the courtyard of dog mess, serves meals and shares quiet moments with her fellow maid Adela. Sofia, the lady of the house, is struggling with a husband who is increasingly absent. Cleo, meanwhile, begins a relationship with a young man who becomes involved in a paramilitary group.
As the year unfolds, both women face abandonment, and the film's quiet accumulation of detail gives way to several extraordinary, harrowing sequences, including one set against the Corpus Christi massacre of 1971. These are handled without melodrama, which makes them all the more powerful. The film's gaze has limits, however: Cleo is depicted with great tenderness, yet the screenplay rarely lets the audience inside her thoughts, and some critics questioned whether it fully escapes the perspective of the family she serves.
Direction and craft
Cuaron shot the film himself on large-format digital cameras, and the black-and-white images are pristine and richly textured. Most scenes are staged in slow pans or long lateral tracking shots, often from a distance, so that the characters are always part of a busy environment: street vendors, marching bands, cinemas and crowded department stores fill the frame. The effect is of memory made physical.
There is no conventional score. Instead, a meticulously layered soundscape of radios, dogs, aeroplanes, traffic and distant voices surrounds the viewer, placing sounds precisely around the room. Recurring images, such as water washing across floor tiles or a family car squeezing into a narrow garage, are repeated to quietly witty and poignant effect.
Performances
Yalitza Aparicio, a trained teacher with no previous acting experience, gives a remarkable, entirely unaffected performance. Her Cleo is patient, reserved and quietly strong, and the camera's long takes suit her stillness. Marina de Tavira provides an effective contrast as Sofia, whose composure frays under stress and whose treatment of Cleo shifts between kindness and thoughtless cruelty. The children, largely non-professionals, feel convincingly unpolished.
Who it is for
Roma is for viewers who value visual artistry, slow cinema and personal, historically grounded storytelling. Anyone who needs a propulsive plot or frequent dialogue will likely find it trying, particularly in its opening hour. It is best seen with good sound and without distractions, which is somewhat ironic for a film that reached most audiences through a streaming release.
What works
- Black-and-white photography of astonishing depth, detail and control
- Yalitza Aparicio's natural, unforced presence carries the film with quiet force
- Long, layered takes capture a whole city's life around the characters
- Sound design is so immersive it rewards careful listening
What doesn’t
- Very slow, observational pace demands real patience from viewers
- Cleo's inner life is often observed at a distance rather than explored
Head to head
- Craft
- 9.78.8
- Story
- 8.18.0
- Direction
- 9.48.9
- Performances
- 8.99.4
Roma edges it by 0.3. See them side by side
The verdict
Roma is a work of breathtaking craft and deep feeling, one of the most beautifully made films of its decade. Its pacing is deliberately austere, and its distance from Cleo's interior life keeps it from being as emotionally complete as it is visually magnificent. For patient viewers, though, it offers moments of rare power and an immersive portrait of a time and place.




