Skip to content
Hardware reviewExcellent#8 in hardware

Sega Dreamcast · 1998

Sega Dreamcast: the console that got the future right and ran out of time to profit from it

Sega Dreamcast review. Sega's last console brought arcade-grade games and a built-in modem home in 1998, then lost out to the PS2. Is it worth owning today?

Voxizer EditorialSection editor Pablo Huguet9 min read

Excellent

Editorial score out of 10

History keeps grading the Dreamcast on a curve, and for once the curve is fair. Sega launched it in Japan in November 1998, more than a year before Sony's PlayStation 2, with a modem in the box, a memory card that doubled as a handheld and an architecture borrowed from its own arcade boards. Almost everything it attempted became standard practice within a decade. Almost none of it saved Sega, which stopped making the machine in March 2001 and has made software for other people's hardware ever since.

8.8
Editorial score
#8
Of 33 hardware reviewed
1998
Released
9.3
Best at: Features

Judged as a piece of hardware rather than as a story about a company, it holds up well. The chipset was modest and cleverly chosen, the online features were genuine rather than promised, and the library it attracted in three short years is one of the most inventive any platform has had. The weaknesses are real too: a controller that never suited the fighting games the console was good at, a disc format that dated quickly, and an official life too short for its ideas to mature.

Why it existed

The Dreamcast was built to repair the damage of the Saturn. Sega's previous console had been expensive to make and difficult to program, with two main processors that only the most patient studios learned to use well, and it lost badly to the original PlayStation outside Japan. For its successor, the company went the other way: off-the-shelf parts, a cleaner design and tools a PC developer would recognise, including a version of Windows CE for porting PC games.

Development ran in two places at once. An internal team under Hideki Sato chose Hitachi's SH-4 processor and the PowerVR2 graphics chip made by NEC, while a separate group in the United States built a rival design around 3dfx graphics. Japan's version won, the American partner sued, and Electronic Arts, which had backed 3dfx, declined to make games for the console. That last decision mattered more than any spec sheet. Without EA's sports games in the West, or Square's role-playing games in Japan, the Dreamcast went into its fight with two of the heaviest punches already missing.

  1. 1998

    Revealed in Tokyo on 21 May; launches in Japan on 27 November and sells out its limited stock on the day

  2. 1999

    Price cut to ¥19,900 in Japan in June; US launch on 9 September and European launch on 14 October

  3. 2000

    SegaNet opens in the US in September; Phantasy Star Online brings online role-playing to a console

  4. 2001

    Sega announces the end of production on 31 January; the last units leave the factory at the end of March

  5. 2002

    Licensed releases in the US wind down in the first half of the year

The Japanese launch was a warning. A shortage of PowerVR chips limited stock, only one of the four launch games sold well, and Sonic Adventure missed the day by weeks. The American launch, ten months later, went the other way: a large marketing push, a slogan built from the date and the price, and a library of launch games that made the Japanese line-up look thin.

Sega Dreamcast
Sega DreamcastEvan-Amos · Public domain

The hardware

The heart of the machine is a 200 MHz SH-4 with a floating-point unit tuned for geometry, a 100 MHz PowerVR2 that Sega rated at over three million polygons a second, and 26 MB of memory split between system, video and sound. None of those numbers sound like much now, and the PlayStation 2 beat several of them on paper within eighteen months. What they bought in 1999 was a clean, sharp image with effects the previous generation could only fake: proper transparency, trilinear filtering, anti-aliasing and a picture that held at 640 by 480.

The cleverest decision was invisible. The Dreamcast shares its architecture with NAOMI, the arcade board Sega used for much of its coin-op output at the time, so a game written for one could be brought to the other with little loss. For a company whose identity lived in arcades, that was the whole pitch: Crazy Taxi, Virtua Tennis and The House of the Dead 2 at home in versions close to what players had fed coins into.

How it launched around the world
RegionDateLaunch priceModem
Japan27 November 1998¥29,80033.6 kbit/s
North America9 September 1999$19956 kbit/s
Europe14 October 1999£200 in the UK33.6 kbit/s
Australia30 November 1999A$49933.6 kbit/s

Storage was the compromise. Sega's GD-ROM, developed with Yamaha, holds about a gigabyte per disc, comfortably more than a CD and far less than the DVD the PlayStation 2 adopted. It kept manufacturing cheap and licensing costs low, and it also left the Dreamcast unable to play films at a time when a DVD player was a reason in itself to buy a console. Sega saved money on the format and lost a selling point to its main rival.

Watch
Sega Dreamcast — trailer

Online before anyone

Every Dreamcast in the major markets shipped with a modem, a decision Isao Okawa pushed through over objections about the extra cost per unit. It was designed to be removable so that faster connections could be added later, and a broadband adaptor did follow. Out of the box, owners got a web browser and email on their television, at a time when many households had no computer.

It's thinking.

— Sega of America's launch campaign, 1999

The games caught up more slowly. ChuChu Rocket! was Sega's first online release, and Phantasy Star Online in 2000 showed that a console could host a persistent online adventure with players across continents. Downloadable content and in-game voice chat both appeared on the Dreamcast before they became expected elsewhere. The catch was the dial-up world they lived in: slow, metered in many countries, and dependent on Sega keeping servers running for a console it had already stopped making.

Gallery · 3 imagesEvan-Amos, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Design and the controller

The console itself is a small white box, about 1.5 kg, with four controller ports on the front and a swirl logo on the lid: orange in Japan and North America, blue in Europe. It is quieter in its looks than the Saturn and sits well next to a television. The controller is another matter. Based on the Saturn's 3D pad, it is large, has only four face buttons and two triggers, and pushes the hands into a parallel grip many players found awkward. For a console whose arcade fighting games were a major draw, six-button layouts had to be remapped or played on a separate stick.

What the pad got right was hidden inside it. The analogue stick and triggers use Hall-effect sensors, which avoid the drift that troubles many modern controllers, and the two slots on top take the VMU and a rumble pack. The VMU is the most distinctive idea on the whole platform: a memory card with a small monochrome screen, a D-pad and buttons, which showed private information during play, let NFL 2K players pick plays without the opponent seeing, and ran small games on its own.

How it measures up today

Arcade fidelity
9/10
Close to the NAOMI originals in most conversions
Online legacy
9.5/10
Pioneered features consoles adopted years later
Controller comfort
5/10
Bulky, with too few face buttons for fighters
Ease of ownership
5.5/10
Old drives, region locks and a flat clock battery
Library breadth
8/10
Over 600 games across all regions, thin on Western sports

Owning one now

The console's afterlife has been kinder than its retail life. Sega ported many of its Dreamcast games to later platforms, and the company that once competed with Sony now publishes series such as Like a Dragon on its rivals' machines, including Like a Dragon: Infinite Wealth. The PlayStation 2 that displaced the Dreamcast went on to host a library that includes Shadow of the Colossus, and it is fair to wonder what Sega's studios might have done with the same runway.

For anyone without a working console, many of the platform's best games survive in later editions on current hardware. For those who want the machine itself, a large community has kept it alive with private servers for some online games and new unofficial software, so a Dreamcast bought today does more than it did when Sega stopped supporting it.

For you if

  • Collectors who want the platform where Sega's arcade era peaked
  • Anyone curious about how online console play began
  • Players who value odd, experimental games over long franchises

Not for you if

  • Anyone wanting a plug-and-play retro machine with no maintenance
  • Players who need a comfortable pad for six-button fighting games
  • Those who only want the best-known games, most of which exist in later versions

The best way to understand the console is still the maker's own account of it, with the full specification and the price history.

What works

  • Shared NAOMI architecture made arcade conversions near-identical at home
  • A modem in the box, years before online play was normal on consoles
  • The VMU turned a memory card into a second screen and a tiny handheld
  • VGA output gives a sharp 480p picture that still suits modern displays

What doesn’t

  • The controller is bulky, with too few buttons for fighting games
  • Original units are now over 25 years old, with optical drives that wear out
  • Short official life left many series and online services abandoned early

Head to head

Value
7.68.0
Design
8.88.8
Features
9.39.2
Performance
8.68.6

Nintendo 64 edges it by 0.1. See them side by side

ExcellentHow we score

The verdict

The Dreamcast earns its score on ideas and on what it did with modest parts. It brought Sega's arcade games home with almost nothing lost, put a modem in every box before the internet was a household utility, and made the memory card into a second screen. It did all of this on a budget chipset and an inexpensive disc format that were already looking thin when the PlayStation 2 arrived. The controller is the one design choice that has aged badly, and the value mark reflects what owning one means now: an ageing optical drive, a region lock and a reliance on enthusiasts for services Sega switched off long ago. As a piece of consumer electronics it was a commercial failure. As a design for what consoles would become, it was right about almost everything.

Quick answers

Is Sega Dreamcast worth buying?

Voxizer scores Sega Dreamcast (1998) 8.8 out of 10 — excellent. The Dreamcast earns its score on ideas and on what it did with modest parts. It brought Sega's arcade games home with almost nothing lost, put a modem in every box before the internet was a household utility, and made the memory card into a second screen.

Who will enjoy Sega Dreamcast?

Collectors who want the platform where Sega's arcade era peaked. Anyone curious about how online console play began. Players who value odd, experimental games over long franchises.

Who should skip Sega Dreamcast?

Anyone wanting a plug-and-play retro machine with no maintenance. Players who need a comfortable pad for six-button fighting games. Those who only want the best-known games, most of which exist in later versions.

What is Sega Dreamcast like, in short?

Sega's last console, and the first of the generation that the PlayStation 2 went on to dominate. Arcade-board architecture meant home versions of Sega's arcade games lost very little. The first console sold with a modem, years before online play was routine. The VMU and the analogue triggers still read as forward-thinking; the pad itself does not.

What readers say

Written by Voxizer members and checked by our moderators before they appear.

Written reviews

–

No written reviews yet

Write a review
9–10
0
7–8.5
0
5–6.5
0
3–4.5
0
0–2.5
0

Nobody has reviewed Sega Dreamcast yet. Be the first.

All reviews →

Verified sources

Published by the Voxizer editorial team — David Abellán, Ignacio Pineda, Pablo Huguet. Section editor for hardware: Pablo Huguet.

Revision history

  1. Published

Scores are revised when the facts behind them change, and the change is recorded here. How we score.