Skip to content
Anime reviewExcellent

Serial Experiments Lain · 1998

Serial Experiments Lain: it guessed the feeling of the network, not the shape

Serial Experiments Lain review. Triangle Staff's 1998 anime about a networked world has dated in its hardware and almost nowhere else.

Voxizer EditorialSection editor Ignacio Pineda10 min read

Excellent

Editorial score out of 10

A series made in 1998 about a global network, before most of its audience had ever used one, ought to be a museum piece by now. Serial Experiments Lain is not, and the reason is that it never really tried to guess the technology. It guessed the mood.

8.8
Editorial score
#24
Of 93 anime reviewed
1998
Released
13
Episodes

Thirteen episodes, called Layers, follow Lain Iwakura, a quiet fourteen-year-old in a Tokyo suburb, who is sent an email by a classmate who has just killed herself. The classmate writes that she has not died, only put her body down, and that she is still there in the Wired, which occupies roughly the position our internet occupies. Lain's father, a man delighted by machines and vague about his daughter, is only too happy to build her a better computer. Almost everything after that happens to Lain rather than being chosen by her.

It is also among the most demanding things the medium has asked an audience to sit through, and being honest about that is more useful than another round of praise. Lain withholds. It repeats itself. It declines to say what its images mean, and a good deal of it is held frames, hum and a girl not speaking. The reward is real. So is the cost, and any recommendation that mentions only the first is worthless.

The premise

The suburb comes first. Before anything strange happens, the series spends its attention on pylons, transformers, junction boxes and the fat bundles of cable that run above a Japanese residential street, and it puts a hum under all of them. Shadows in daylight have red pools in them. Nothing is explained. By the time a dead girl's email arrives in Layer 01, the show has already established that the infrastructure is the antagonist and the plot is a symptom.

Lain herself is drawn small and soft, in a bear-eared hooded top, against backgrounds that are all right angles and wire. She has a family that shares a house rather than a life: a father who talks to her mainly about equipment, a mother who barely registers her, a sister who finds her embarrassing. At school she is the girl other girls discuss. Her one friend, Alice, tries to drag her out to a nightclub called Cyberia, where the drugs and the hardware are much the same commodity.

What the first three Layers establish, and what the rest of the series elaborates rather than resolves, is that Lain's presence in the Wired is not something she built. It was already there, and it is better at being her than she is.

  1. 6 July 1998

    Layer 01 goes out on TV Tokyo in a slot after one in the morning

  2. 28 September 1998

    The thirteenth and final Layer is broadcast

  3. Late 1998

    An Excellence Prize in the animation division of the Japan Media Arts Festival

  4. 26 November 1998

    Pioneer LDC ships the PlayStation companion, whose script was written first

  5. 1999

    Pioneer Entertainment licenses the series for North America on tape and disc

  6. January 2003

    The series reaches American television through TechTV's Anime Unleashed block

  7. December 2009

    A Japanese Blu-ray box, RESTORE, returns it to print

  8. May 2025

    An authorised derivative game ships under guidelines the rights holder published

That last line is the most telling one. Very few television series from the 1990s have a rights holder that formally invites strangers to make more of them, and fewer still have an audience that wanted to.

Serial Experiments Lain
Serial Experiments LainFrame from the official release trailer, via the Crunchyroll Dubs channel on YouTube

Story and structure

Konaka's scripts do something television is normally too nervous to do: they decline to explain, and they decline to reassure. Information arrives as rumour, as a line of on-screen type, as a voice in a room with nobody in it. Characters state things as fact that the series never confirms. The English titles of each Layer are read aloud by a synthesised whisper before the episode begins, which is either a mannerism or a thesis depending on the day.

The structure works in two halves and the join is visible. The first six or so Layers are a mystery with a shape: a death, a message, a nightclub, a piece of hardware that should not exist, a group of hackers who may be a religion. The stretch after that turns inward, and the series starts arguing with itself about identity, memory and whether a person who is only known through a network is a person at all. It is the more ambitious half and the weaker television. Images recur without gaining meaning, several episodes end more or less where they began, and viewers who abandon the show almost always abandon it here.

Nothing in it is as frightening as an open line that nobody has hung up.

The ending justifies a good deal of the wandering, and it is a genuine ending rather than the shrug the middle threatens. Getting there requires accepting that the series is not going to hold anyone's hand, and that a scene which appears to be padding is often the point being made at length.

Watch
Serial Experiments Lain — trailer

What has dated

The hardware, comprehensively. Lain's room fills with a tower cooled by pipes and a display that hangs in mid-air; people go to the Wired the way one goes to a building, by sitting down at a terminal and logging in. The series is full of period Apple worship, from the operating system on the machines to the speech synthesiser reading the titles, which in 1998 read as insider wit and now reads as a fossil of a particular office. Nobody in it has a phone worth mentioning. The network is a destination.

What has not dated is everything social. A teenager who exists more vividly as a handle than as a body; an account that says things its owner did not say and is believed anyway; a suicide that circulates as content among people who were unkind to the person; the ease with which a rumour becomes a fact because enough machines repeated it. The series treats being online as a condition rather than an activity, and that turned out to be the correct call by a margin of about twenty years.

The show's predictions are therefore worth judging on the right axis. As futurology it is a curiosity. As a description of what a networked life would feel like from the inside, it is close to unnerving.

Gallery · 3 imagesFrame from the official release trailer, via the Crunchyroll Dubs channel on YouTube

How it looks

Triangle Staff were not working with much, and the series turns that into a method. Whole sequences hold on a single composition while sound does the work; characters are framed small, at the bottom of tall shots, with cable and sky above them; the palette is washed out in daylight and sodium-orange at night. The red blotches in the shadows are never mentioned by anyone on screen.

Abe's original designs give Lain a deliberate asymmetry, a single forelock over one ear, that the production staff asked for precisely because it makes her face slightly wrong. Takahiro Kishida's character design for the animation keeps that oddness while making it move, and the result is the rare 1990s show whose main character is instantly recognisable in silhouette. When the series does spend money, it spends it on transitions: hard cuts to static, typography over a black frame, an image degraded until it becomes a different image.

How demanding it is

Difficulty
9/10
Explanation is withheld as a matter of policy
Pace
4/10
Slow throughout, slowest across the middle Layers
Plot clarity
3/10
Coherent in retrospect, opaque in the moment
Bleakness
8/10
Alienation is the subject, not just the atmosphere
Visual spectacle
3/10
Stillness, by design and by budget

None of which would carry thirteen episodes on its own. What carries them is the noise.

How it sounds

Reichi Nakaido, a rock guitarist rather than a television composer, wrote a score that mostly declines to be music. The third soundtrack album collects forty-five ambient cues, which gives a fair idea of how much of the series is texture: drones, room tone, the buzz of a transformer, a guitar figure that arrives once and does not return. Yōta Tsuruoka's sound direction pushes the hum of the power lines up until it sits at the front of the mix, where dialogue would normally be, and leaves it there for minutes at a stretch.

Against that, the opening is a shock every week. "Duvet" was written and performed in English by the British band Bôa, which was an unusual choice for a Japanese broadcast in 1998 and remains the single most recognisable thing about the series. It is warm, melodic and slightly exhausted, and it sets up an expectation the show then spends twenty-four minutes dismantling.

Where to start

Start at Layer 01 and continue in order. There is no film, no compilation cut and nothing to read first. The 2009 Japanese Blu-ray is the best-looking version by a distance; the older discs are soft and dark in a way that flatters nobody. Either audio track is defensible, since the series carries so little of its meaning in dialogue, though the Japanese cast's flatness suits the material.

For anyone mapping it against the catalogue, three neighbours are worth naming. [Neon Genesis Evangelion](/item/neon-genesis-evangelion) is the obvious comparison and the one Konaka rejected, saying he had not seen it until Lain was four episodes in. [Ghost in the Shell: Stand Alone Complex](/item/ghost-in-the-shell-sac) asks similar questions with a police procedural to hold them up. [The Matrix](/item/the-matrix), released the following year, took the same anxieties and made them kinetic.

Head to head

Sound
9.49.5
Story
8.59.2
Animation
8.88.9
Characters
8.39.7

Neon Genesis Evangelion edges it by 0.7. See them side by side

Both are 1990s television about a withdrawn teenager and an unbearable inheritance, and both spend their final act inside a head rather than a plot. Evangelion has spectacle, a cast to care about and a budget crisis that became its style. Lain has none of those and is the more controlled piece of work: quieter, shorter, less interested in being loved, and considerably harder to shake off afterwards.

For you if

  • Viewers who want science fiction that argues with itself rather than explaining itself
  • Anyone drawn to sound design, silence and atmosphere ahead of plot
  • People curious about how the 1990s imagined the life everyone now leads

Not for you if

  • Anyone who needs a story to answer its questions on screen
  • Viewers who lose patience when an episode repeats an image instead of advancing
  • Anyone after the action end of cyberpunk

It is easy to find, easy to finish in a week, and the rights holder still keeps a page up for it.

What works

  • A soundscape of mains hum and power lines that does most of the frightening
  • Thirteen episodes with almost no exposition and no narrator to lean on
  • Yoshitoshi Abe's designs put a cartoon girl inside a documentary about cables
  • An opening theme in English, by a British band, that nothing else sounds like

What doesn’t

  • The middle Layers circle their own imagery instead of moving the story
  • Nearly every character except Lain is a function rather than a person
  • Long stretches are held frames, by design and by the limits of the budget
ExcellentHow we score

The verdict

Serial Experiments Lain is the best argument in anime for making science fiction out of atmosphere rather than prediction. Its machines are wrong and its instincts are right, and the gap between the two is the most interesting thing about revisiting it now. Nakamura's direction holds shots long past comfort, Nakaido's score refuses to become melody, and Konaka's scripts trust an audience further than most writers would dare. The price is a middle third that circles, a supporting cast built from functions, and a series that will lose plenty of people who would have liked where it ended up. It remains a landmark, and it remains hard work. Both things are true, and neither cancels the other.

Quick answers

Is Serial Experiments Lain worth watching?

Voxizer scores Serial Experiments Lain (1998) 8.8 out of 10 — excellent. Serial Experiments Lain is the best argument in anime for making science fiction out of atmosphere rather than prediction. Its machines are wrong and its instincts are right, and the gap between the two is the most interesting thing about revisiting it now.

Who will enjoy Serial Experiments Lain?

Viewers who want science fiction that argues with itself rather than explaining itself. Anyone drawn to sound design, silence and atmosphere ahead of plot. People curious about how the 1990s imagined the life everyone now leads.

Who should skip Serial Experiments Lain?

Anyone who needs a story to answer its questions on screen. Viewers who lose patience when an episode repeats an image instead of advancing. Anyone after the action end of cyberpunk.

What is Serial Experiments Lain like, in short?

A 1998 anime that got the feeling of a networked life right and nearly all of the hardware wrong. Sound carries the dread; the picture is often deliberately, sometimes budgetarily, still. Thirteen Layers that withhold on purpose. The middle third is where most viewers stop. Abe's character designs set against Nakamura's power lines remain the defining image.

What readers say

Written by Voxizer members and checked by our moderators before they appear.

Written reviews

–

No written reviews yet

Write a review
9–10
0
7–8.5
0
5–6.5
0
3–4.5
0
0–2.5
0

Nobody has reviewed Serial Experiments Lain yet. Be the first.

All reviews →

Verified sources

Published by the Voxizer editorial team — David Abellán, Ignacio Pineda, Pablo Huguet. Section editor for anime: Ignacio Pineda.

Revision history

  1. Published

Scores are revised when the facts behind them change, and the change is recorded here. How we score.