Skip to content
Book reviewEssential

Stoner · 1965

Stoner: a quiet life told so exactly that it stops feeling small

Stoner review. John Williams's 1965 novel about a Missouri farm boy turned English teacher is plain, patient and one of the great American books about work.

Voxizer EditorialSection editor David Abellán8 min read

Essential

Editorial score out of 10

Stoner tells you on its first page that its hero was an unremarkable man whom almost nobody remembers, and then spends under three hundred pages proving that remark wrong without once raising its voice. John Williams wrote a campus novel with no satire in it, a love story mostly about work, and a tragedy in which nothing very dramatic happens. It should not hold a reader. It holds almost everyone who opens it.

9.1
Editorial score
#15
Of 61 books reviewed
1965
Released
9.6
Best at: Writing

The reason is the prose, which is as plain as American fiction of its period gets and as exact as anything in it. Williams never decorates a sentence and never wastes one, and the cumulative effect of all that restraint is a book that seems to be telling the truth about an ordinary life. Sixty years after publication, and two decades after its rescue from obscurity, it reads less like a rediscovered curiosity than like a book that was always going to be found.

The premise

William Stoner is born on a hard-scrabble farm in central Missouri, and his father, hoping to make the land pay, sends him to the new College of Agriculture at the state university in Columbia. Stoner works for his board on a relative's farm outside town, takes his soil chemistry seriously, and has no idea what else a university might be for. Then a compulsory survey of English literature puts him in front of Archer Sloane, a sardonic professor who reads a Shakespeare sonnet to the class and asks the farm boy what it means.

He cannot answer. Something has happened to him all the same, and within a few pages he has quietly changed his course of study without telling his parents. The rest of the first act follows that decision outwards: graduate study, friendship with two fellow students, Gordon Finch and Dave Masters, the arrival of the First World War, and a courtship of Edith, a banker's daughter from St Louis, conducted with more determination than understanding. The marriage begins badly. The book does not hurry to tell you how badly.

That time of year thou mayst in me behold

— Shakespeare, Sonnet 73, the poem Archer Sloane reads to the class
Stoner
StonerJesse Hall, Missouri University, Columbia, Mo., period postcard published by Plattner Dist. Co. Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

The writing

Williams writes the kind of sentence that looks easy until anyone tries to imitate it. There are no flourishes and very few metaphors; adjectives are rationed and verbs do the work. When Stoner finally tells his parents that he has abandoned agriculture, the scene is a few short paragraphs of almost nothing said, and it is devastating. Nothing is underlined; the reader is trusted to feel the distance that has opened between a son and the people who sent him away to come back useful.

That restraint is also how the novel handles time. Chapters are short and frequently cover years, yet the narration slows to a near standstill whenever something matters: a lecture, a doctoral examination, an evening in a cold rented room. The pacing is so assured that the reader rarely notices the decades going by until they have gone. It is a style built for endurance rather than display, which is exactly what the life it describes requires.

  1. 1922

    John Edward Williams is born in Clarksville, Texas

  2. 1960

    Butcher's Crossing, his second novel, is published

  3. 1965

    Viking Press publishes Stoner in April; it sells modestly and is soon out of print

  4. 1973

    Augustus shares the National Book Award for Fiction with John Barth's Chimera

  5. 2006

    New York Review Books Classics reissues Stoner

  6. 2011

    Anna Gavalda's French translation becomes a bestseller

  7. 2013

    Stoner is named Waterstones Book of the Year

Characters

Stoner himself is an unusual hero: decent, stubborn, inarticulate about his feelings and fluent about almost nothing except the literature he teaches. Williams refuses to make him either a saint or a fool. He makes poor choices out of loyalty and sometimes out of passivity, and the book is honest about the cost, both to him and to those around him. A reader may want to shake him. That frustration is part of the design rather than a flaw in it.

The supporting cast is sketched more sparingly but rarely thinly. Archer Sloane, dry and remote, is the most persuasive portrait of an inspiring teacher in fiction precisely because he never tries to inspire anyone. Gordon Finch, bluff and practical, moves through the department with an ease Stoner never acquires. Dave Masters gets one of the best speeches in the book, a cynical account of what the university is really for that the novel spends its whole length quietly answering.

The weak spot is Edith. She is seen almost entirely through her husband's incomprehension, and while the novel gives hints of where her coldness comes from, it never takes the reader inside her. Some of that is the point of view the book has chosen. Some of it reads, at this distance, as a limit of the book's sympathy, and it is the one place where its fairness to everyone falters.

Gallery · 3 imagesHistoric columns, Missouri University, period postcard by Tichnor Quality Views. Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons · The Columns, Francis Quadrangle, University of Missouri. Photo: VoyagerMU, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons · Vintage Classics edition (2013), via Open Library

Work and love

The ideas in Stoner are carried by its situations rather than stated, and the central one is vocation. The novel takes seriously something fiction usually treats as background: the daily business of preparing a lecture, marking a weak essay, defending a standard against a colleague who would rather not have one. Stoner loves literature, and the book treats that love as no less real for being undramatic. It is one of very few novels in which a career in teaching feels like a calling worth having.

Set against that is a sober view of what institutions do to the people inside them. The English department is a small world of grievances and alliances, and Williams writes its politics with the clarity of someone who had spent his own career in one. He took his doctorate at the University of Missouri and taught for three decades at the University of Denver, and the novel never mistakes the academy for a refuge. Its question is narrower and harder: what a person can keep faith with when most things go wrong.

That question links Stoner to another novel about a life spent in service and examined late. Kazuo Ishiguro's *The Remains of the Day* gives its butler an unreliable voice and lets irony do the work; Williams gives his teacher a clear-sighted narrator and lets plainness do it. Both are about what duty costs. Stoner is the less clever book and, for many readers, the more consoling one.

Head to head

Ideas
9.09.1
Story
8.48.1
Writing
9.69.6
Characters
9.29.4

The Remains of the Day edges it by 0.1. See them side by side

Editions and translations

For a book this widely read, Stoner had a slow road to it. Viking's first printing found few readers, and the novel survived for decades through a mass-market paperback, a university press edition and the loyalty of writers who kept recommending it. The 2006 reissue from New York Review Books Classics, with an introduction by the Irish novelist John McGahern, gave it a durable home in English, and the French translation by the novelist Anna Gavalda in 2011 turned it into a bestseller across much of Europe. Two years later British booksellers made it their book of the year.

Editions worth knowing
EditionYearWorth knowing
Viking Press hardcover1965The first edition, 278 pages; long out of print
Pocket Books paperback1972The mass-market printing that kept it alive
University of Arkansas Press1998A small-press revival before the wider rediscovery
New York Review Books Classics2006The standard US edition, introduced by John McGahern
Vintage paperback2003A paperback revival three years before NYRB

Any of the current paperbacks will serve. The NYRB and Vintage texts are the ones most readers now meet, and McGahern's introduction is short enough to read afterwards, which is the better order, since it discusses the whole novel.

For you if

  • Readers who love fiction about work, teaching, or a life given to one thing
  • Anyone who admires plain prose that earns every effect it makes
  • Readers of quiet, retrospective novels such as The Remains of the Day

Not for you if

  • Readers who need plot, suspense or a strong forward pull
  • Anyone looking for a satire of academia; this is not that book
  • Readers who find a passive protagonist more maddening than moving

The best edition to start with is the one nearest to hand, but the publisher that rescued the book is the natural place to begin.

What works

  • Prose so plain and exact that a sentence about a ploughed field carries real weight
  • The Sonnet 73 scene shows a vocation arriving, rather than describing it
  • Makes teaching and scholarship feel like work worth a life, without sentiment
  • Short chapters that cover decades without ever feeling rushed

What doesn’t

  • The opening page settles the shape of the life, so suspense is not on offer
  • Edith is drawn almost entirely from outside, and the book loses something for it
  • Readers wanting incident may find the even, low-key tone unrelieved
EssentialHow we score

The verdict

Stoner earns its reputation by doing very little and doing it perfectly. Williams takes the least promising material for a novel, a teacher who stays in one place for forty years, and finds in it a full account of what a working life asks and gives. The writing is close to flawless, the portrait of vocation has no equal we can name, and the restraint that might have made the book dull is what makes its few raised moments land. It stops short of the very top tier because its sympathy does not reach every character equally, Edith above all, and because its even tone will leave some readers outside it. For everyone else it is one of the essential American novels of the twentieth century, and the rare rediscovery that deserves the fuss.

Quick answers

Is Stoner worth reading?

Voxizer scores Stoner (1965) 9.1 out of 10 — essential. Stoner earns its reputation by doing very little and doing it perfectly. Williams takes the least promising material for a novel, a teacher who stays in one place for forty years, and finds in it a full account of what a working life asks and gives.

Who will enjoy Stoner?

Readers who love fiction about work, teaching, or a life given to one thing. Anyone who admires plain prose that earns every effect it makes. Readers of quiet, retrospective novels such as The Remains of the Day.

Who should skip Stoner?

Readers who need plot, suspense or a strong forward pull. Anyone looking for a satire of academia; this is not that book. Readers who find a passive protagonist more maddening than moving.

What is Stoner like, in short?

A whole working life, told in plain, exact prose that makes small events land hard. The best novel we know about vocation: why someone gives a life to teaching and to books. Its tone is even from first page to last, which is its strength and, for some, its limit. Little noticed in 1965, it became a word-of-mouth bestseller across Europe after 2011.

What readers say

Written by Voxizer members and checked by our moderators before they appear.

Written reviews

–

No written reviews yet

Write a review
9–10
0
7–8.5
0
5–6.5
0
3–4.5
0
0–2.5
0

Nobody has reviewed Stoner yet. Be the first.

All reviews →

Verified sources

Published by the Voxizer editorial team — David Abellán, Ignacio Pineda, Pablo Huguet. Section editor for books: David Abellán.

Revision history

  1. Published

Scores are revised when the facts behind them change, and the change is recorded here. How we score.