Skip to content
Album reviewGood

Swag · 2025

Swag: Justin Bieber's loosest record, and his most interesting in a decade

Swag review. Justin Bieber trades stadium pop for hazy guitars and late-night R&B; the best songs are his finest in years, the skits and sprawl less so.

Voxizer EditorialSection editor Pablo Huguet9 min read

Good

Editorial score out of 10

For most of his career Justin Bieber has made records that sound as if they were built to be played in an arena before they were played anywhere else. Swag is the first that sounds as if it was made in a living room, by a handful of people who liked each other, with the tape left running. It is loose, hazy, occasionally half-finished, and for long stretches it is the most interesting music he has put his name to.

7.3
Editorial score
#43
Of 44 albums reviewed
2025
Released
21
Tracks

The album arrived with almost no warning, four years after Justice, and it is plainly a reset. The gloss is gone. In its place are wobbly guitars, voice memos, drum loops that sound borrowed from a bedroom demo, and a singer who has stopped trying to be heard at the back of the room. Not everything works, and the record is long enough to make its weaker ideas obvious. But the best half-dozen songs here are his strongest in years, and they sound like nobody else's.

Taken together, those first eight tracks run under half an hour and would stand as one of the better pop records of the year on their own.

Context

Swag follows a turbulent stretch, and reliable reporting has covered the outline: the rest of the Justice world tour cancelled in 2022 on health grounds, marriage to Hailey Bieber in 2018 and the birth of their son in 2024. The album does not narrate any of this in detail, but it is clearly the material. The songs are about staying in a marriage that has been tested, about becoming a father, about faith as something to lean on rather than perform, and about the strangeness of being watched all the time. It is a record by a man in his thirties who has been famous since he was fifteen, and it sounds like one.

The bigger change is who he made it with. Dijon, the American songwriter whose records sound like warped cassette tapes of old soul, is the album's central collaborator, and Mk.gee, whose guitar playing has become one of the most imitated sounds in recent indie music, co-wrote and produced the lead single. Eddie Benjamin, Carter Lang and Dylan Wiggins fill out a small, consistent team. The result is that a pop star with access to anyone chose a sound with a strong identity of its own and let it lead.

  1. 2010

    My World 2.0, his first full-length studio album, makes him a teen star

  2. 2015

    Purpose reinvents him as a tropical-house and electronic pop singer

  3. 2021

    Justice arrives, followed weeks later by the gospel EP Freedom

  4. 2025

    Swag is released on 11 July with a day's notice; Swag II follows on 5 September

  5. 2026

    Headlines Coachella for the first time, with a set drawn from both Swag albums

Seen in that run, Swag is the most abrupt turn he has made since Purpose, and the first where the new direction was not set by what was already on the radio.

Swag
SwagJustin Bieber / Def Jam Recordings, "First Place" video, via YouTube

The songs

The opening stretch is the case for the whole album. All I Can Take opens slowly, a man pleading his case, and sets the register: intimate, slightly ragged, in no hurry. Daisies, the lead single, is the clearest pop song here, a bright guitar figure and a light, almost offhand chorus about love as a game of chance. It is the one track a casual listener will recognise, and it earned that place. Yukon follows with a woozy, vocoder-treated R&B groove that is the strangest thing he has released as a single and, for many listeners, the best.

Go Baby is a straightforward devotional love song, sung sweetly over a warm, rolling arrangement, and Butterflies keeps the temperature low and the hooks soft. Way It Is, with Gunna, slides the record towards hip-hop without breaking its mood, and First Place is a sincere, mid-tempo love song that keeps the focus on one person. Taken together, those first eight tracks run under half an hour and would stand as one of the better pop records of the year on their own.

The second half is where the album starts to sprawl. Walking Away is a fine, aching ballad about a relationship under strain, and Devotion, with Dijon, is a raw, gospel-tinged duet that shows exactly why the two men work well together. Around them, though, are sketches: Glory Voice Memo, which is what its title says, Zuma House, a brief instrumental-feeling vignette, and the title track with Cash Cobain and Eddie Benjamin, which never decides whether it is a joke or a statement. Sweet Spot, with Sexyy Red, has a playful premise, but the feature arrives like a guest from a different party.

Where to start
TrackWhy
DaisiesThe most immediate song, and the one that shows the new sound most clearly
YukonVocoder R&B that sounds like no previous Bieber single
All I Can TakeThe opener; a slow build that sets the mood for the whole record
DevotionBieber and Dijon trading lines over a gospel-leaning arrangement
Walking AwayThe best ballad in the second half
Watch
Swag — trailer

Production

Dijon's influence is everywhere in the sound. Guitars are slightly out of focus, drums are often dry and close, and vocals are layered with harmonies that seem to drift in from another room. Mk.gee's playing on Daisies has the clipped, chorused tone that has made him a reference point for a generation of producers, and Carter Lang and Dylan Wiggins keep the low end warm without letting it swell into the big pop mixes of Justice. Several songs stop rather than resolve, ending when the idea runs out instead of circling back for a last chorus.

That restraint is mostly a strength. The record feels lived-in rather than manufactured, and the occasional rough edge, a breath, a laugh, a fumbled line left in, makes it sound as if the people involved were enjoying themselves. The cost is that a handful of tracks feel like demos that never received their last pass, and when three of them arrive in a row the album loses momentum.

How it sounds

Energy
4/10
Mostly low-lit and mid-tempo, with a few brighter singles
Intimacy
8/10
Close-miked vocals and spare arrangements throughout
Density
5/10
Twenty-one tracks, but many are short and light
Accessibility
6/10
The singles are easy; the sketches and skits ask for patience
Gallery · 3 imagesJustin Bieber / Def Jam Recordings, "Yukon" video, via YouTube · Justin Bieber / Def Jam Recordings, "First Place" video, via YouTube

Performance

Bieber has always been a better singer than his biggest hits required, and Swag is the first album to prove it at length. He sings softly for most of the record, stays in his upper register, and leans on texture rather than power: a crack in a held note, a run that trails off, ad-libs that sound improvised because they probably were. On Walking Away and Devotion in particular, the feeling is carried by the voice rather than the lyric, which is just as well, because the writing can be plain to the point of flatness.

That is the album's weak spot. The lyrics favour sincerity over detail, and some lines are little more than statements of loyalty or faith with nothing specific attached. When the music is strong enough, as on the opening run, it does not matter. When the arrangement is thin, there is little in the words to hold on to.

Sequencing and cohesion

Three spoken skits with the comedian Druski are spread through the second half: Soulful, Therapy Session and Standing on Business. They are short, they are meant to puncture the solemnity, and on a first listen one or two may raise a smile. On a fifth, they are the tracks every listener will skip. Combined with the run of short sketches, they turn a record that begins with real focus into something closer to a well-curated playlist. A gospel performance by Marvin Winans near the close brings back some of the album's spiritual weight, but the drift by then is hard to undo.

The obvious comparison is *Blonde*, which also uses fragments, voice memos and blurred guitars to make an R&B record feel private. Frank Ocean's album holds its pieces together with a tighter thread; Swag has some of the same textures and more of the loose ends.

For listeners who arrive from Bieber's earlier hits, the shift in sound will be the main question, and the answer depends on how much patience there is for an album that refuses to raise its voice.

For you if

  • Listeners who liked Dijon, Mk.gee or the softer side of recent R&B
  • Anyone who wrote Bieber off after the big pop singles and is willing to try again
  • Fans of albums that sound like they were made in a room, not a lab

Not for you if

  • Anyone hoping for the dance-pop of Purpose or the anthems of Justice
  • Listeners who find skits and voice memos a drag on an album's flow
  • Those who want lyrics with sharp, specific detail

For the songs in the order the artist intended, and for news of the companion record, the official site is the place to start.

What works

  • Dijon and Mk.gee's smudged guitars give Bieber a sound no earlier album had
  • His voice, mostly soft and close-miked, carries more feeling than his big ballads did
  • The opening run from *All I Can Take* to *Butterflies* barely puts a foot wrong
  • Short songs and abrupt endings keep the best tracks from outstaying their welcome

What doesn’t

  • The Druski skits break the mood and do not survive a second listen
  • At 21 tracks the second half drifts, and several sketches feel unfinished
  • Some rap features sound bolted on rather than written in

Head to head

Cohesion
6.28.2
Production
8.28.0
Performance
7.88.6
Songwriting
6.88.8

Virgin edges it by 1.1. See them side by side

GoodHow we score

The verdict

Swag is the record on which Justin Bieber stopped making pop at scale and started making music on his own terms, and the gamble pays off more often than it fails. The partnership with Dijon and Mk.gee gives him a sound with real character, his singing has never been more expressive, and the opening run of songs is as good as anything in his catalogue. The score is held back by everything around that core: skits that wear thin quickly, sketches that needed another pass, guest spots that sit awkwardly, and lyrics that rely on sincerity where detail would do more. A tighter cut of twelve tracks might have been an excellent album. As released, it is a good one with an excellent one hidden inside it.

Quick answers

Is Swag worth listening to?

Voxizer scores Swag (2025) 7.3 out of 10 — good. Swag is the record on which Justin Bieber stopped making pop at scale and started making music on his own terms, and the gamble pays off more often than it fails. The partnership with Dijon and Mk.

Who will enjoy Swag?

Listeners who liked Dijon, Mk.gee or the softer side of recent R&B. Anyone who wrote Bieber off after the big pop singles and is willing to try again. Fans of albums that sound like they were made in a room, not a lab.

Who should skip Swag?

Anyone hoping for the dance-pop of Purpose or the anthems of Justice. Listeners who find skits and voice memos a drag on an album's flow. Those who want lyrics with sharp, specific detail.

What is Swag like, in short?

A deliberate break from stadium pop: soft, guitar-led R&B made with Dijon, Mk.gee and Eddie Benjamin. Bieber's singing is quieter and more expressive than on any of his earlier albums. The first eight tracks make an excellent record on their own. Skits with Druski and a sagging second half keep it from holding together.

What readers say

Written by Voxizer members and checked by our moderators before they appear.

Written reviews

–

No written reviews yet

Write a review
9–10
0
7–8.5
0
5–6.5
0
3–4.5
0
0–2.5
0

Nobody has reviewed Swag yet. Be the first.

All reviews →

Verified sources

Published by the Voxizer editorial team — David Abellán, Ignacio Pineda, Pablo Huguet. Section editor for albums: Pablo Huguet.

Revision history

  1. Published

Scores are revised when the facts behind them change, and the change is recorded here. How we score.