The Banshees of Inisherin · 2022
The Banshees of Inisherin: a bleakly funny parable about a friendship's end
The Banshees of Inisherin review: Martin McDonagh's tragicomedy of a broken friendship on a 1923 Irish island is sharp, sad and beautifully acted.
Excellent
Editorial score out of 10
The Banshees of Inisherin begins with a premise that sounds like a sketch: one man tells another that he simply does not like him any more. Martin McDonagh spins that small, absurd event into a funny, melancholy and eventually harrowing fable about loneliness, pride, kindness and the ways people wound one another. It reunites Colin Farrell and Brendan Gleeson, the pairing at the heart of McDonagh's In Bruges, and their chemistry, even in estrangement, is superb.
- 8.5
- Editorial score
- #61
- Of 112 movies reviewed
- 2022
- Released
- 9.4
- Best at: Performances
It is McDonagh's most controlled film and arguably his best, with the sharp dialogue of his plays tempered by a new tenderness.
His eyebrows alone convey worlds of confusion, and he finds heartbreak in a man whose greatest pride is being nice.
Story
Padraic is a gentle, somewhat simple farmer who lives with his sister Siobhan and cherishes a daily trip to the pub with Colm. When Colm refuses to speak to him, the island is baffled. Colm explains that he finds Padraic dull and wants to use his time to write music that might outlast him. Padraic, wounded and uncomprehending, keeps pushing, and Colm responds with an ultimatum of startling severity.
Around them the island's small community watches: a nosy shopkeeper, a menacing policeman, an eerie old woman who seems to foresee death, and the policeman's troubled son Dominic, who is drawn to Padraic's decency. The distant booms of the Civil War across the water make the connection between this petty feud and a nation turning on itself explicit. That parallel is effective, although the film occasionally points at it more directly than necessary. The escalation of the central conflict also requires characters to make extreme choices, which strains credulity for some viewers even within the fable framework.

Direction and craft
McDonagh's direction is more visually assured here than in his earlier films. Ben Davis's cinematography captures the green fields, stone walls and wild coastlines of Ireland's western islands with a painterly beauty that contrasts with the bitterness of the story. Interiors, from the smoky pub to Padraic's cramped cottage with its animals wandering in, feel lived-in.
Carter Burwell's score has a delicate, fairy-tale quality that suits the film's folkloric overtones. The editing sustains a rhythm that allows comic moments to breathe while quietly increasing the tension.
Performances
Colin Farrell is exceptional as Padraic. His eyebrows alone convey worlds of confusion, and he finds heartbreak in a man whose greatest pride is being nice. Brendan Gleeson matches him with a performance of restrained intensity, making Colm's existential despair and stubbornness understandable even when his actions are not. Farrell won the Volpi Cup for Best Actor at Venice for the role.
Kerry Condon is wonderful as Siobhan, an intelligent, book-loving woman suffocated by island life, and her scenes offer the film's clearest emotional perspective. Barry Keoghan is both comic and deeply sad as Dominic, a young man abused at home whose innocence makes him vulnerable. Even Jenny, Padraic's miniature donkey, becomes an unexpectedly important presence.
Who it is for
The Banshees of Inisherin will appeal to viewers who enjoy dark comedy, character-driven drama and films in which humour and sorrow coexist. Fans of McDonagh's plays will recognise his voice. Those who are squeamish or who expect a light Irish comedy should be aware that its violence, although brief, is disturbing and that the story grows increasingly bleak.
What works
- Colin Farrell's hurt, bewildered Padraic is the finest work of his career
- Brendan Gleeson makes Colm's cold resolve oddly understandable
- Kerry Condon and Barry Keoghan add depth, warmth and heartbreak
- McDonagh's dialogue is consistently hilarious even as the mood darkens
What doesn’t
- The allegory for the Civil War is signposted rather heavily at times
- Its escalation depends on extreme choices some viewers will find contrived
Head to head
- Craft
- 8.68.6
- Story
- 8.57.4
- Direction
- 8.48.2
- Performances
- 9.48.8
The Banshees of Inisherin edges it by 0.5. See them side by side
The verdict
The Banshees of Inisherin is a beautifully acted, sharply written and surprisingly moving film, and it was widely praised as one of the best of its year. Its heavy-handed allegory and reliance on extreme escalation keep it from true greatness, but its performances, especially Farrell's, and its bittersweet insight into human connection make it excellent.





