The Binding of Isaac: Rebirth · 2014
The Binding of Isaac: Rebirth is grotesque, obsessive and almost bottomless
The Binding of Isaac: Rebirth remakes Edmund McMillen's disturbing twin-stick roguelike with hundreds of items, many characters and near-endless replays.
Excellent
Editorial score out of 10
The Binding of Isaac: Rebirth is a roguelike built on obsession. Its dungeons are small and its controls simple, but its item pool, secrets and unlocks run so deep that players can spend years discovering new combinations. Its unsettling themes and grotesque imagery are not for everyone, yet for those who embrace them it is one of the most replayable games ever made.
- 8.8
- Editorial score
- #60
- Of 116 games reviewed
- 2014
- Released
- 9.8
- Best at: Longevity
Rebirth took Edmund McMillen's original concept, rebuilt it with better performance and presentation, and expanded it dramatically.
The soundtrack by Ridiculon blends haunting melodies with driving electronic and rock-inspired tracks, enhancing the eerie atmosphere.
How it plays
Isaac explores procedurally assembled floors made of interconnected rooms, reminiscent of classic Zelda dungeons. Players shoot tears in four directions while dodging enemies and hazards. Each floor contains treasure rooms, shops, secret rooms and a boss, and players must decide how to use keys, bombs and coins.
Items are the heart of the game. Many change Isaac's appearance and behaviour, from altering tear effects to granting flight, homing projectiles, familiars or powerful beams. Items can stack and interact unpredictably, creating builds that range from nearly useless to screen-clearing power.
Runs are short, and death is common. Progression comes from unlocking new characters, items and challenges. Characters vary significantly, with some focused on health, speed or unusual mechanics, and later unlocks provide substantial new twists.
The game's opacity is a double-edged sword. Many items lack clear descriptions, secret rooms are hidden, and unlock conditions can be cryptic. Discovering these secrets is part of the appeal, but many players rely on wikis. Randomness can create unwinnable runs, and some later unlocks require demanding challenges.

World and themes
The premise draws from the biblical story of Abraham and Isaac, reframed through a child's imagination and trauma. The imagery is grotesque, featuring bodily fluids, deformed monsters and religious symbolism.
Beneath the shock value lies a story about abuse, fear, guilt and escapism, told through short cutscenes and multiple endings. Its dark themes are handled with a mixture of dark humour and sincerity, and players who pursue the endings uncover a more reflective narrative.
Presentation
Rebirth replaces the original Flash visuals with detailed pixel art, improving clarity and performance. Enemy and item designs are imaginative and unsettling.
The soundtrack by Ridiculon blends haunting melodies with driving electronic and rock-inspired tracks, enhancing the eerie atmosphere.
Later expansions have added huge amounts of content, including new floors, bosses, characters and items, making the complete package vast.
Who it is for
Players who enjoy roguelikes, discovery and replayability will find a nearly endless game. Those uncomfortable with grotesque imagery, religious themes or heavy randomness may find it off-putting.
What works
- Hundreds of items combine into wildly different, often absurd builds
- A deep pool of unlockable characters, secrets and endings
- Tight, Zelda-inspired room design keeps each floor tense
- A haunting, energetic soundtrack from Ridiculon
What doesn’t
- Grotesque imagery and dark themes will repel many players
- Secrets and item effects are opaque without outside help
- Luck can decide runs, and late unlocks demand heavy grinding
Head to head
- Story
- 7.26.3
- Gameplay
- 9.39.4
- Longevity
- 9.89.2
- Presentation
- 7.98.6
The Binding of Isaac: Rebirth edges it by 0.1. See them side by side
The verdict
The Binding of Isaac: Rebirth offers deep roguelike design, enormous item variety and years of replay value, with a dark, surprisingly thoughtful story beneath its shock tactics. Opaque mechanics, disturbing imagery and luck-dependent runs limit its appeal, but its depth and inventiveness have made it an enduring classic of the genre.




