The Dark Knight · 2008
The Dark Knight: the superhero film that became a sprawling crime epic
The Dark Knight review: Christopher Nolan's Batman sequel, powered by Heath Ledger's anarchic Joker, is a gripping crime saga that still sets the bar.
Essential
Editorial score out of 10
The Dark Knight is the film most often cited when people argue that a superhero story can be serious cinema. Christopher Nolan took Batman out of the gothic fantasy of earlier versions and placed him in a recognisable modern city, then built a sprawling crime saga around the question of what it costs to fight chaos. The result is tense, grand and morally complex, and many of its images and scenes have become part of popular culture.
- 9.2
- Editorial score
- #20
- Of 112 movies reviewed
- 2008
- Released
- 9.5
- Best at: Performances
It is not flawless, and its length and seriousness occasionally become heavy. But its ambition, its craft and one of the most celebrated villain performances in film history keep it firmly among the genre's very best.
Its violence and intense psychological menace mean it may be too dark for younger children despite its PG-13 rating.
Story
Batman, Gordon and Harvey Dent have formed an alliance to dismantle the city's mob, and their success is working. Then the Joker appears, robbing a mob bank in a meticulously planned heist, and offering to kill Batman in exchange for half the criminals' money. His real goal is not profit, though, but to show that Gotham's heroes and citizens will abandon their principles under enough pressure.
The screenplay moves at a relentless pace through heists, kidnappings, assassinations and moral traps. It is structured more like a crime epic in the vein of Michael Mann's Heat than a typical comic-book film. Dent, the city's white knight, is especially well developed, and his arc gives the story tragic weight. The final act is overcrowded, however, adding several climactic sequences and speeches in quick succession, and a subplot involving a city-wide surveillance system is presented with more emphasis than subtlety.

Direction and craft
Nolan's direction is controlled and ambitious. He shot several major sequences on IMAX cameras, including the opening bank robbery and sweeping aerial shots over Chicago, which stands in for Gotham. The practical effects are superb: a truck flipping end over end in the city streets remains one of the most famous stunts in modern blockbusters.
Wally Pfister's photography gives the film a sleek, urban look, and the score by Hans Zimmer and James Newton Howard uses a single sustained, rising note for the Joker that creates constant unease. The editing is dense, sometimes to the point of making action sequences hard to follow.
Performances
Heath Ledger's Joker is extraordinary. With smeared make-up, a lolling tongue and constantly shifting stories about his scars, he is funny, frightening and entirely unpredictable. Ledger died before the film's release, and he was posthumously awarded the Academy Award for Best Supporting Actor, but the performance needs no context to be astonishing.
Aaron Eckhart makes Dent charismatic and idealistic, which gives his storyline real power. Gary Oldman is quietly excellent as the decent, weary Gordon, and Michael Caine and Morgan Freeman provide humour and gravitas. Christian Bale is solid, particularly as the tortured Bruce Wayne, though his gravelly Batman voice has been widely parodied. Maggie Gyllenhaal improves on the previous film's Rachel Dawes, but the role remains thin.
Who it is for
The Dark Knight is for anyone who enjoys crime thrillers, action cinema and superhero stories with genuine stakes. Its violence and intense psychological menace mean it may be too dark for younger children despite its PG-13 rating.
What works
- Heath Ledger's Joker is a truly unpredictable, mesmerising screen villain
- Aaron Eckhart's Harvey Dent gives the story a tragic moral centre
- Practical stunts and IMAX sequences give the action real weight
- Uses a comic-book frame to explore surveillance, fear and compromise
What doesn’t
- The overstuffed final act piles on too many climaxes and speeches
- Christian Bale's growling Batman voice can undercut dramatic scenes
- Rachel Dawes is underwritten despite Maggie Gyllenhaal's efforts
Head to head
- Craft
- 9.38.3
- Story
- 9.07.9
- Direction
- 9.28.4
- Performances
- 9.59.1
The Dark Knight edges it by 0.9. See them side by side
The verdict
The Dark Knight is an exceptional blockbuster that changed expectations of what the genre could achieve. Its gripping story, superb craft and an iconic villain performance make it essential. An overstuffed finale, some clumsy dialogue and underwritten characters keep it just short of landmark status, but it remains one of the most accomplished and influential superhero films ever made.





