The Holdovers · 2023
The Holdovers: a gruff, gentle Christmas film that earns its warmth
The Holdovers review: Alexander Payne's 1970 boarding-school drama reunites him with Paul Giamatti for a funny, melancholy and deeply humane story.
Excellent
Editorial score out of 10
The Holdovers is a film about three lonely people stuck together over Christmas, and its pleasures are old-fashioned in the best sense. Alexander Payne, returning to the bittersweet character comedy that made his name, crafts a film that looks and feels like it could have been made in the early 1970s. It is funny and sad, sharply observed and generous to its characters.
- 8.3
- Editorial score
- #71
- Of 112 movies reviewed
- 2023
- Released
- 9.2
- Best at: Performances
It does not reinvent its familiar premise, and anyone who has seen a story about mismatched outsiders forming a makeshift family will know roughly where it is headed. What makes it special is the specificity of its characters and the richness of its performances.
Da'Vine Joy Randolph won the Academy Award for Best Supporting Actress as Mary, and she is extraordinary.
Story
Paul Hunham teaches ancient history at Barton, and he is proud of his rigour and contemptuous of the privileged boys he teaches. Students and colleagues dislike him in equal measure. When he is forced to stay on campus for the holidays, he runs the remaining boys through tedious study sessions and exercise. Circumstances soon leave him alone with Angus, a clever, angry teenager whose mother has abandoned his holiday plans at the last minute.
Mary Lamb, the head of the kitchen, stays too, because she cannot face leaving the place where her son once studied. The three form an uneasy household, eating in the empty dining hall, watching television and eventually taking a trip to Boston. As they reveal their wounds and secrets, the film gently explores class, privilege, grief and the value of kindness. Some developments are predictable, and a late turn nudges the film towards sentimentality, but the writing remains witty and humane throughout.

Direction and craft
Payne and cinematographer Eigil Bryld give the film a vintage texture, with soft grain, muted colours and snow-covered New England landscapes. Retro studio logos, a period font for the credits and an old-fashioned title sequence reinforce the illusion of a lost 1970s gem. The effect is charming without becoming a gimmick.
The pacing is leisurely. This allows moments of connection to feel earned, but some middle sections, including scenes at a Christmas party and some lingering walks around campus, could have been tighter. The music, featuring period songs and gentle instrumental choices, suits the reflective mood.
Performances
Paul Giamatti is superb as Hunham. He relishes the teacher's elaborate insults and pomposity, but he also reveals the loneliness, shame and self-doubt underneath. His scenes of awkward kindness are among the film's most touching. It is one of the best roles of his career, and it reunites him with Payne nearly two decades after Sideways.
Da'Vine Joy Randolph won the Academy Award for Best Supporting Actress as Mary, and she is extraordinary. Her grief is expressed not through big speeches but through small gestures, dry humour and moments of overwhelming sadness. Dominic Sessa, in his screen debut, is wonderful as Angus, capturing the bratty defensiveness and vulnerability of a boy who feels discarded by his family. Carrie Preston adds warmth as a kind colleague who shows interest in Paul.
Who it is for
The Holdovers is for viewers who enjoy character-driven comedy, bittersweet holiday stories and films with strong performances. It is ideal for anyone looking for a Christmas film for adults that avoids easy cheer. Those who prefer fast pacing or unconventional storytelling may find it too familiar.
What works
- Paul Giamatti turns a pedantic misanthrope into a wonderfully rich character
- Da'Vine Joy Randolph's grief-stricken Mary is quietly devastating
- Newcomer Dominic Sessa is a sharp, natural match for Giamatti
- A convincing 1970s look, from the film grain to the opening titles
What doesn’t
- The story's arc of prickly people softening is familiar and predictable
- A few late developments tip into sentimentality
- Some mid-film scenes drag and could have been tightened
Head to head
- Craft
- 8.58.1
- Story
- 8.08.0
- Direction
- 8.38.6
- Performances
- 9.29.2
Anora edges it by 0.1. See them side by side
The verdict
The Holdovers is a warm, witty and beautifully acted film that brings depth and honesty to a familiar formula, and it was widely embraced by critics and audiences. Its predictable arc, occasional sentimentality and slow patches keep it from greatness, but its three central performances make it an excellent and moving experience that is likely to become a seasonal favourite.





