The Lighthouse · 2019
The Lighthouse: a salt-crusted, hallucinatory descent into madness
The Lighthouse review: Robert Eggers's black-and-white two-hander with Willem Dafoe and Robert Pattinson is bizarre, funny, grotesque and unforgettable.
Excellent
Editorial score out of 10
The Lighthouse is one of the strangest films to find a wide audience in recent years: a claustrophobic, black-and-white two-hander steeped in maritime folklore, flatulence jokes, sea shanties and cosmic dread. Robert Eggers's follow-up to The Witch is funnier, wilder and more experimental than his debut, and it is carried by two extraordinary performances.
- 8.1
- Editorial score
- #80
- Of 112 movies reviewed
- 2019
- Released
- 9.4
- Best at: Performances
It is not a film that offers tidy answers or easy pleasures. For viewers willing to surrender to its madness, however, it is a thrilling, unforgettable experience.
The Lighthouse is for viewers who enjoy experimental horror, psychological dramas, folklore and bold performances.
Story
Ephraim Winslow, a former timber worker, arrives with Thomas Wake to tend a lighthouse. Wake is a gruff, superstitious old sailor who delivers florid toasts and speeches, and he treats Winslow like a servant. The younger man hauls coal, cleans cisterns, repaints the tower and endures his superior's constant criticism, while Wake guards the lamp at the top of the lighthouse and forbids Winslow from going near it.
Winslow becomes fascinated by the light, haunted by a hostile seagull and plagued by visions, including erotic images of a mermaid. As the weather worsens and the two men start drinking heavily, their power struggle, shared confessions and paranoia spiral. The narrative becomes increasingly unreliable, with time and identity growing uncertain. Eggers draws on mythology, particularly the stories of Prometheus and Proteus, but the film deliberately leaves much open to interpretation. That ambiguity is intriguing, though some viewers will find the lack of clarity frustrating.
Direction and craft
Eggers's direction is precise and fearless. Shot by Jarin Blaschke on black-and-white film in a boxy, nearly square frame, the images resemble early cinema and photography, and the narrow frame traps the characters within walls, stairwells and small rooms. The lighting, created to evoke oil lamps and harsh sea light, gives faces a rugged, sculpted look.
The sound design is equally immersive. A booming foghorn punctuates scenes with oppressive regularity, while wind, rain and crashing waves never let up. Mark Korven's score mixes dissonance with ominous low tones. The production design captures the damp, cramped living quarters in convincing detail. The film is often visually grotesque, with mud, vomit, rot and bodily fluids, which suits its descent but can be unpleasant.
Performances
Willem Dafoe is magnificent as Wake. He delivers archaic, poetic dialogue with booming theatricality, and one extended curse, spoken in a rage over a slight about his cooking, is a highlight of his career. He is also funny, needy and pitiable, preventing Wake from becoming a caricature.
Robert Pattinson matches him. His Winslow is quiet and resentful at first, but his accent, physicality and growing volatility make him compelling. As the tension escalates, Pattinson delivers some of the most unhinged and physically committed work of his career. The film's comedy relies on the actors' timing, and their antagonistic chemistry is exceptional.
Who it is for
The Lighthouse is for viewers who enjoy experimental horror, psychological dramas, folklore and bold performances. Admirers of Eggers's other films will find his fascination with historical language and myth at its most intense. Those who dislike ambiguity, bodily grotesquerie or slow pacing should approach with caution.
What works
- Dafoe and Pattinson give wild, fearless, utterly committed performances
- Near-square black-and-white frame creates an intensely claustrophobic mood
- Rich period dialogue, drawn from sailors' speech, is a pleasure to hear
- Unexpected dark humour keeps the escalating madness strangely entertaining
What doesn’t
- Its deliberately cryptic narrative resists any clear interpretation
- Grotesque imagery and relentless grime will repel some viewers
Head to head
- Craft
- 9.39.2
- Story
- 7.47.2
- Direction
- 8.98.5
- Performances
- 9.47.8
The Lighthouse edges it by 0.2. See them side by side
The verdict
The Lighthouse is an audacious, superbly crafted and brilliantly acted film that blends horror, comedy and myth into something utterly distinctive. It won widespread praise, particularly for its leads and its visual style. Its intentionally baffling narrative and grotesque excess will limit its appeal, but as a feat of atmosphere and performance, it is excellent.




