Skip to content
Book reviewExcellent

The Martian · 2011

The Martian: a nerdy survival thriller powered by duct tape, maths and jokes

Andy Weir's The Martian strands astronaut Mark Watney alone on Mars with dwindling supplies. Gripping and funny, with thin characters and plain prose.

Voxizer EditorialSection editor David Abellán3 min read

Excellent

Editorial score out of 10

The Martian began life as a self-published serial and grew into a bestseller and a hit film, and its appeal is refreshingly straightforward. It is a story about one person facing an impossible situation and refusing to give up, using science, engineering and a great deal of sarcasm. It is also one of the most convincing arguments in popular fiction that competence can be thrilling.

8.3
Editorial score
#40
Of 61 books reviewed
2011
Released
369
Pages

The book is not subtle, and its strengths are narrow. But within them, it is superbly effective.

Dialogue is functional and frequently jokey, and few supporting figures develop meaningful arcs.

Science as survival

Most of the novel consists of Watney's log entries, in which he describes each problem and his proposed solution. How can he grow food on a planet with no fertile soil? How can he produce water? How can he travel long distances in a rover designed for short trips? Weir explains each challenge in accessible detail, and the pleasure lies in watching Watney reason through calculations, improvise equipment and occasionally make catastrophic mistakes.

The science is grounded enough to feel credible, although Weir has acknowledged taking liberties, most notably with the strength of the storm that strands Watney in the first place, since the Martian atmosphere is too thin to produce such force. Readers who enjoy technical problem-solving will be delighted; those who find chemistry and orbital mechanics tedious may lose interest.

The Martian
The MartianEdition cover via Open Library

Watney's voice

Mark Watney is irreverent, self-deprecating and endlessly determined. His jokes about disco music, old television and the indignities of his situation make him great company, and the humour prevents the novel from becoming a grim survival story. Yet the relentless flippancy also limits the book's emotional range. There is little sense of the psychological toll of isolation, and moments that should feel devastating are often defused with a quip.

Earth and orbit

Chapters set at NASA and aboard the crew's returning spacecraft broaden the story and add an extra layer of suspense. Engineers and administrators debate risks, public relations and budgets, while scientists race to develop rescue plans. These sections are brisk and entertaining, giving a sense of a vast collective effort.

The characters, however, are thinly drawn. Mission director Venkat Kapoor, satellite controller Mindy Park and the crew commander Lewis are serviceable, but they mostly exist to solve problems or deliver information. Dialogue is functional and frequently jokey, and few supporting figures develop meaningful arcs.

Gallery · 3 imagesEdition cover via Open Library

Style and structure

Weir's prose is plain and conversational, suited to a log format but offering little in the way of atmosphere or description. The Martian landscape is rarely evoked with any lyricism. The structure of crisis followed by solution followed by new crisis becomes predictable, though Weir is skilled at escalating stakes and inserting sudden setbacks.

Who it is for

It is ideal for fans of science, engineering and survival stories, and for readers who enjoyed the film. It is also a strong pick for reluctant readers who like humour and fast pacing. Those looking for rich characterisation or literary prose will find it thin.

What works

  • Survival problems are grounded in plausible science and ingenuity
  • Watney's gallows humour makes a desperate situation hugely entertaining
  • Relentless series of crises keeps tension high throughout
  • NASA's problem-solving on Earth adds scale and procedural fun

What doesn’t

  • Characters beyond Watney are functional and largely interchangeable
  • Constant quips can undercut danger and emotional depth
  • Technical explanations and log format limit prose and variety

Head to head

Ideas
8.49.7
Story
8.98.8
Writing
7.27.5
Characters
7.36.9

The Dark Forest edges it by 0.2. See them side by side

ExcellentHow we score

The verdict

The Martian is a gripping, funny and cleverly constructed survival story that makes scientific problem-solving genuinely exciting. Its flat supporting characters, one-note humour and utilitarian prose hold it back, but its sheer ingenuity and momentum make it an excellent entertainment and a model of optimistic, competence-driven science fiction.

Quick answers

Is The Martian worth reading?

Voxizer scores The Martian (2011) 8.3 out of 10 — excellent. The Martian is a gripping, funny and cleverly constructed survival story that makes scientific problem-solving genuinely exciting. Its flat supporting characters, one-note humour and utilitarian prose hold it back, but its sheer ingenuity and momentum make it an excellent entertainment and a model of optimistic, competence-driven science fiction.

What readers say

Written by Voxizer members and checked by our moderators before they appear.

Written reviews

–

No written reviews yet

Write a review
9–10
0
7–8.5
0
5–6.5
0
3–4.5
0
0–2.5
0

Nobody has reviewed The Martian yet. Be the first.

All reviews →

Verified sources

Published by the Voxizer editorial team — David Abellán, Ignacio Pineda, Pablo Huguet. Section editor for books: David Abellán.

Revision history

  1. Published

Scores are revised when the facts behind them change, and the change is recorded here. How we score.