The Power of the Dog · 2021
The Power of the Dog: Jane Campion's slow-burning Western holds a knife
The Power of the Dog review: Jane Campion's 1920s Montana drama with Benedict Cumberbatch is a tense, beautifully made study of cruelty and repression.
Excellent
Editorial score out of 10
The Power of the Dog is a Western in which most of the violence is psychological and much of the most important action occurs in glances and silences. Jane Campion's first feature in over a decade is a patient, unsettling and quietly powerful study of masculinity, desire and cruelty. It is beautifully made and superbly acted, and its tension tightens so gradually that its impact is only fully felt in its closing stages.
- 8.4
- Editorial score
- #66
- Of 112 movies reviewed
- 2021
- Released
- 9.3
- Best at: Direction
Its measured approach is also its greatest challenge. The film is slow, elliptical and emotionally reserved, and it rewards attention more than it offers conventional excitement.
Shot in New Zealand, standing in for Montana, the film captures vast plains, mountains and big skies with extraordinary beauty.
Story
Phil Burbank is a Yale-educated rancher who has made himself the embodiment of rugged frontier masculinity. He is intelligent, musical and deeply contemptuous of anything he perceives as weak. His brother George, awkward and kind, marries Rose after meeting her at her inn, where Phil had mocked her son Peter for his delicate manners and artistic interests.
At the ranch, Phil's torment of Rose is persistent and subtle: mimicking her halting piano practice on his banjo, mocking her and making her feel unwelcome. She begins drinking, increasingly isolated and anxious. When Peter comes to stay during his holidays from medical school, Phil unexpectedly takes an interest in him, teaching him to ride and braid rope. The film's shifting dynamics are fascinating, and Campion carefully reveals Phil's secrets and vulnerabilities, including his devotion to a late mentor, Bronco Henry. Rose's story, however, recedes as the film focuses on Phil and Peter, which diminishes one of its most compelling characters. The ending is best experienced without prior knowledge.

Direction and craft
Campion's direction is masterful. Shot in New Zealand, standing in for Montana, the film captures vast plains, mountains and big skies with extraordinary beauty. Ari Wegner's cinematography uses light and shadow to reflect the characters' emotional states, and many shots frame people in doorways and windows, emphasising isolation and observation.
Jonny Greenwood's score is a highlight, using cello, banjo and unusual techniques to create a sense of unease and emotional disturbance. The production design, from the dark, wood-panelled ranch house to the dusty barns, grounds the story in convincing detail. Campion won the Academy Award for Best Director, and the film's command of tone and detail makes that recognition easy to understand.
Performances
Benedict Cumberbatch delivers one of his finest performances as Phil. He embodies the character's physical toughness, sharp intelligence and cruelty, but also hints at the pain and repression beneath. Kirsten Dunst is heartbreaking as Rose, conveying fear and fragility through subtle, physically expressive work.
Jesse Plemons is quietly moving as George, a man of few words whose love for Rose is sincere but who seems unable to protect her. Kodi Smit-McPhee is outstanding as Peter, a young man whose gentle demeanour conceals a surprising determination. His performance becomes increasingly intriguing as the story unfolds.
Who it is for
The Power of the Dog is for viewers who enjoy slow-burning psychological dramas, revisionist Westerns and character studies with complex themes. It is especially rewarding for those who like to analyse details and discuss films afterwards. Anyone seeking conventional Western action or a fast-paced plot may find it frustratingly restrained.
What works
- Benedict Cumberbatch is menacing and complex as the volatile Phil
- Kodi Smit-McPhee's unreadable Peter grows ever more fascinating
- Ari Wegner's vast landscapes and Campion's precise framing are stunning
- Jonny Greenwood's discordant strings keep a constant undertow of dread
What doesn’t
- The very slow pace demands patience, especially in the first hour
- Rose's storyline is sidelined as the film shifts focus
- Its subtle, withholding approach may leave some viewers detached
Head to head
- Craft
- 9.08.3
- Story
- 8.37.9
- Direction
- 9.38.4
- Performances
- 8.99.1
The Power of the Dog edges it by 0.1. See them side by side
The verdict
The Power of the Dog is a masterfully directed, beautifully acted and haunting drama that was widely acclaimed and earned major awards recognition. Its slow pace, emotional reserve and sidelining of Rose's story keep it from greatness for some viewers. Nevertheless, its craft, performances and quietly devastating conclusion make it an excellent film.





