The Substance · 2024
The Substance: a gleefully grotesque satire that goes for the jugular
The Substance review: Coralie Fargeat's body horror about a fading star and her younger double is bold, gory and fearless, with a career-best Demi Moore.
Good
Editorial score out of 10
The Substance is a film that knows exactly what it wants to say and says it at full volume. Coralie Fargeat's body horror satire takes aim at the entertainment industry's obsession with youth and the pressure placed on women to remain desirable, and it does so with lurid colours, extreme close-ups and increasingly grotesque practical effects. It is provocative, funny, disgusting and frequently thrilling.
- 7.6
- Editorial score
- #101
- Of 112 movies reviewed
- 2024
- Released
- 8.8
- Best at: Craft
It is also relentlessly unsubtle and considerably overlong, and its final act tests even viewers who have been enjoying the ride. Still, it is a bold, memorable piece of genre filmmaking, and it features one of the most daring performances of Demi Moore's career.
The film's visual style is bright and heightened, featuring glossy studio sets, bold colours and symmetrical compositions.
Story
Elisabeth Sparkle's television fitness show has kept her famous for years. When her crude, sexist producer Harvey decides to replace her with a younger star, her sense of worth collapses. After a car accident, she receives a mysterious offer to become a better version of herself through a treatment. She agrees and follows the instructions, which produce Sue, a young, flawless woman.
Sue and Elisabeth must switch places every week, with one body resting while the other lives. Sue lands Elisabeth's old job and is soon a sensation, but she begins to resent her older self, while Elisabeth becomes consumed by jealousy and self-loathing. The premise is a sharp metaphor for the conflict between a woman and the idealised version of herself demanded by society. The film's message, however, is conveyed repeatedly and forcefully, without much nuance. Once the rules begin to break down, the story moves predictably towards escalating horror rather than deepening its ideas.

Direction and craft
Fargeat's direction is distinctive and confident. The film's visual style is bright and heightened, featuring glossy studio sets, bold colours and symmetrical compositions. The camera often lingers on bodies in extreme close-up, exaggerating the objectification the film criticises. Some viewers have argued that the film indulges in the same leering gaze it condemns, but the approach is clearly deliberate.
The practical effects and make-up are impressive and grotesque, depicting transformations and injuries in gruesome detail. Raffertie's score is pulsing and aggressive, and the sound design amplifies bodily noises to disturbing effect. Fargeat's control of tone is strong in the first two acts, balancing black comedy and dread, but the final act's gore becomes so extravagant that it tips into exhausting spectacle.
Performances
Demi Moore is exceptional as Elisabeth. She conveys vulnerability, desperation and self-hatred with painful honesty, and she is fearless in scenes that expose her physically and emotionally. A sequence in which she prepares for a date and repeatedly examines her appearance in the mirror is devastating. The performance won her a Golden Globe and wide acclaim.
Margaret Qualley is excellent as Sue, capturing the character's confidence, ambition and cruelty with an unsettling blankness. Dennis Quaid plays Harvey as a loud, grotesque caricature of sexist showbusiness executives; he is entertaining, but the character is deliberately one-dimensional.
Who it is for
The Substance is for viewers who enjoy body horror, satire and bold, provocative filmmaking. Fans of David Cronenberg and extreme genre cinema will appreciate its commitment. Anyone sensitive to graphic gore, nudity or disturbing imagery should avoid it, as it is extremely explicit.
What works
- Demi Moore gives a raw, courageous performance of ageing and self-loathing
- Margaret Qualley makes Sue both seductive and chillingly empty
- Bold, saturated visual design and gruesome practical effects
- A clear, furious satire of beauty standards and the entertainment industry
What doesn’t
- Its satire is blunt and repeats the same point rather than developing it
- The overlong final act pushes excess to the point of exhaustion
- Dennis Quaid's producer is an intentionally broad caricature
Head to head
- Craft
- 8.89.7
- Story
- 7.08.5
- Direction
- 8.39.3
- Performances
- 8.68.8
Dune: Part Two edges it by 1.3. See them side by side
The verdict
The Substance is a daring, visually striking and brilliantly performed satire, and it was one of the most talked-about films of its year, winning the screenplay prize at Cannes. Its blunt, repetitive message and excessive final act keep it from greatness, but Demi Moore's performance and Fargeat's audacious vision make it a good and often exhilarating experience.





