The Truman Show · 1998
The Truman Show: a sunny satire that saw the reality-TV age coming
The Truman Show review: Peter Weir's comedy-drama about a man whose life is secretly a TV show is funny, moving and more relevant than ever, led by Jim Carrey.
Excellent
Editorial score out of 10
The Truman Show is a rare Hollywood film that is both a crowd-pleasing entertainment and a sharp piece of social satire. Released before reality television and social media became dominant forces, it imagined a world in which a man's life is a product consumed by millions. It is funny, poignant and thought-provoking, and its central performance showed Jim Carrey's range beyond broad comedy.
- 8.9
- Editorial score
- #35
- Of 112 movies reviewed
- 1998
- Released
- 9.2
- Best at: Story
More than two decades later, its themes of surveillance, performance and manufactured authenticity feel more relevant than ever.
He is married to Meryl, a nurse with a habit of mentioning products, and his best friend Marlon brings beer and reassurance.
Story
Truman lives in a pastel-coloured town where everyone smiles, the weather is always pleasant and neighbours greet him with the same cheerful phrases each morning. He is married to Meryl, a nurse with a habit of mentioning products, and his best friend Marlon brings beer and reassurance. Truman longs to travel, particularly to Fiji, to find Lauren, a woman he met briefly in college, but a childhood trauma has left him terrified of water.
When a studio light falls from the sky and he glimpses a man he believed to be dead, Truman begins noticing inconsistencies: repeating patterns of people, strange radio transmissions and obstacles preventing him from leaving. The screenplay alternates between Truman's growing paranoia and scenes from the production control room and the show's audience, led by Christof, the show's visionary creator. The concept is brilliantly realised, although some practical aspects of the world, such as how it has been sustained for decades, require a leap of faith.
Direction and craft
Peter Weir's direction is precise and elegant. Seahaven looks like an idealised advertisement, with immaculate houses, clean streets and bright colours. Much of the film is shot as if through hidden cameras, with vignettes, odd angles and obstructed views, reminding the audience that Truman is always being watched.
The production design and cinematography create a world that is both appealing and unsettling. The score, combining original music by Burkhard Dallwitz with pieces by Philip Glass, gives the film a sense of wonder and melancholy. Weir moves smoothly between satire, comedy and emotional drama, and the climactic scenes are powerfully staged.
Performances
Jim Carrey is superb as Truman. His natural charm and comic timing make Truman's everyday optimism endearing, and his performance becomes increasingly moving as Truman's suspicion and desperation grow. It remains one of the best performances of Carrey's career, and it earned him a Golden Globe.
Laura Linney is very funny as Meryl, whose fixed smile and awkward product endorsements satirise the artificiality of television. Noah Emmerich gives Marlon a sad, conflicted quality. Ed Harris is excellent as Christof, whose soft-spoken manner conceals a controlling and manipulative worldview. Natascha McElhone brings warmth to Lauren, though her role is brief.
Who it is for
The Truman Show is for almost everyone. It works as a light comedy for younger viewers and as a thoughtful satire for adults, and it is an excellent introduction for anyone who knows Jim Carrey only from his broader comedies. Viewers interested in media, surveillance and identity will find plenty to discuss.
What works
- Jim Carrey shows remarkable restraint, balancing comedy and pathos
- A clever, prescient concept about surveillance, media and control
- Ed Harris's Christof is a calm, paternal and chilling creator
- Weir's glossy, candy-coloured Seahaven is both idyllic and sinister
What doesn’t
- Some logistical questions about the show's world are best ignored
- Supporting characters exist more as devices than as people
Head to head
- Craft
- 8.79.0
- Story
- 9.29.5
- Direction
- 8.99.1
- Performances
- 8.89.2
Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind edges it by 0.3. See them side by side
The verdict
The Truman Show is an exceptional blend of entertainment and insight, with a brilliant concept, a finely judged central performance and assured direction. It was a critical and commercial success and has only grown in cultural relevance. A few implausibilities and thinly drawn supporting characters are the only things holding it back from the highest tier, but it remains a smart, humane and timeless film.




