The Walking Dead · 2003
The Walking Dead comic is a relentless, sixteen-year study of survival and power
The Walking Dead, Robert Kirkman and Charlie Adlard's 193-issue Image saga, is a gripping, brutal survival drama whose endless cycle of loss can grow repetitive.
Excellent
Editorial score out of 10
The Walking Dead began with a simple promise: a zombie story that would never end in the way films do. Robert Kirkman wanted to show what happens after the survivors escape, after the credits would normally roll, and over sixteen years and nearly two hundred issues he did exactly that. The result became one of the most successful independent comics ever published and spawned a multimedia franchise.
- 8.1
- Editorial score
- #40
- Of 53 comics reviewed
- 2003
- Released
- 193
- Issues
It is also a book of highs and lows. When it works, it is an intense, morally complicated drama about survival and leadership. When it does not, it can feel like a machine for manufacturing misery.
The result became one of the most successful independent comics ever published and spawned a multimedia franchise.
Life after the end
The opening issues, drawn by Tony Moore, follow Rick Grimes as he wakes in hospital, travels through a ruined landscape and finds his family. From there, the group moves from camp to farm to prison and beyond, encountering other survivors and trying to build a stable home. Kirkman's key insight is that the dead are a constant background threat, while the real danger lies in human beings, their desperation, cruelty and ambition.
The cast is large and constantly changing. Glenn, Michonne, Andrea and Carl are among those who grow and change dramatically, and Kirkman shows how survival reshapes their morality. Rick, in particular, becomes a fascinating figure, whose choices as a leader become increasingly difficult and ruthless.

Adlard's grey world
Charlie Adlard's art defines the series. His black-and-white style, with heavy shadow and Cliff Rathburn's grey tones, suits the grim world, and his layouts are clear and functional. He is especially effective at showing the scale of zombie hordes and the claustrophobia of confined spaces. Tony Moore's opening issues are more detailed and gruesome, and the change in style is noticeable.
Adlard's characters, though, can be difficult to distinguish, especially bearded men in similar clothes. His faces sometimes lack subtlety, which can blunt emotional scenes.
The long cycle
The Walking Dead's biggest weakness is repetition. Many arcs follow a similar pattern: the group finds a safe place, meets a new human threat, conflict escalates and someone important is lost. Kirkman varies this with new settings and ideas, including larger societies and the challenges of rebuilding civilisation, but the structure can become predictable over nearly two hundred issues.
The series is also known for its shocking deaths and extreme violence, which can be powerful but occasionally feel designed to provoke rather than to deepen character. The dialogue is often expository, with long speeches explaining motivations. Nevertheless, the series' later chapters explore more ambitious themes of society and justice, and it concluded with a surprise final issue that ended the story on its own terms.
Who it is for
The Walking Dead is for readers who enjoy long, character-driven survival stories and can handle graphic violence and emotional loss. Fans of the television adaptation will find the comic similar in spirit but different in many details, often more extreme and more focused. The compendium editions offer an efficient way to read the full saga.
What works
- Follows survivors for years past where most zombie stories stop
- Rick's evolution as a leader is gripping and morally complex
- Explores how communities, laws and societies rebuild after collapse
- An ending that concludes the series on its own thoughtful terms
What doesn’t
- The cycle of settlement, threat and loss becomes repetitive
- Charlie Adlard's characters can be hard to tell apart
- Shock violence sometimes overwhelms character development
Head to head
- Art
- 7.68.2
- Story
- 8.28.7
- Pacing
- 7.48.1
- Characters
- 8.58.9
Y: The Last Man edges it by 0.5. See them side by side
The verdict
The Walking Dead is a gripping, ambitious and influential series that turned a zombie premise into a long, meaningful exploration of human nature and society. Its repetitive structure, hard-to-distinguish characters and reliance on shock hold it back. An 8.1 reflects an excellent, landmark series whose power sometimes gets lost in its length.




