The Whale · 2022
The Whale: Brendan Fraser's great performance, trapped inside a heavy film
The Whale review: Darren Aronofsky's drama about a reclusive teacher and his estranged daughter features a moving Brendan Fraser but is stagy and manipulative.
Mixed
Editorial score out of 10
The Whale is a film of powerful individual moments and a very strong central performance, but its emotional manipulation and stagebound structure undermine its impact. Darren Aronofsky's adaptation of Samuel D. Hunter's play aims to be a story of redemption and compassion, and Brendan Fraser gives it real heart. Too often, though, it relies on melodramatic confrontations and a heavy approach to suffering.
- 6.7
- Editorial score
- #111
- Of 112 movies reviewed
- 2022
- Released
- 8.6
- Best at: Performances
It divided critics sharply on release. Many were moved by Fraser's work and the film's themes of forgiveness, while others found its portrayal of obesity and grief both exploitative and emotionally forced. Both reactions are understandable.
His performance won the Academy Award for Best Actor, and it is moving even when the material around him is heavy-handed.
Story
Charlie spends his days in a dim, cluttered apartment, teaching online classes and eating compulsively. His weight and heart condition make everyday movement difficult. His only regular visitor is Liz, a nurse whose connection to Charlie is linked to his late partner. Over the course of a week, Charlie receives unexpected visits from Thomas, a young missionary, and from Ellie, the daughter he abandoned when she was a child, now an angry teenager.
Charlie tries to rebuild his relationship with Ellie by offering to help her with school essays, while Thomas tries to save his soul. Charlie's past, including the circumstances surrounding his partner's death, is revealed gradually. The central theme, the need to find goodness in others and to be honest, is sincere, and Charlie's obsession with an essay about Moby-Dick adds a literary framework. However, the dialogue is often expository and theatrical, and the story relies on revelations and confrontations that feel manufactured. Ellie's cruelty is so extreme that her eventual complexity feels unearned.

Direction and craft
Aronofsky confines the film almost entirely to Charlie's apartment, and the narrow aspect ratio emphasises the claustrophobia. This approach captures Charlie's isolation, but it also makes the film feel like a filmed play, with characters constantly entering and leaving.
The film's depiction of Charlie's body has been widely debated. Fraser wore extensive prosthetics, and while the make-up is technically impressive and won an Academy Award, the camera sometimes lingers on eating binges and physical struggles in ways that feel designed to shock or elicit pity. Rob Simonsen's score is emotive, and the relentless rain and gloomy lighting reinforce the sombre mood, though the result can feel overwrought.
Performances
Brendan Fraser is the reason to see The Whale. He brings kindness, humour and deep regret to Charlie, often conveying emotion through his eyes and voice. His performance won the Academy Award for Best Actor, and it is moving even when the material around him is heavy-handed.
Hong Chau is superb as Liz, capturing her love, grief and frustration with a sharp, understated intensity. Sadie Sink commits to Ellie's rage, but the character is so relentlessly cruel that she becomes more a device than a person. Ty Simpkins is serviceable as Thomas, and Samantha Morton makes a strong impression in a brief, bitter scene as Charlie's ex-wife.
Who it is for
The Whale is for viewers who appreciate intense performance-driven dramas and stage adaptations. Admirers of Brendan Fraser will find much to value. Those sensitive to depictions of obesity, self-destructive behaviour and emotional manipulation may find it uncomfortable or distasteful.
What works
- Brendan Fraser gives a warm, vulnerable and deeply felt lead performance
- Hong Chau is excellent as Liz, a friend whose care is tangled with anger
- The confined setting creates a vivid sense of claustrophobia and isolation
What doesn’t
- Heavy-handed, melodramatic writing pushes hard for tears
- Ellie is written as so cruel that she becomes hard to believe
- Its camera often treats Charlie's body as a spectacle of misery
Head to head
- Craft
- 6.98.6
- Story
- 6.07.4
- Direction
- 6.38.2
- Performances
- 8.68.8
Marcel the Shell with Shoes On edges it by 1.3. See them side by side
The verdict
The Whale features a remarkable, humane central performance and a strong supporting turn from Hong Chau, but it is weighed down by melodramatic writing, a stagy structure and a troubling approach to its subject. Fraser's work gives it real emotional force, yet the film around him is too heavy-handed to be more than a mixed success.





