Us · 2019
Us: Jordan Peele's mirror-image nightmare is bigger, stranger and messier
Us review: Jordan Peele's doppelgänger horror has a towering Lupita Nyong'o performance and indelible images, even when its mythology starts to wobble.
Good
Editorial score out of 10
Us arrived carrying the weight of Get Out's success, and Jordan Peele responded not by repeating himself but by swinging wider. Where his debut was a precision instrument, this is a sprawling, image-rich horror film about doubles, privilege and the people a comfortable society prefers not to see. It is frequently terrifying and often very funny. It is also less tidy, and the harder it leans on explaining itself, the more its spell loosens.
- 7.8
- Editorial score
- #95
- Of 112 movies reviewed
- 2019
- Released
- 9.0
- Best at: Performances
What keeps it compelling throughout is Lupita Nyong'o, whose work in two roles ranks among the finest horror performances of its decade. Even when the logic frays, she makes every scene feel urgent.
What keeps it compelling throughout is Lupita Nyong'o, whose work in two roles ranks among the finest horror performances of its decade.
Premise and structure
The setup is elegantly simple. A prologue in 1986 establishes a girl's encounter in a boardwalk hall of mirrors; decades later, that girl is a mother, uneasy about returning to the same stretch of coast. The first act is patient and domestic, full of sly observation about middle-class family life, from Gabe's boat envy to the kids' bickering. Then the doubles appear in the driveway, holding hands, and the film shifts gear.
The home-invasion sequence that follows is the best thing Peele has staged. The Tethered, as the doubles are called, are grotesque parodies of their originals, and the confrontation in the living room is shot with a patient, theatrical stillness that makes the eventual violence land harder. Peele understands that a figure simply standing still in the dark can be scarier than any jump scare.

Performances
Nyong'o plays both Adelaide and Red, her double, and the contrast is astonishing. Adelaide is guarded, protective and quietly haunted; Red speaks in a strangled rasp, moving with a jerky, marionette physicality that feels genuinely unnatural. Winston Duke gives Gabe a goofy warmth that keeps the film funny even in its darkest stretches, and Elisabeth Moss makes a vivid impression as a boozy neighbour and, briefly, as her own unsettling twin. Shahadi Wright Joseph and Evan Alex handle their dual roles with real discipline for young performers.
Ideas and mythology
This is where opinion divides. Us is dense with suggestion: the Hands Across America campaign, recurring images of rabbits, Jeremiah 11:11, the notion of an underclass that mirrors those above it. Taken as a nightmare's logic, it is rich and provocative. But the film eventually offers a fairly literal explanation of where the doubles come from, and that exposition invites practical questions it cannot comfortably answer. Horror has always run on dream logic, yet Us sets up a mystery-box structure and then half commits to solving it, which leaves some viewers more puzzled than haunted.
The final act also opens outward, away from the family and towards something larger, and while the imagery is striking, the tight grip of the early scenes slackens.
Craft
Mike Gioulakis' cinematography makes excellent use of reflections, symmetry and deep shadow, and the boardwalk sequences have a grimy, sun-bleached menace. Michael Abels' score is a highlight, particularly its choral, string-heavy reworking of a mid-1990s Luniz hip-hop hit into a slowly unravelling threat. Sound design is precise, and the red jumpsuits and golden scissors give the film an iconography that has lasted.
What works
- Lupita Nyong'o is extraordinary in two sharply opposed roles
- The driveway reveal and home invasion are masterfully staged
- Michael Abels' score turns a hip-hop track into pure menace
- Winston Duke's comic timing makes the family feel lived-in
What doesn’t
- The late explanation of the doubles raises more questions than it settles
- Allegorical ideas pile up faster than the film can develop them
- The final act trades tight dread for a sprawling, looser scale
Head to head
- Craft
- 8.38.4
- Story
- 7.09.1
- Direction
- 8.48.9
- Performances
- 9.09.0
Get Out edges it by 1.1. See them side by side
The verdict
Us is more ambitious and less controlled than Get Out, and its reception reflected that: widely admired, frequently debated, rarely dismissed. The direction is confident, the central performance is exceptional and several sequences are among the most frightening in modern studio horror. A mythology that buckles under scrutiny and an overstuffed final stretch hold it back from the very top tier, which is why it lands at 7.8 rather than higher.





