Skip to content
Comic reviewEssential#10 in comics

Vagabond · 1998

Vagabond: the best-drawn sword story in comics, and an unfinished one

Vagabond review. Takehiko Inoue's Musashi manga is drawn like few comics ever have been, but it has sat on hiatus since 2015 with its story still open.

Voxizer EditorialSection editor David Abellán9 min read

Essential

Editorial score out of 10

Few comics have ever looked like Vagabond, and none has made stillness so exciting to look at. Takehiko Inoue took a novel every Japanese reader knew, Eiji Yoshikawa's Musashi, and redrew its young swordsman as something closer to an animal: filthy, furious, and so hungry to be the strongest man alive that he cannot see the people he hurts on the way. Over seventeen years of serialisation, the comic follows that animal as it slowly learns to be a person.

9.1
Editorial score
#10
Of 53 comics reviewed
1998
Released
9.9
Best at: Art

It is also unfinished. Vagabond has been on indefinite hiatus since May 2015, its 37 volumes stopping in the middle of a journey rather than at a natural pause. That matters for anyone deciding whether to start, and the review below is honest about it. It does not change the fact that the volumes that exist contain some of the finest drawing the medium has produced, in any country, in any genre.

In Vagabond, losing means dying, and so does winning carelessly, and the comic never lets Musashi or the reader forget it.

The premise

The comic opens in 1600, in the mud after the Battle of Sekigahara. Two seventeen-year-olds from the same village, Shinmen Takezō and his friend Hon'iden Matahachi, have fought on the losing side and lie among the dead while survivor hunters comb the field. They escape together and swear to become invincible under the heavens. Then their paths split: Matahachi drifts towards an easier life, and Takezō goes home alone to tell his friend's family that Matahachi is alive.

Home is the worst place he could go. The village already fears Takezō for his violence, and Matahachi's mother, Osugi, wants someone to blame for her missing heir. Hunted through the hills like the animal they think he is, Takezō is finally brought to heel not by a stronger fighter but by the monk Takuan, who gives him a new name taken from his home village. Miyamoto Musashi walks out of that first act with a sword, a reputation and almost no idea what he is for, and the rest of the comic is the search for an answer.

  1. 1998

    Serialisation begins in Kodansha's Morning on 3 September

  2. 2000

    Wins the Grand Prize for manga at the Japan Media Arts Festival and the Kodansha Manga Award

  3. 2002

    Grand Prize of the Tezuka Osamu Cultural Prize; VIZ Media begins the English volumes

  4. 2008

    VIZ launches the VIZBIG Edition, three volumes to a book

  5. 2012

    Returns after an eighteen-month break, now as a monthly series

  6. 2015

    Chapter 327 is published in May; the series goes on indefinite hiatus

  7. 2025

    VIZ begins the large-format Definitive Edition in January

Vagabond
VagabondVIZ Media, Vagabond: Definitive Edition Vol. 1 trailer

The writing

Inoue came to Vagabond straight from Slam Dunk, the basketball manga that made him famous, and the two works share more than first appears. Both are about a talented, arrogant young man learning that winning is not the same as understanding the game. The difference is the stakes. In Vagabond, losing means dying, and so does winning carelessly, and the comic never lets Musashi or the reader forget it.

What sets the writing apart from most samurai fiction is its interest in the inside of a fight. A duel in Vagabond is rarely about technique for its own sake. It is about fear, about what Musashi notices and fails to notice, about the moment an opponent's calm frightens him more than a blade would. The early challenges, against the Yoshioka school in Kyoto and the spearmen of the Hōzōin temple, work as lessons in that sense: each one leaves Musashi alive and slightly less certain of what strength means.

Inoue also takes real liberties with Yoshikawa. Supporting characters are rewritten with different temperaments, and Kojirō, the rival history has waiting at the end of Musashi's road, is reimagined so completely that he gets an extended stretch of the series to himself. That strand is among the boldest decisions in the comic, and it reads as a second story about the same question rather than a detour from the first.

How it reads

Art and detail
10/10
Faces, hands, rain and grass, drawn with equal care
Violence
8.5/10
Frequent, anatomical and lingering
Philosophical weight
8.5/10
More interested in why a man fights than how
Pace
5.5/10
Brisk early on, then increasingly contemplative
Closure
2/10
No ending; on hiatus since May 2015
Watch
Vagabond — trailer

The art

This is the reason Vagabond is spoken of the way it is. Inoue's figures are drawn from an understanding of how bodies work rather than how comics usually show them moving, so a duel has weight, balance and consequence instead of speed lines. He has said that his assistants handled backgrounds while he drew the people, and the division shows in the best way: every face is his, and every face is specific.

Over the run the line changes. The early volumes are drawn with a precise, almost illustrative pen; later chapters lean towards the brush, with looser, wetter strokes that suit a story increasingly concerned with stillness, nature and the mind. Pages of a man sitting in a field, or water moving over stones, carry as much tension as the fights do. The colour pages, retained in the English editions from the magazine run, show Inoue as a watercolourist of real range.

The craft has a cost in tone. The violence is depicted with medical frankness, wounds are lingered on, and parts of the story include sexual content. None of it is gratuitous by the standards of the genre, but this is a comic for adults, and the realism that makes the duels land also makes their aftermath hard to look at.

Gallery · 2 imagesVIZ Media, Vagabond: Definitive Edition Vol. 1 trailer

Characters

Musashi is the centre, and the comic's great achievement is that his change is slow enough to believe. The arrogant fighter of the opening is not replaced by a sage overnight; he keeps backsliding, keeps choosing the sword over the people who care for him, and keeps learning the same lessons at a higher price. Inoue has said he wanted to show the young man before enlightenment rather than the legend after it, and the comic keeps that promise.

Around him, the supporting cast are drawn as fully as he is. Takuan, the monk who names him, is funny and sharp rather than serene. Matahachi, the friend who chose comfort, becomes one of the most painfully human characters in manga: weak, boastful, self-pitying, and impossible to dismiss. Otsū, the young woman who waits for Musashi, has more interior life here than the tradition usually gives her, though the comic is still more interested in its swordsmen than in anyone else.

Pacing and editions

Vagabond's pace is a matter of taste rather than a flaw, up to a point. The early volumes move quickly from challenge to challenge. The later ones slow down on purpose, spending chapters on recovery, labour and reflection, and readers who arrived for duels may find the turn frustrating. Combined with the hiatus, it means the final volumes in print are its quietest.

Collected editions
EditionVolumesWorth knowing
Kodansha (Japanese)37The original collection, 1999 to 2014
VIZ standard (English)372002 to 2015, with the magazine's colour pages
VIZBIG Edition (English)12Three volumes to a book; 728 pages in volume 1
Definitive Edition (English)In progressLarge 7 × 10 inch hardcovers from January 2025

For English readers the choice is between the VIZBIG Edition, which is complete and compact, and the Definitive Edition, whose larger page does more justice to the art but is still being published.

Vagabond shares a shelf with Kentaro Miura's dark fantasy, and the comparison is worth making. Both are unfinished epics about a swordsman built on extraordinary draughtsmanship, but Berserk is a story of rage turned outward, and Vagabond one of rage slowly turned inward and examined.

Head to head

Art
9.99.8
Story
8.79.2
Pacing
7.87.6
Characters
9.39.4

Berserk edges it by 0.1. See them side by side

Readers who came to the samurai period through games will find much of the imagery here familiar: the windblown grass and the duel at a distance in Ghost of Tsushima, or the posture-and-timing combat of Sekiro, sit comfortably next to the way Vagabond pictures a sword fight: patient, physical, and decided in a moment.

For you if

  • Readers who want a historical epic where the fights mean something beyond who wins
  • Anyone interested in drawing, ink or the craft of comics at its highest level
  • Fans of slow, character-led storytelling who do not need an ending to enjoy the road

Not for you if

  • Readers who need a finished story before committing to 37 volumes
  • Anyone looking for brisk action without long meditative stretches
  • Readers who want to avoid graphic violence and sexual content

The decision, in the end, is about whether a journey without a destination is enough. For most readers who try the first VIZBIG book, it will be.

What works

  • Inoue's brushwork makes faces, weather and stillness carry as much as the duels
  • Musashi changes from beast to student across the run, and the change is earned
  • Duels are staged as anatomy and timing, not speed lines, so every cut has weight
  • Supporting cast, from Takuan to Matahachi, have arcs as full as the hero's

What doesn’t

  • The story stops mid-journey; there has been no new chapter since May 2015
  • Long meditative stretches in the later volumes test readers who came for duels
  • Graphic violence and sexual content make it a strictly adult read
EssentialHow we score

The verdict

Vagabond is held back from the very top of the scale by one fact no amount of craft can fix: it has no ending, and may never have one. Everything else argues for it. Inoue turned a familiar national story into a study of violence and self-knowledge, gave its hero a transformation that unfolds at the speed of a real life, and drew it with a care that makes almost any page worth stopping on. The slower later volumes ask for patience, and the violence asks for a strong stomach. What readers get in return is the most beautifully drawn sword story in comics, and a portrait of a young man learning, too slowly and at great cost, what being strong is for.

Quick answers

Is Vagabond worth reading?

Voxizer scores Vagabond (1998) 9.1 out of 10 — essential. Vagabond is held back from the very top of the scale by one fact no amount of craft can fix: it has no ending, and may never have one. Everything else argues for it.

Who will enjoy Vagabond?

Readers who want a historical epic where the fights mean something beyond who wins. Anyone interested in drawing, ink or the craft of comics at its highest level. Fans of slow, character-led storytelling who do not need an ending to enjoy the road.

Who should skip Vagabond?

Readers who need a finished story before committing to 37 volumes. Anyone looking for brisk action without long meditative stretches. Readers who want to avoid graphic violence and sexual content.

What is Vagabond like, in short?

Takehiko Inoue's retelling of Miyamoto Musashi's youth, drawn with a detail and a calm that few comics approach. A story about what strength costs, told through duels that read as physical events rather than choreography. The pace slows deliberately in the later volumes, and readers expecting a fight on every page will notice. Unfinished since 2015, with no confirmed return; read it for the journey, not the destination.

What readers say

Written by Voxizer members and checked by our moderators before they appear.

Written reviews

–

No written reviews yet

Write a review
9–10
0
7–8.5
0
5–6.5
0
3–4.5
0
0–2.5
0

Nobody has reviewed Vagabond yet. Be the first.

All reviews →

Verified sources

Published by the Voxizer editorial team — David Abellán, Ignacio Pineda, Pablo Huguet. Section editor for comics: David Abellán.

Revision history

  1. Published

Scores are revised when the facts behind them change, and the change is recorded here. How we score.