Whiplash · 2014
Whiplash: a jazz drama that plays like a white-knuckle thriller
Whiplash review: Damien Chazelle's drama about a drummer and his abusive teacher, with J.K. Simmons and Miles Teller, is electrifying and unsettling.
Excellent
Editorial score out of 10
Whiplash is a thrilling, intense and unsettling drama about ambition, abuse and the pursuit of greatness. Damien Chazelle's second feature turns the world of a jazz conservatory into a battleground, depicting the relationship between a driven student and his tyrannical teacher with the pace and tension of a thriller. It is powered by two outstanding performances and exceptional editing.
- 8.9
- Editorial score
- #35
- Of 112 movies reviewed
- 2014
- Released
- 9.4
- Best at: Performances
It also raises uncomfortable questions about whether cruelty can produce excellence, and it deliberately refuses to answer them neatly. That ambiguity is what makes it so compelling.
The climactic performance is extraordinary and should be experienced without prior knowledge.
Story
Andrew is a talented but lonely drummer who idolises jazz legends such as Buddy Rich. When Terence Fletcher invites him to join his elite studio band, Andrew believes he has found his chance. He quickly discovers that Fletcher uses humiliation, insults and violence to push his musicians. Andrew is berated for his tempo, pitted against other drummers and forced to practise until his hands bleed.
Rather than breaking him, Fletcher's abuse fuels Andrew's obsession. He ends his relationship with Nicole, a student he has recently started dating, and alienates his supportive father. The story's tension builds as Andrew's physical and mental health deteriorate. Some of the film's dramatic turns, particularly in its later stages, stretch credibility. The narrative is focused and efficient, however, and the power struggle between Andrew and Fletcher remains gripping. The climactic performance is extraordinary and should be experienced without prior knowledge.
Direction and craft
Chazelle's direction is precise and energetic. Sharone Meir's cinematography uses warm, amber tones and tight close-ups, capturing sweat, blood and cymbals in intense detail. The band rehearsals are staged with the tension of combat, and Fletcher's hand gestures become as threatening as any weapon.
Tom Cross's editing is exceptional and won an Academy Award, along with the film's sound mixing. The rapid cuts between drums, faces and instruments create a rhythmic intensity that mirrors the music. The soundtrack features big-band jazz performances, including Hank Levy's composition Whiplash and Duke Ellington's Caravan, performed with thrilling energy. The film's lean running time keeps the momentum high.
Performances
J.K. Simmons is extraordinary as Fletcher. He is funny, charismatic and terrifying, moving from quiet encouragement to explosive rage in an instant. His performance won the Academy Award for Best Supporting Actor, and it is easy to see why. Fletcher is never simply a monster; he believes his methods produce greatness, which makes him more disturbing.
Miles Teller is excellent as Andrew. He performed much of the drumming himself, conveying the physical toll of practice and performance. He makes Andrew arrogant, insecure and driven, a character whose obsession mirrors Fletcher's. Paul Reiser is warm as Andrew's father, and Melissa Benoist is appealing as Nicole, though both roles are relatively thin.
Who it is for
Whiplash is for viewers who enjoy intense character studies, stories about ambition and films with a propulsive, thriller-like energy. Music lovers will appreciate its depiction of performance, although jazz enthusiasts may question its narrow emphasis on speed and technical perfection. Its depiction of emotional abuse and strong language may be distressing for some viewers.
What works
- J.K. Simmons's Fletcher is a ferocious, magnetic and terrifying presence
- Miles Teller convincingly conveys obsession, ambition and physical exhaustion
- Razor-sharp editing gives drumming scenes the tension of action sequences
- A lean running time and propulsive pace leave no wasted moments
What doesn’t
- Jazz musicians have questioned its narrow view of greatness
- Andrew's girlfriend and father are underdeveloped
- Some plot developments strain plausibility for dramatic effect
Head to head
- Craft
- 9.29.4
- Story
- 8.68.0
- Direction
- 9.18.9
- Performances
- 9.48.5
Whiplash edges it by 0.3. See them side by side
The verdict
Whiplash is an electrifying, superbly crafted drama with two career-defining performances and brilliant editing. It won major prizes at Sundance before its awards-season success, and it launched Chazelle's career. A few implausible developments and underwritten supporting characters keep it just below landmark status, but its intensity and provocative themes make it an exceptional film.




