Skip to content

Head to head

1984 vs One Hundred Years of Solitude

Dead level: both score 9.5. What separates them is what they are for, not how good they are.

Cover of 1984
1984

1949 · Masterpiece

  • Telescreens, Newspeak and doublethink remain startlingly precise tools of thought
  • Plain, controlled prose makes the horror feel procedural rather than fantastical
  • The long extract from Goldstein's book stalls the narrative badly
Cover of One Hundred Years of Solitude
  • Marvels are narrated with a deadpan calm that makes them feel entirely real
  • Úrsula Iguarán is an unforgettable centre of gravity across generations
  • Recycled names across generations make a family tree almost essential

Where the gap is

Ideas
10.09.7
Story
9.09.0
Writing
9.19.8
Characters
8.19.1

At a glance

Fact1984One Hundred Years of Solitude
Released8 June 19495 June 1967
AuthorGeorge OrwellGabriel Garcia Marquez
PublisherSecker & WarburgPenguin Random House
Pages328417
GenreSci-Fi · Drama · PoliticsMagical realism · Literary fiction

The two verdicts

1984

1984: Orwell's cold, exact nightmare has lost none of its bite

1984 has flaws a modern editor would flag: an underwritten heroine, a lecture dropped into the thriller and a mood that never lifts. None of them dents its achievement. Few books have given readers such durable language for recognising how power manipulates truth, and fewer still have done it in prose this clear. That near-unmatched influence and enduring precision earn it a place among the landmarks of the form.

Read the full review →

One Hundred Years of Solitude

One Hundred Years of Solitude: magical realism at its most dazzling and humane

One Hundred Years of Solitude is a landmark: inventive, funny, melancholy and politically acute, told in a voice that influenced writers across the globe. Its repeated names and loose structure can test patience, and some of its content has aged uncomfortably, but its imaginative ambition and emotional reach are extraordinary. It deserves its place among the handful of genuinely all-time novels.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.