Skip to content

Head to head

A Silent Voice vs The Apothecary Diaries

Dead level: both score 8.8. What separates them is what they are for, not how good they are.

Cover of A Silent Voice
A Silent Voice

2016 · Excellent

  • Refuses to make redemption quick, tidy or earned by one grand gesture
  • Naoko Yamada's framing of feet, hands and averted eyes says what dialogue cannot
  • Compressing a seven-volume manga leaves some side characters underwritten
Cover of The Apothecary Diaries
The Apothecary Diaries

2023 · Excellent

  • A detective whose motive is professional curiosity rather than conscience
  • Cases built on medicine and household chemistry, explained without condescension
  • The second season slows for court politics and a widening cast of names

Where the gap is

Sound
8.78.7
Story
8.68.6
Animation
9.18.8
Characters
9.29.2

At a glance

FactA Silent VoiceThe Apothecary Diaries
Released17 September 201622 October 2023
StudioKyoto AnimationToho Animation Studio, OLM
DirectorNaoko YamadaNorihiro Naganuma, Akinori Fudesaka
Episodes148 across two seasons, 24 each
GenreDrama · RomanceDrama · Mystery · Historical
Status—Two seasons aired; a third from October 2026

The two verdicts

A Silent Voice

A Silent Voice: a hard, humane film about the long work of making amends

A Silent Voice was widely embraced on release as one of the finest anime films of the 2010s, and that reputation holds. Its occasional melodramatic lurch and the thinness of some supporting arcs keep it just short of the very top tier, but its intelligence about guilt, forgiveness and the slow work of becoming a better person is rare in any medium. The exceptional character writing and Yamada's expressive direction earn it a firm 8.8.

Read the full review →

The Apothecary Diaries

The Apothecary Diaries: a palace mystery that runs on curiosity, not justice

The Apothecary Diaries is the most satisfying episodic mystery anime in years, and almost all of that rests on its heroine. Maomao is written and performed with a consistency that makes the formula work: a case, a symptom, a domestic detail nobody else noticed, and an explanation that treats the audience as capable of following it. The production matches her, with a palace that feels staffed and a score that has more than one idea in it. The second season is the weaker half, diffusing the tight case structure into a serialised political plot that asks for more patience than the first ever did. It remains excellent company, and it earns its place among the best television the medium has produced this decade.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.